Oy Naukri

India Jobs. Read. Talk. Share.

Advertisements

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 23:38:33)

IF U NEED DETAILS U SHOULD REVEAL UR IDENTITY FIRST

SO THAT CANDIDATES COULD TRUST YOU FIRST

AS FROM WHAT WE GATHER FROM ALL YOUR POSTS IS THAT SUCCESS OR FAILURE REALLY CHANGES YOUR VIEWS ABOUT YOURSELF

YOU PREACH WHAT YOU DONT YOURSELF FOLLOW

YOU LIE USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE ONLY TO PURSUADE OTHERS TO FIT YOUR PLANS

FIRST YOU LIED BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE THAT EVERYTHING IS FINE, NO NEED TO WORRY BECAUSE YOU WERE OVER-CONFIDENT THAT YOU WILL PASS THE MAINS EXAM AND YOU HAD FEAR IN MIND THAT ANYONE COULD HARM THE COMPLETION OF RECRUITMENT CYCLE IF CANDIDATES GET TO FEEL THAT SOMETHING IS GOING WRONG...YOU , BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE TRIED TO PULL THE WOOL BEFORE EVERYONE'S EYES...SO THAT NOBODY STANDS IN YOUR WAY....

AS YOUR PLANS FAILED DUE TO MAINS RESULT BEING NEGATIVE...

YOU AT ONCE SHOUTED....INJUSTICE

AND THEN YOU STARTED YOUR PROPAGANDA

YOU DEMANDED TIME TO CREATE A NEW E-MAIL ID JUST TO HIDE YOUR IDENTITY
AND THEN YOU REQUESTED ALL TO SEND THEIR MARKSHEETS TO UR NEWLY CREATED FAKE MAIL ID..

WITHOUT EVEN ASCERTAINING THE FACT THAT HOW MANY OF THE CANDIDATES HAVE POSTED THEIR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION MARKS HERE, YOU AT ONCE GENERALIZED AND CLAIMED THAT

EVERYBODY IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION HAS GOT LESS MARKS...

EVEN AFTER ASKING SO MANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE MERIT AND LOGIC BEHIND YOUR CASE , YOU REPLIED TO NONE, YOU JUST DID THE SAME THING WHAT YOU WERE DOING BEFORE DECLARATION OF RESULT....

THIS TIME TRYING TO PULL THE WOOL OVER THE LOSING CANDIDATES' EYES,

NOT ONCE IT CAME TO YOUR MIND THAT YOU ARE SO OBSESSED WITH YOUR PLANNING THAT YOU HAVE NO CONCERN FOR OTHERS WHOM YOU USED BEFORE AND WHOM YOU ARE PLANNING TO USE NOW...

YOU KNOW THAT YOU ARE NOT GOING TO FILE THIS USELESS WRIT IN YOUR NAME

AND I ALSO KNOW THIS FACT

AND STILL YOU ARE LYING...

YOU ARE MOULDING ALL LOGIC TO SUIT YOUR AGENDA...

YOU KNOW THAT YOUR LOGICS DON'T HAVE MERIT

YOU YOURSELF SAID TODAY THAT YOUR PETITION IS WEAK, BECAUSE THE BASE IS WEAK...

YOU ARE SERIOUSLY JEOPARDIZING THE FUTURE OF SO MANY HERE BY TRYING TO DELAY NEXT NOTIFICATION

AND PLEASE DONT GIVE THIS LOLIPOP TO EVERYONE THAT IT WILL BE FRUITFUL FOR THE NEXT NOTIFICATION...

LET THE PROCESS COMPLETE
LET THE NEXT NOTIFICATION COME
AND IF IT COMES WITH THE SAME INSTRUCTIONS AND RULES, THAT IS THE TIME TO FILE YOUR WRIT...

YOU ARE JUST PLAYING WITH EVERYBODY'S EMOTIONS HERE...EVERYBODY'S LIFE HERE AND ALSO THEIR FUTURE....

REGARDS

AND FRIENDS PLEASE DONT SEND UR DETAILS TO HIS FAKE ID....HE WILL USE YOU AND THEN DITCH YOU..

HE WILL NEVER FILE WRIT IN HIS OWN NAME...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 23:32:52)

KUCHH LOG DAR GAE AUR BAR BAR KAH RAHE H KI APNI MARKSHEET KO DEKH KAR ROTE RAHO AND DON'T DISPATCH IT TO SOMEONE DU
KYO BHAI YE DAR KAISA AAKHIR COMMISSION NE TUMHE QUALIFY KIYA HAI JAB PICHHLE ONE AND HALF YEAR SE INTZAAR HO RAHA TO THODA AUR KAR LO

TUM APNA INTEREST DEKH RAHO HO KUCHH LOG APNA

JISKO JO KARNA HAI KARNE DO BUT DON'T PASS DEROGATORY REMARKS TO EACH OTHR

DU HI NAHI KOI AUR BHI YE KAAM KAR SAKTA HAI

INTERVIEW WALE FOCUS ON INTERVIEW YE CHANCE BAR BAR NHI AATA

DU TYPE APNE CHANCE KE LIYE TRY KARO SO THAT TUM BHI LINE ME LAG JAO

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 22:43:15)

IF U NEED DETAILS U SHOULD REVEAL UR IDENTITY FIRST

SO THAT CANDIDATES COULD TRUST YOU FIRST

AS FROM WHAT WE GATHER FROM ALL YOUR POSTS IS THAT SUCCESS OR FAILURE REALLY CHANGES YOUR VIEWS ABOUT YOURSELF

YOU PREACH WHAT YOU DONT YOURSELF FOLLOW

YOU LIE USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE ONLY TO PURSUADE OTHERS TO FIT YOUR PLANS

FIRST YOU LIED BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE THAT EVERYTHING IS FINE, NO NEED TO WORRY BECAUSE YOU WERE OVER-CONFIDENT THAT YOU WILL PASS THE MAINS EXAM AND YOU HAD FEAR IN MIND THAT ANYONE COULD HARM THE COMPLETION OF RECRUITMENT CYCLE IF CANDIDATES GET TO FEEL THAT SOMETHING IS GOING WRONG...YOU , BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE TRIED TO PULL THE WOOL BEFORE EVERYONE'S EYES...SO THAT NOBODY STANDS IN YOUR WAY....

AS YOUR PLANS FAILED DUE TO MAINS RESULT BEING NEGATIVE...

YOU AT ONCE SHOUTED....INJUSTICE

AND THEN YOU STARTED YOUR PROPAGANDA

YOU DEMANDED TIME TO CREATE A NEW E-MAIL ID JUST TO HIDE YOUR IDENTITY
AND THEN YOU REQUESTED ALL TO SEND THEIR MARKSHEETS TO UR NEWLY CREATED FAKE MAIL ID..

WITHOUT EVEN ASCERTAINING THE FACT THAT HOW MANY OF THE CANDIDATES HAVE POSTED THEIR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION MARKS HERE, YOU AT ONCE GENERALIZED AND CLAIMED THAT

EVERYBODY IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION HAS GOT LESS MARKS...

EVEN AFTER ASKING SO MANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE MERIT AND LOGIC BEHIND YOUR CASE , YOU REPLIED TO NONE, YOU JUST DID THE SAME THING WHAT YOU WERE DOING BEFORE DECLARATION OF RESULT....

THIS TIME TRYING TO PULL THE WOOL OVER THE LOSING CANDIDATES' EYES,

NOT ONCE IT CAME TO YOUR MIND THAT YOU ARE SO OBSESSED WITH YOUR PLANNING THAT YOU HAVE NO CONCERN FOR OTHERS WHOM YOU USED BEFORE AND WHOM YOU ARE PLANNING TO USE NOW...

YOU KNOW THAT YOU ARE NOT GOING TO FILE THIS USELESS WRIT IN YOUR NAME

AND I ALSO KNOW THIS FACT

AND STILL YOU ARE LYING...

YOU ARE MOULDING ALL LOGIC TO SUIT YOUR AGENDA...

YOU KNOW THAT YOUR LOGICS DON'T HAVE MERIT

YOU YOURSELF SAID TODAY THAT YOUR PETITION IS WEAK, BECAUSE THE BASE IS WEAK...

YOU ARE SERIOUSLY JEOPARDIZING THE FUTURE OF SO MANY HERE BY TRYING TO DELAY NEXT NOTIFICATION

AND PLEASE DONT GIVE THIS LOLIPOP TO EVERYONE THAT IT WILL BE FRUITFUL FOR THE NEXT NOTIFICATION...

LET THE PROCESS COMPLETE
LET THE NEXT NOTIFICATION COME
AND IF IT COMES WITH THE SAME INSTRUCTIONS AND RULES, THAT IS THE TIME TO FILE YOUR WRIT...

YOU ARE JUST PLAYING WITH EVERYBODY'S EMOTIONS HERE...EVERYBODY'S LIFE HERE AND ALSO THEIR FUTURE....

REGARDS

AND FRIENDS PLEASE DONT SEND UR DETAILS TO HIS FAKE ID....HE WILL USE YOU AND THEN DITCH YOU..

HE WILL NEVER FILE WRIT IN HIS OWN NAME...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 21:46:16)

hadh hai yaar ye DU dusro ko bda bevkuf samjhta hai. bhai itna bawla koi na hai unknown Id pe bola dia mail kro,or sab kar bhi denge.sabko samjhdaar hai koi dudh peete bache nhi.koi nhi krega bhai swal he nhi uthta.kya pta uska kis trah use krey.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 21:14:40)

ITS A NEW GOVERNMENT

EVERY NEW GOVERNMENT TAKES TIME TO START,

JUST LIKE THE PREVIOUS ONES

IN YOUR OWN WORDS: HPSC IS WORKING OVER-TIME AND WITH UTMOST SINCERETY...

IT CAN EASILY COMPLETE THE NEXT RECRUITMENT CYCLE BY THIS SAME TIME NEXT YEAR...

YOU ARE AGAIN DOING THE SAME THING...PULLING WOOL BEFORE EVERYONE'S EYES...

WHAT ABOUT YOUR IDENTITY?

YOU KNOW AND I KNOW YOU ARE JUST USING OTHERS

YOU WILL NOT FILE THE WRIT IN YOUR OWN NAME...
NEVER...

NOW YOU WILL ASK WHAT IT HAS TO DO WITH UR IDENTITY?

BECAUSE YOU ARE ASKING FOR OTHER CANDIDATES' DETAILS ON YOUR FAKE ID..

YOU ARE SO SCARED THAT NOW YOU ARE WRITING ANONYMOUSLY

AND YOU ALSO KNOW THAT WHOEVER'S NAME POPS UP IN THAT WRIT MAY HAVE TO FACE THE BRUNT OF HPSC AND THE GOVERNMENT...

REGARDS

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 21:10:41)

ITS A NEW GOVERNMENT

EVERY NEW GOVERNMENT TAKES TIME TO START,

JUST LIKE THE PREVIOUS ONES

IN YOUR OWN WORDS: HPSC IS WORKING OVER-TIME AND WITH UTMOST SINCERETY...

IT CAN EASILY COMPLETE THE NEXT RECRUITMENT CYCLE BY THIS SAME TIME NEXT YEAR...

YOU ARE AGAIN DOING THE SAME THING...PULLING WOOL BEFORE EVERYONE'S EYES...

WHAT ABOUT YOUR IDENTITY?

YOU KNOW AND I KNOW YOU ARE JUST USING OTHERS

YOU WILL NOT FILE THE WRIT IN YOUR OWN NAME...
NEVER...

NOW YOU WILL ASK WHAT IT HAS TO DO WITH UR IDENTITY?

BECAUSE YOU ARE ASKING FOR OTHER CANDIDATES' DETAILS ON YOUR FAKE ID..

YOU ARE SO SCARED THAT NOW YOU ARE WRITING ANONYMOUSLY

AND YOU ALSO KNOW THAT WHOEVER'S NAME POPS UP IN THAT WRIT MAY HAVE TO FEAR THE BRUNT OF HPSC AND THE GOVERNMENT...

REGARDS

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 21:05:13)

Let's address the said next notification which has become talk of the town recently.Expectations and assumptions are nothing but mother of all f-ups in life.
Since last election that is later half of 2014 the HPSC has come up with atleast 8 notification, advertising 10-12 jobs in altogether.Unfortunately,commission has not been able to complete more than one process till date.Recruitment for Hcs jb branch was completed last year and Hcs exe and asst professor recruitment is still in process.
Now,I maybe naive but those already advertised post are to be filled.Syllabus has been declared implying preliminary test followed by interview is in order.
Food for thought,isn't?
The next round of HCS exe is going to take a while.Even if they notify it this year,surely nothing would be done in its respect before the latter half of the next year.Simply and practically cause their ain't no time in HPSC schedule as of this moment.
FYI-Asst professor recruitment is to take at least three more months.No other recruitment test would be conducted in the said time frame.
If you Cant see Forest for the trees,my friends.No,one can help you

Re:

Posted by Hcs Baba, (2016-07-16 21:03:44)

bhai kyun iss ek bande ki le rakhi h.. jo iska man h karann dyo naa.. thaare jo jee me h vo karlyo...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 21:02:39)

Let's address the said next notification which has become talk of the town recently.Expectations and assumptions are nothing but mother of all f-ups in life.
Since last election that is later half of 2014 the HPSC has come up with atleast 8 notification, advertising 10-12 jobs in altogether.Unfortunately,commission has not been able to complete more than one process till date.Recruitment for Hcs jb branch was completed last year and Hcs exe and asst professor recruitment is still in process.
Now,I maybe naive but those already advertised post are to be filled.Syllabus has been declared implying preliminary test followed by interview is in order.
Food for thought,isn't?
The next round of HCS exe is going to take a while.Even if they notify it this year,surely nothing would be done in its respect before the latter half of the next year.Simply and practically cause their ain't no time in HPSC schedule as of this moment.
FYI-Asst professor recruitment is to take at least three more months.No other recruitment test would be conducted in the said time frame.
If you Cant see Forest for the trees,my friends.No,one can help you

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 21:01:14)

IF U NEED DETAILS U SHOULD REVEAL UR IDENTITY FIRST

SO THAT CANDIDATES COULD TRUST YOU FIRST

AS FROM WHAT WE GATHER FROM ALL YOUR POSTS IS THAT SUCCESS OR FAILURE REALLY CHANGES YOUR VIEWS ABOUT YOURSELF

YOU PREACH WHAT YOU DONT YOURSELF FOLLOW

YOU LIE USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE ONLY TO PURSUADE OTHERS TO FIT YOUR PLANS

FIRST YOU LIED BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE THAT EVERYTHING IS FINE, NO NEED TO WORRY BECAUSE YOU WERE OVER-CONFIDENT THAT YOU WILL PASS THE MAINS EXAM AND YOU HAD FEAR IN MIND THAT ANYONE COULD HARM THE COMPLETION OF RECRUITMENT CYCLE IF CANDIDATES GET TO FEEL THAT SOMETHING IS GOING WRONG...YOU , BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE TRIED TO PULL THE WOOL BEFORE EVERYONE'S EYES...SO THAT NOBODY STANDS IN YOUR WAY....

AS YOUR PLANS FAILED DUE TO MAINS RESULT BEING NEGATIVE...

YOU AT ONCE SHOUTED....INJUSTICE

AND THEN YOU STARTED YOUR PROPAGANDA

YOU DEMANDED TIME TO CREATE A NEW E-MAIL ID JUST TO HIDE YOUR IDENTITY
AND THEN YOU REQUESTED ALL TO SEND THEIR MARKSHEETS TO UR NEWLY CREATED FAKE MAIL ID..

WITHOUT EVEN ASCERTAINING THE FACT THAT HOW MANY OF THE CANDIDATES HAVE POSTED THEIR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION MARKS HERE, YOU AT ONCE GENERALIZED AND CLAIMED THAT

EVERYBODY IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION HAS GOT LESS MARKS...

EVEN AFTER ASKING SO MANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE MERIT AND LOGIC BEHIND YOUR CASE , YOU REPLIED TO NONE, YOU JUST DID THE SAME THING WHAT YOU WERE DOING BEFORE DECLARATION OF RESULT....

THIS TIME TRYING TO PULL THE WOOL OVER THE LOSING CANDIDATES' EYES,

NOT ONCE IT CAME TO YOUR MIND THAT YOU ARE SO OBSESSED WITH YOUR PLANNING THAT YOU HAVE NO CONCERN FOR OTHERS WHOM YOU USED BEFORE AND WHOM YOU ARE PLANNING TO USE NOW...

YOU KNOW THAT YOU ARE NOT GOING TO FILE THIS USELESS WRIT IN YOUR NAME

AND I ALSO KNOW THIS FACT

AND STILL YOU ARE LYING...

YOU ARE MOULDING ALL LOGIC TO SUIT YOUR AGENDA...

YOU KNOW THAT YOUR LOGICS DON'T HAVE MERIT

YOU YOURSELF SAID TODAY THAT YOUR PETITION IS WEAK, BECAUSE THE BASE IS WEAK...

YOU ARE SERIOUSLY JEOPARDIZING THE FUTURE OF SO MANY HERE BY TRYING TO DELAY NEXT NOTIFICATION

AND PLEASE DONT GIVE THIS LOLIPOP TO EVERYONE THAT IT WILL BE FRUITFUL FOR THE NEXT NOTIFICATION...

LET THE PROCESS COMPLETE
LET THE NEXT NOTIFICATION COME
AND IF IT COMES WITH THE SAME INSTRUCTIONS AND RULES, THAT IS THE TIME TO FILE YOUR WRIT...

YOU ARE JUST PLAYING WITH EVERYBODY'S EMOTIONS HERE...EVERYBODY'S LIFE HERE AND ALSO THEIR FUTURE....

REGARDS

AND FRIENDS PLEASE DONT SEND UR DETAILS TO HIS FAKE ID....HE WILL USE YOU AND THEN DITCH YOU..

HE WILL NEVER FILE WRIT IN HIS OWN NAME...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 20:57:24)

Let's address the said next notification which has become talk of the town recently.Expectations and assumptions are nothing but mother of all f-ups in life.
Since last election that is later half of 2014 the HPSC has come up with atleast 8 notification, advertising 10-12 jobs in altogether.Unfortunately,commission has not been able to complete more than one process till date.Recruitment for Hcs jb branch was completed last year and Hcs exe and asst professor recruitment is still in process.
Now,I maybe naive but those already advertised post are to be filled.Syllabus has been declared implying preliminary test followed by interview is in order.
Food for thought,isn't?
The next round of HCS exe is going to take a while.Even if they notify it this year,surely nothing would be done in its respect before the latter half of the next year.Simply and practically cause their ain't no time in HPSC schedule as of this moment.
FYI-Asst professor recruitment is to take at least three more months.No other recruitment test would be conducted in the said time frame.
If you Cant see Forest for the trees,my friends.No,one can help you

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 20:38:58)

IF U NEED DETAILS U SHOULD REVEAL UR IDENTITY FIRST

SO THAT CANDIDATES COULD TRUST YOU FIRST

AS FROM WHAT WE GATHER FROM ALL YOUR POSTS IS THAT SUCCESS OR FAILURE REALLY CHANGES YOUR VIEWS ABOUT YOURSELF

YOU PREACH WHAT YOU DONT YOURSELF FOLLOW

YOU LIE USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE ONLY TO PURSUADE OTHERS TO FIT YOUR PLANS

FIRST YOU LIED BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE THAT EVERYTHING IS FINE, NO NEED TO WORRY BECAUSE YOU WERE OVER-CONFIDENT THAT YOU WILL PASS THE MAINS EXAM AND YOU HAD FEAR IN MIND THAT ANYONE COULD HARM THE COMPLETION OF RECRUITMENT CYCLE IF CANDIDATES GET TO FEEL THAT SOMETHING IS GOING WRONG...YOU , BY USING YOUR FLOWERY LANGUAGE TRIED TO PULL THE WOOL BEFORE EVERYONE'S EYES...SO THAT NOBODY STANDS IN YOUR WAY....

AS YOUR PLANS FAILED DUE TO MAINS RESULT BEING NEGATIVE...

YOU AT ONCE SHOUTED....INJUSTICE

AND THEN YOU STARTED YOUR PROPAGANDA

YOU DEMANDED TIME TO CREATE A NEW E-MAIL ID JUST TO HIDE YOUR IDENTITY
AND THEN YOU REQUESTED ALL TO SEND THEIR MARKSHEETS TO UR NEWLY CREATED FAKE MAIL ID..

WITHOUT EVEN ASCERTAINING THE FACT THAT HOW MANY OF THE CANDIDATES HAVE POSTED THEIR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION MARKS HERE, YOU AT ONCE GENERALIZED AND CLAIMED THAT

EVERYBODY IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION HAS GOT LESS MARKS...

EVEN AFTER ASKING SO MANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE MERIT AND LOGIC BEHIND YOUR CASE , YOU REPLIED TO NONE, YOU JUST DID THE SAME THING WHAT YOU WERE DOING BEFORE DECLARATION OF RESULT....

THIS TIME TRYING TO PULL THE WOOL OVER THE LOSING CANDIDATES' EYES,

NOT ONCE IT CAME TO YOUR MIND THAT YOU ARE SO OBSESSED WITH YOUR PLANNING THAT YOU HAVE NO CONCERN FOR OTHERS WHOM YOU USED BEFORE AND WHOM YOU ARE PLANNING TO USE NOW...

YOU KNOW THAT YOU ARE NOT GOING TO FILE THIS USELESS WRIT IN YOUR NAME

AND I ALSO KNOW THIS FACT

AND STILL YOU ARE LYING...

YOU ARE MOULDING ALL LOGIC TO SUIT YOUR AGENDA...

YOU KNOW THAT YOUR LOGICS DON'T HAVE MERIT

YOU YOURSELF SAID TODAY THAT YOUR PETITION IS WEAK, BECAUSE THE BASE IS WEAK...

YOU ARE SERIOUSLY JEOPARDIZING THE FUTURE OF SO MANY HERE BY TRYING TO DELAY NEXT NOTIFICATION

AND PLEASE DONT GIVE THIS LOLIPOP TO EVERYONE THAT IT WILL BE FRUITFUL FOR THE NEXT NOTIFICATION...

LET THE PROCESS COMPLETE
LET THE NEXT NOTIFICATION COME
AND IF IT COMES WITH THE SAME INSTRUCTIONS AND RULES, THAT IS THE TIME TO FILE YOUR WRIT...

YOU ARE JUST PLAYING WITH EVERYBODY'S EMOTIONS HERE...EVERYBODY'S LIFE HERE AND ALSO THEIR FUTURE....

REGARDS

AND FRIENDS PLEASE DONT SEND UR DETAILS TO HIS FAKE ID....HE WILL USE YOU AND THEN DITCH YOU..

HE WILL NEVER FILE WRIT IN HIS OWN NAME...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 20:29:22)

totally agree with you shrutI.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 20:27:26)

hi all,

I am also a hcs aspirant as all of you. I was following this blog and du's views from a long time. I had a lot of respect for du. but sorry to say after mains results, split personality of du is giving me shocks. from a move on,accept destiny,life beyond hcs to frustrated,unmanageable and self obsessed person.I also could not clear mains and hoping for next attempt.these govt. jobs exams take so long already and now pepole are trying to delay next notification unnecessarily. nothing can happen by these writs.every sensible person is aware of this.

shruti

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:52:51)

well i cant blame u....common sense is so uncommon these days.. comparing with Ekta kapoor serial is really funny. reg HC judges, I really dont doubt their caliber. and i would love if u pls explain how a single case is enough in this case... and how by including other's marks as sample to this plea to strengthen our argument( this is what it seems) will actually weaken this case..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:40:33)

Rofl... it's not ekta kapoor serial, it's honourable court
if your case has any base...then you don't need to highlight, even single candidate is more than enough,
Judges are learned and experienced persons.....nos. can't influence them.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:36:36)

Re: @ HCS selection
Posted by DU, (2016-05-15 16:51:35)
Hi

These are my private views and expressed here to waylaying the anxiety that is been growing up among all of us. In no way these are to belittle anyone's efforts and hopes with this exam process. If someone is not agree with this viewpoint then reject them but it's not a personal level comment.

As word of wisdom I like to tell you all that there is nothing to fear about HCS exam or for that matter any other test of like variety. Why I would say this, as because everyone of us already know the consequences- either pass or fail. There couldn't be any different conclusion and hence there shouldn't be any room for fear even. And despite the fact that your exam went well there could be 50 more facts which could simultaneously go against your selection rendering into a negative result like culling of your optional etc. Thus it is neither a test of competence especially in light of no scaling and no level playing field nor it is something that most of us have made as sole purpose of life (though we must have strong feelings for being clear but I'm pretty sure Hcs is not something for which ppl sit back and prepare for years like in IAS).

Hence be prepared about either of the two consequences like if pass then prepare well for interview or if negative then next round of PT with changed pattern, if you're still keen on taking exam.

And speaking rationally, ball is now out of your court, whether you worry and feel anxious or be calm and productive, it won't change the consequences as its sealed off on last day of your mains paper.

So be calm and composed and believe in yourself- success or failure shouldn't change your views about yourself.

Regards

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:28:57)

or yeh material fact ja aapne likha hai ..that fact is being hidden by HPSC by not displaying marks of candidates online... so much for transparency.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:26:35)

we need others marksheet to highlight the case only....ofcourse HPSC will provide the details later on... common sense dost...common sense.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:24:48)

interesting ... now anyone who is writing against the hpsc is DU...well i had written that post and i m not DU.. and by the way ..if u think that process is so fair then why are u so concerned.. let DU do what he wants to do...and contrary to ur perception, the junta here is not stupid . they will do whatever they feel right,just and fair..irrespective of you and your belief..i dont have any intention to hurt ur feeling but it is interesting that ppl are writing against sending DMCs as if this is a pseudo criminal activity..
this uneasiness on ur part is the glimmer of future and hope for these slaughtered candidates

reg

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:21:16)

Why you are begging candidates for their mark sheets?

If you are so positive that ur case has material facts worth pursuing?

you can just file the writ in your name,HPSC will provide all the details you need, it has to...

you need other's marksheets because you want to hide your own identity and use others as puppets....by filling in their names. ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 19:11:42)

Same language, same words , same style

DU anonymous ban ke khud ko defend kar raha hai...

BTW I have just said very logical things and supported them with facts....

No personal hatred with anyone..

Jab koi case banta hi nahi aur koi logon ko bewakuf banaye ga to mai bhi apna farz samajhta hun ki logon ko kisi ki jhoothi baaton mei aur bahkavey mei aane se rokun....

DU ki puraani posts padh ke sab samajh aa gaya mujhe to ki uski pahle kya planning thi, ab kya planning hai,

Aur new e-mail id create kar ke logon se details le kar kya karne ki soch raha hai....

Bhaiyon apni personal details kisi ko mat dena...

Jo khud ki identity reveal nahi kar raha usse koi detail deni bhi nahi chahiye....

It's called common sense DU...

Regards

Re: @DU and all

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 18:32:03)

Hi
it is really a lie that 50% are from pubAd in interviewee grp... the no is very less. further, ppl with pubAD who have qualified for interviewee ought to have a glucose subject(Sciences subjects, LAW). what about the combination of PUBAD/HIST/GEOG/SOCIO.....i seriously doubt a lot of candidates will be from these combination....anyways it is DUs right to go for writ... and ppl who feel that the marking patterns is arbitrary and unjust,,, i appeal to them to forward the copy of their DMC to him... its a blatant lie that DU can file a writ on others name.... he need to strengthen the case.. more the DMCs to show.. better the chance.. i have forwarded mine ..
so pls ..dont simply read the blog and rue your luck and the failed chance... and the impression that HPSC can do anything....its is not .. we need to highlight the issue at hand.. ppl who have been selected for interview will always be against such moves because most of them are there beacuse of this bloody arbitrary marking patterns...so dont listen to them.
I appeal to all my friends to kindly forward the DMCs .. this is for our own good and if someone is taking initiative to fight this bloody injustice.. the least we can do is to forward him/her our DMCs..
i seriously believe that this is the only chance in this cycle of recruitment.. otherwise keep waiting for next cycle.. same thing will happen....there is no hope for these subjects... lets us ask some questions to HPSC thru HC. scaling is not there but who is stopping hpsc from moderation and compensate for examiner/ subject variability.. that should be our target...

so pls forward ur copy and pray for the best

reg

Re:

Posted by THIRD AND FINAL, (2016-07-16 17:25:40)

BIZZARE....

Re: mains question paper

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 16:49:39)

dear du, qaz, yash, adi and other friends
could you please upload the question paper. plzz

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 16:33:46)

Same language, same words , same style

DU anonymous ban ke khud ko defend kar raha hai...

BTW I have just said very logical things and supported them with facts....

No personal hatred with anyone..

Jab koi case banta hi nahi aur koi logon ko bewakuf banaye ga to mai bhi apna farz samajhta hun ki logon ko kisi ki jhoothi baaton mei aur bahkavey mei aane se rokun....

DU ki puraani posts padh ke sab samajh aa gaya mujhe to ki uski pahle kya planning thi, ab kya planning hai,

Aur new e-mail id create kar ke logon se details le kar kya karne ki soch raha hai....

Bhaiyon apni personal details kisi ko mat dena...

Jo khud ki identity reveal nahi kar raha usse koi detail deni bhi nahi chahiye....

It's called common sense DU...

Regards

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 15:37:18)

There are more than 50% candidates IN with public administration...

It could be even 70%...and maybe above that too...

The case will not stand...

Re:

Posted by qaz, (2016-07-16 15:31:42)

Jis hisaab se marks diye hain chuityaap he hai waise

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 15:25:13)

So,what's your basic plan?.By bad mouthing DU you are going to reverse the thought process of an unsuccessful candidate in not joining him in the writ.When it can be the last glimmer of hope for one.
Are you proposing that one should abstain from taking a legal step just cause of your personal hatred for DU?
No,sir,I wouldn't be deviated,nor would I be demoralised by your blatant abrasive propaganda.I will fight for my right cause I think my position to be correct and righteous.I am sure you are too in your own view.
This is a democracy and everyone is entitled to approach the judiciary if ones right is violated.Has DU benefitted from the existing system?Surely he has but he also lost ground and lost the proper exe post.Now that is an objective appreciation of the in hand situation.

What does one aspirant want?....does he want to revolt against the very authority which is going to conduct the selection procedure?,I suppose not...He wants to be selected and appointed but when he is denied and that too unfairly he is not only morally entitled but also lawfully to fight for his rights.
Should I not do the same?..Put yourself in my position and ask yourself what would you have done?

What's the worst outcome?..Interviews might get delayed..Your loss isn't an irrepairable loss if that happens but my would be,if my stand is lawfully correct according to the court.
Lastly,why don't you file a suit against the government first for delaying the mains for more than one and half a year?..That should be done first before you file a suit against someone fighting the system itself..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 14:58:52)

according to me,

kuchh aisa hone wala hai

people willing to apply for writ:judge sahab injustice h fail kr dia pub ad walo ko.

Judge : sabko?

people : na ji selected ko target kia.

Judge : R u insane?

people :(trying to use influential language to manipulate court) there should be scaling in all subjects as upsc and other states are following this.

Judge : Was this mentioned in instructions when you filled the form that scaling will be done?

people : no

Judge : Haven't you read the instructions at that time?

people : Yes we did

Judge : ok,you cleared prelims,you had no problems....you took mains....no problems. ..waiting for positive results...no problems,you FLUNKED......judge sahib injustice.(sorry for using this language )

Judge : what do you want?

people:stay, rechecking and direct entry to interview.

Judge: Really you think this is a joke,court is to help people, genuine people with genuine issues (not to entertain fools.)

people : we are not fools...few of us are working in hcs allied services.

Judge : did u get this job by following scaling method?

people : no

Judge : hmmmmm

Judgement : it is stated that petitioners have misled this honourable court.this petition is motivated and vexatious to serve personal interest of the petitioner who has not disclosed that he is working and was chosen by same procedure and now trying to defame accuracy and authenticity of the constitutional body like HPSC. This Court warns the petitioners for wasting the time of the hon'be Court and for trying to abuse the process of selection by HPSC at this stage and effective steps should be taken to cure this abuse on the basis of monetary and non monetary directions by court.

iss sab mey abhi HPSC ke jawab , shortlisted candidates ki UPSC profiles and yahan ki DU ki result aane se pahle ki posts with IP addresses adduce kar lo....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 14:02:38)

Ye jo only question worth asking bataya gaya hai

Ye stage hi nahi hai ye question puchhne ki

HPSC advertisement instructions jab padhi nahi thi kya, that was the stage to do this, uske baad 2 years tak bhi dhyan nahi aaya kya,,

Well dhyan to tha

DU ki pichhli posts bata rahi hain

But he was hopeful to get benefit of that...last last time he got benefited

This is not the stage to file this case, as it was clearly mentioned in the instructions and you signed the form that you have read the instructions and you accept and will abide by them...

Even if you haven't read...it is understood

Par DU ne to padhi thi

Aur unka hawala dekar hi sabko chup kara diya tha. ..!!

Ab kuch nahi ho sakta....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 13:52:42)

DU ne ek-do ko bali ka bakra banane k liye tayyar kar liya hai

He will not file in his own name

So that everyone keeps guessing ki in ek-do mei se koi DU hai

He will be behind curtains

I assure everyone that I am 100% correct

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 13:36:51)

result aane se pahle

according to DU, this time HPSC has shown utmost sincerity and fairness.

result aane ke baad

according to DU, Injustice ho gaya

result se pahle, HPSC ke rules mei likha hai, clear from day one,since first exam of HCS ki scaling nahi adopt karegi HPSC, iss stage pe kuch nahi ho sakta



result k baad ,
injustice ho gaya

Re: @Du

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 13:23:18)

sahi h bhai, kuch haath lage na lage, kosish toh banti hi h, some people who are selected understand them more superior, what to say them?

Re: @ locus standi

Posted by DU, (2016-07-16 13:04:49)

Hi

Please try and understand this case is not for my own paper but it's because of simple fact that HPSC is not adopting normal fair standard practises to reduce the vagarities of subjective paper.

I'll pray that last time too hpsc denied is proper dealing for us and hence we landed up in allied rather than proper.

Now we have two three more friends who are joining the petition as original petitioners and we are filing it jointly. It will be having an effect of PIL only due to injury to most of candidates of humanities.

Only thing worth asking is how HPSc is equating humanities and science Optionals ?

Why it is not doing its duty to do some scaling when UPSC and other public service commissions do the same ?

One more thing I'm sorry to say this but surely interviews of HCS are to be postponed as this will also be prayer that till some sort of scaling is done it should be stayed.

Regards

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 11:38:34)

He is not getting any response

He is bluffing...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-16 11:36:56)

Guys he is never going to file writ in his own name....

Think before giving your personal information to anyone who didn't even reveal his identity and demanded time for posting his e-mail id because he had to create a new one ....

He will use anyone of your names to file writ...

Because he cannot file writ as he is chosen and in job through the same process and getting the same benefit against which he is now planning to file writ....

Re: @ update duonlinehry@gmail.com

Posted by D.U., (2016-07-16 11:01:32)

Hi

Friends I am getting good responses from you people on mail please continue sending more.

Though there are not high hopes from petitions but at least through court case we will put up a spirited attack on grave injustice of lack of scaling.

I request all those like qaz, third and final etc to send their marksheets please on this mail id duonlinehry@gmail.com

I am again and again saying that please understand we are not against anyone here but our fight is with the system.

I request only for your marksheets and nothing else and that too only to impress the court that injustice is real and apparent primafacia which demands intervention.

Remember guys if not this time than it will keep on continuing forever and will hurt all of us except lucky 30 HCS Exe of this batch.

I urge all of you to send marksheet not just marks as we have to attach them in writ as evidence at duonlinehry@gmail.com

We have taken time to carefully study the precedents of this nature and we will seek urgent intervention from court in this regard.

duonlinehry@gmail.com

Regards

Re: number dalo apne apne aur shanti banaye rakho

Posted by Gopal , (2016-07-16 09:05:44)

bhai log apne apne number to dalo..cut off ka andaza to lage..case vale chutiyape karte rehna.case karna hai to karo zyada shor na machao.and Ajay is right that these litigations are not good as I know for sure that checking has been fair.a friend has given intw upsc thrice.and has no connections figures in the list.and I know 2 more such deserving candidates.

Re: @Ajay

Posted by VI, (2016-07-15 19:50:58)

I congratulate u on ur success. but u should not forget the toil of others.. as fas as i know a lot of u are sitting in interview not on the basis of ur presumptive talents in the hcs mains but simply due to blatant carelessness of HPSC marking pattern. there are lot of UPSC interviewee/mains appeared candidates who even failed Pubad . a lot of them are in 60s.. so u says that they are not as talented as u r.
So lets be pragmatic ... dont belittle others.. if u have interview call ..prepare for it ...and thanks ur stars/ GOD/ Allah whatever
reg

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 19:38:54)

Hi, I am Ajay from Gurgaon, I have been reading here that people are planning to apply for baseless,worthless,fruitless and unnecessary writ just to satisfy their frustration and ego thinking this may result in delay of final result.because nothing more can happen in this case.so my lawyer friend suggested us that we can file a case against people who apply for such useless writ and waste time of honorable court and cause mental harrasment to selected candidates.I have details of 41 people who are in for interview along with me.I have contacted these people personally with the help of my friends and fb groups.Reasons to take this extreme step:
1)Few people think that legal cases, HPSC and Hon'ble High Court can be easily manipulated to suit their whims and fancies. They make a mockery of the system.
2)They can not accept that other people can do better than them,they should understand that selected candidates did not pass just like that. There are 16 candidates who took UPSC interviews, some of us twice, and other 9 who appeared in UPSC mains.
3) We have toiled hard enough to crack these exams and we will not let anyone come in our way just because some guy thinks he is more deserving. The real test of your worth was the exam which you have not been able to pass.
4) Some of us have spent many years preparing, taking interviews, again and again preparing, passing Mains , again preparing for interviews. Don't think the world is only what you have seen, it's even beyond that and everyone has had it's share in it...be it pain or suffering.
5) And I don't need anyone else's help , 41 interviewees are more than enough to deal with this stupid writ.

Ajay

Re: ye rahi link

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 19:25:31)

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chandigarh/Category-cancelled-candidate-drags-HPSC-to-court/articleshow/53218241.cms

Ab jahan tak i knw result 8 October tak nahin aaega as Justice Dhindsa is hearing d case.
He is always in d favour of students atleast stay to lagva dega.

Re: case filled

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 19:22:17)

sab DU ke piche pade hain or udhar hisar ke launde ne case daal dia hpsc pe.
8 october is next hearing.
Candidate challenged the SBC quota as it was cancelled by hpsc on HC order and as a result hpsc cancelled d candidature of all d sbc people.
Verified it from HC itself

Re: @DU @others @yash

Posted by Rakesh, (2016-07-15 18:33:40)

You all are same whether selected or not people are asking you constantly to upload or share Mains Paper....I request you last time please share with me on my WhatsApp number 9779694188.

Re: @ reply

Posted by DU, (2016-07-15 17:42:49)

Hi

Again simple things:-

1. I never said anything to anyone who wanted to file case against HPSC last time too as only wearer knows where shoe bites. Like you who have got interview call finds its fair that HPSC doesn't do scaling and we outside of this finds it unfair.

2. Last time I was also on receiving end due to lack of scaling as it let me down in a way that I didn't get HCS Exe due to culling of geography.

3. I'm not asking for any money from anyone nor I'm asking anyone to think of me as some sort of revolutionary. It's just against the injustice done by commission and that's it.

4. My criticism and questions on my integrity are just because u feel that if this injustice is fought in court your interview might be delayed. And those who say I'm bad guy than please realise I'm like u. You are defending your interview call and I'm defending my right to have a fair chance. That's it.

5. What does my real identity has anything to do it ? Those who are "praising" me should also disclose their identity and tell us why they have problem with court case.

I'm getting good response on my mail id so friends please keep sending your mark sheets. This is only way we can force HPSC to alter the discrepancy in lack of scaling.

As and when you receive marks send it by scanning (blur the address part) as we have to take print out and adduce it in writ to show discrepancy in marks.

This battle is for all those who feel they been cheated by HPSC due to low score in optionals.

ID is duonlinehry@gmail.com

Regards

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 17:29:43)

Ek baat pakki hai

Is DU ka to dubaara number bilkul nahi padega

Apne aap ko shaana samajh raha hai?!!

Jab scaling nahi thi tab sifarish karva ke select ho gaya (he must be having affiliations with hooda)

Abki baar number nahi pada to isko scaling chahiye....

Tera to bilkul nahi hoga

Beshak kitna hi zor laga le

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 17:21:16)

Just one thing

If u r so true that u will file the writ in ur name

Than just reveal ur identity first

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 17:16:59)

Where were you at the time of filling form for 2014 prelims?

You had knowledge that in HPSC rules it has mentioned that it doesn't do scaling operations (u mentioned in posts)

So because u didn't get call its unfair

If u had, like in earlier attemt, Than it's ok....no need was there to file writ then....

He is befooling everyone like he was doing earlier. ...

If he files in his own name, Court will first ask him where were you when you got selected last time, was it fair than and unfair now?!!!

And if it was unfair then, why didn't u file writ then???

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 17:12:05)

Exactly

Baat self interest ki nahi h... aur koi bhi writ daal raha hota to mujhe samajh aa jaati baat. And I favour scaling in principle... (though I've got a call this time around with pub Ad)

Yaha baat integrity ki h... congruency of Thought Speech and Action... सत्यनिष्ठा।

पहले ज्यादा बड़ी बड़ी हांक दी और अब defend नहीं हो पा रहा सब।

एक सवाल का जवाब नही दिया DU बाबा ने, ये हक़ की लड़ाई पिछली बार क्यों नहीं लड़ी गयी?

Re: @all @DU

Posted by Yo Yo Choti Singh, (2016-07-15 17:04:03)

What the hell is this yrrrrr :(

Waited 5 days to comment here..just to be sure WHY I WAS REJECTED !!.. Now I know why..

PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION.. bc ksuti leli.. 58 marks !!!...was 100% sure of >120-130 score.. best paper of My cse life..and they ruined it by culling !!.. Each and Every question was attempted in Bestest possible manner by me IMO..bcz 3 of 30 markers were I already have practiced and have model answers for same from a ALL INDIA 3 TIMES PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION GOLD MEDALIST TEACHER !!..rest also after reading pub adm for 3 yrs regoursly i have made a quite good command ..I am saying this with so much confidence because i know how much well i written it !!..i know people will give gyaan on my knowledge but who cares..this is sheer frustration and a ridiculous thing by hpsc..2012 se upsc le rhi h or ab hpsc ne.. Don't think I need to attempt HPSC again :( feeling extremely LOW after this DISCRIMINATION .. Will definitely sue hpsc and one day show my Answer sheet here one day if I get..I can still tell what i wrote in each question yrrr...seriously It's totally Ridiculous ..Shame HPSC :( :(

Re: @Category Drags HPSC, DU ors

Posted by Adi, (2016-07-15 17:00:57)

Baat self interest ki nahi h... aur koi bhi writ daal raha hota to mujhe samajh aa jaati baat. And I favour scaling in principle... (though I've got a call this time around with pub Ad)

Yaha baat integrity ki h... congruency of Thought Speech and Action... सत्यनिष्ठा।

पहले ज्यादा बड़ी बड़ी हांक दी और अब defend नहीं हो पा रहा सब।

एक सवाल का जवाब नही दिया DU बाबा ने, ये हक़ की लड़ाई पिछली बार क्यों नहीं लड़ी गयी?

Re: Category cancelled, candidate drags HPSC to court

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 16:28:24)

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chandigarh/Category-cancelled-candidate-drags-HPSC-to-court/articleshow/53218241.cms

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 15:11:05)

Re: @ HCS selection
Posted by DU, (2016-05-15 16:51:35)
Hi

These are my private views and expressed here to waylaying the anxiety that is been growing up among all of us. In no way these are to belittle anyone's efforts and hopes with this exam process. If someone is not agree with this viewpoint then reject them but it's not a personal level comment.

As word of wisdom I like to tell you all that there is nothing to fear about HCS exam or for that matter any other test of like variety. Why I would say this, as because everyone of us already know the consequences- either pass or fail. There couldn't be any different conclusion and hence there shouldn't be any room for fear even. And despite the fact that your exam went well there could be 50 more facts which could simultaneously go against your selection rendering into a negative result like culling of your optional etc. Thus it is neither a test of competence especially in light of no scaling and no level playing field nor it is something that most of us have made as sole purpose of life (though we must have strong feelings for being clear but I'm pretty sure Hcs is not something for which ppl sit back and prepare for years like in IAS).

Hence be prepared about either of the two consequences like if pass then prepare well for interview or if negative then next round of PT with changed pattern, if you're still keen on taking exam.

And speaking rationally, ball is now out of your court, whether you worry and feel anxious or be calm and productive, it won't change the consequences as its sealed off on last day of your mains paper.

So be calm and composed and believe in yourself- success or failure shouldn't change your views about yourself.

Regards

Re: @Du

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 14:56:03)

i do not understand one thing, how can he be wrong, if he did not do it last time, after all yahan sab apna interest hi dekhenge, if you had not selected, tum b du ki praise kar rahe hote iss boldness k liye.

DU bhai you are right, please proceed, i have already sent my marks sheet to your given id.

but remember it, there are lot of obstacles on this path, like you said those persons got their dues after 12 long years.

But, those awaiting the next notification even cannot think how useful it would be for them also.

chahe tum ye apne kar rahe ho, phir b main tumhe salute karta hu, jisne starting main hi clarifiy kar diya, i want nothing from you except your marksheet.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 14:04:24)

Just one plain question again....why did not you ask all ur questions before ? scaling was not done last time when you got a job . DU wins... everything is perfect, DU loose .... it's INJUSTICE.

Re: @ just one logical question

Posted by DU, (2016-07-15 13:57:30)

Hi

No flowery language and no filibustering just plain two questions from those sitting in HPSC:-

1. Why no scaling in mains when everywhere it is done ?

2. How to ensure parity in 19 optional subjects in mains ?

FYI in advertisement hpsc denied scaling in pt and no mention of mains.

And who are against this writ ?

Only two groups:- those called for interview and second who feels it will delay next notifications.

Well first one needs not to worry as I mentioned earlier and second one please understand its between present rights vs future expectations.

All those who accuse me of double standards and everything please understand I accept your allegations all of them. But explain why this step of writ is wrong on logical grounds.

Those who believe it's just please mail your marksheet on duonlinehry@gmail.com and ask others whom u know.

All the best to those who are appearing for interview.

Regards

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 13:15:54)

rofl......its not philosophy it's LOGIC, DU khud he anonymous ban k khud to bacha rha h,please learn to handle failure.

Re: HCS INTERVIEW QUESTIONS FREE DOWNLOAD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 13:15:22)

HCS INTERVIEW QUESTIONS FREE DOWNLOAD
link:
www.kushmanda.com

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 13:02:46)

JO FRIENDS MEHNAT SE YA PHIR LUCK SE MAINS QUALIFY KAR GAE H DON'T THINK THEY WILL BE THROUGH
SO PREPARE WELL

BUT DON'T TRY TO PUT QUESTION MARK ON THE INTENTIONS OF ONE OF OUR FELLOW NAMELY DU

LET HIM DO WHAT HE WANT TO DO.....

NOW QUESTION EMERGES WHETHER HE IS ON RIGHT FOOT OR NOT
LEAVE THIS QUESTION FOE HONOURABLE HC OR OTHER BODY

DU IS IN THE SYSTEM HE KNOWS SYSTEM BETTER THAN THOSE FRIENDS WHO HAVE SOME HOW (EXCLUDING HARDWORK)
QUALIFIED THE EXAM AND NOW THEY THINK AS IF THEY ARE BIG PHILOSOPHER

Re: rechecking

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 13:00:47)

Hpsc secretary k nam pe banana hai postal order

Re: rechecking

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 12:38:04)

postal order kiske favour mein banana hai ??

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 12:21:52)

One more thing...

Guys he is never going to file writ in his own name....

Think before giving your personal information to anyone who didn't even reveal his identity and demanded time for posting his e-mail id because he had to create a new one ....

He will use anyone of your names to file writ...

Because he cannot file writ as he is chosen and in job through the same process and getting the same benefit against which he is now planning to file writ....
Re:
Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 10:50:17)
Agar ye writ file kare to iske khilaf bhi case daalna chahiye...

Iske IP address se isko expose karke aur iski sabhi pichhli posts ko adduce kar ke....jo pichhli baar select hue hain unpe case daalna chahiye....

Jab iski naukri jayegi tab level playing field create ho jayegi shayad!!!

What say??!!!

Kam se kam iska pata to lagao ye double standard hai kaun??

Tell all those who are called for interview ki ye DU kya plan kar raha hai....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 12:19:40)

Where were you at the time of filling form for 2014 prelims?

You had knowledge that in HPSC rules it has mentioned that it doesn't do scaling operations (u mentioned in posts)

So because u didn't get call its unfair

If u had, like in earlier attemt, Than it's ok....no need was there to file writ then....

He is befooling everyone like he was doing earlier. ...

If he files in his own name, Court will first ask him where were you when you got selected last time, was it fair than and unfair now?!!!

And if it was unfair then, why didn't u file writ then???

Re: rechecking

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 12:16:15)

postal order kiske favour mein banana hai ?

Re: @du

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 12:07:48)

Du bro u r doing right thing..sabhi selected dosto se anurodh hai apna jugad bhi dhund le interview k liye..kyuki do hi trah k bache select honge jinke extra ordinary marks ho main m crowd se 30-35 marks jyada...ya jinka political or administrative jugad..DU bro if u need any help just type on blog..m wid u.. karam karo..all the best for interview to all frendz..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:50:04)

Just one thing

If u r so true that u will file the writ in ur name

Than just reveal ur identity first

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:42:38)

Again he is befooling those who are called for interview, by using his flowery language like he did earlier

Kah raha hai, tum sab safe ho safe hi rahoge, bas ek baar mujhe bhi ander ghusne do....
(Fir dekh lunga)

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:39:10)

He is just trying to delay next notification

That's it!

Maybe DU ki age nahi rahi ab! !

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:35:54)

Where were you at the time of filling form for 2014 prelims?

You had knowledge that in HPSC rules it has mentioned that it doesn't do scaling operations (u mentioned in posts)

So because u didn't get call its unfair

If u had, like in earlier attemt, Than it's ok....no need was there to file writ then....

He is befooling everyone like he was doing earlier. ...

If he files in his own name, Court will first ask him where were you when you got selected last time, was it fair than and unfair now?!!!

And if it was unfair then, why didn't u file writ then???

Re: @ selected

Posted by DU, (2016-07-15 11:34:05)

Hi

Please understand those who have already qualified for interviews need not to worry as they are in and no court order will lead to their ouster. Only new candidates will be admitted as in case of 2012 PT.

So please understand our battle nowhere affects you guys. U should focus on preparation of interviews especially factual information on Haryana.

Regards

Re: @ writ

Posted by DU, (2016-07-15 11:26:17)

duonlinehry@gmail.com

I'm filing this writ on my own name and it's a full blown war now. I have been living in fool's paradise that perhaps next time it will be fair but really it's system which is unfair and hence to change it.

Only one prayer that is either HPSC should reveal if it uses scaling for inter subject parity or if not than why not when everyone else is doing and hence revise result on basis of scaling procedure.

It will definitely provide us a level playing field and hope we can have justice then.

It's a very strong ground and if anyone has any doubt read the various judgements of HCs and SC on UPSC site under the heading of Scaling. Hpsc can't say we won't do it even if it amounts to injustice. Earlier till 2009 hpsc never gave question paper of PT but it was changed due to courts.

Than in 2012 HPSc didn't disclose answer key but HC gave directions to disclose within two three days as u can see on last page of last time's PT paper.

Now it's time for HPSC to adopt scaling.

Please mail your mark sheets so that we can show variation in marks of subjects. All of science subjects too please send as much as possible.

Regards

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:06:54)

DU ho yaa PU yaa JNU... sarkaar interview karayegi aur 2 din me result b aayega.. uska man hai usko karne do bhai..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:06:20)

One more thing...

Guys he is never going to file writ in his own name....

Think before giving your personal information to anyone who didn't even reveal his identity and demanded time for posting his e-mail id because he had to create a new one ....

He will use anyone of your names to file writ...

Because he cannot file writ as he is chosen and in job through the same process and getting the same benefit against which he is now planning to file writ....
Re:
Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 10:50:17)
Agar ye writ file kare to iske khilaf bhi case daalna chahiye...

Iske IP address se isko expose karke aur iski sabhi pichhli posts ko adduce kar ke....jo pichhli baar select hue hain unpe case daalna chahiye....

Jab iski naukri jayegi tab level playing field create ho jayegi shayad!!!

What say??!!!

Kam se kam iska pata to lagao ye double standard hai kaun??

Tell all those who are called for interview ki ye DU kya plan kar raha hai....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:06:13)

Its one prerogative to fight for ones own right.If injustice has been dealt to you,why shouldn't one?
It is known by almost everyone that state PCs especially haryana has all sorts of favoritism at work.And if you believe that its going to be Fiar in the interviews this time you are making a mistake cause even bjp members want to have the same clout within the bureaucracy as does the congress and Inld..bjp is facing a stern lack of cooperation from the executive...massive and frequent transfers and vigilance being given open authority are some not so subtle sign...Most importantly having your people working beyond the scope of politics and into the executive is always beneficial when not in power.Known truth hooda still gets your work done through his channel of officers while sitting mla of bjp are often clueless or powerless.
They sure would of have vetted pro rss or bjp affiliated aspirants by now and if not they will when people approach their local bjp leaders and sangh pracharaks for interviews..again long standing custum in haryana..everyone tries..mostly meeting their local MPs or MLAs...almost everyone who is from haryana has gone through this process on getting an interview call.
Nothing is going to change as no change is evident from the selection process itself.
My two cents.

Re: DU go for it.

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 11:03:43)

DU go for it.

ch***yon ki batton me mat aao.
file the writ.
ye sab m***d hain jo select ho chuke hain.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 10:56:07)

One more thing...

Guys he is never going to file writ in his own name....

Think before giving your personal information to anyone who didn't even reveal his identity and demanded time for posting his e-mail id because he had to create a new one ....

He will use anyone of your names to file writ...

Because he cannot file writ as he is chosen and in job through the same process and getting the same benefit against which he is now planning to file writ....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 10:50:17)

Agar ye writ file kare to iske khilaf bhi case daalna chahiye...

Iske IP address se isko expose karke aur iski sabhi pichhli posts ko adduce kar ke....jo pichhli baar select hue hain unpe case daalna chahiye....

Jab iski naukri jayegi tab level playing field create ho jayegi shayad!!!

What say??!!!

Kam se kam iska pata to lagao ye double standard hai kaun??

Tell all those who are called for interview ki ye DU kya plan kar raha hai....

Re: @du

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 10:44:46)

ur email pls???

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 10:41:57)

He is a hypocrite of the highest order!

Re: @DU

Posted by Adi, (2016-07-15 10:38:10)

Are bhai DU... ek baat bata de bass....cerain subjects were favoured in the last cycle of recruitment.

One thought that is at the top of the head right now is:
Pichli baar kyu nahi kiya ye sab???

Khud ko favour kar rhi h to status quo.. aur ab 'not Qualified' ho to ye sab drama?

Why should one not consider it an act of selfishness???

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 10:34:01)

Re: @ HCS selection
Posted by DU, (2016-05-15 16:51:35)
Hi

These are my private views and expressed here to waylaying the anxiety that is been growing up among all of us. In no way these are to belittle anyone's efforts and hopes with this exam process. If someone is not agree with this viewpoint then reject them but it's not a personal level comment.

As word of wisdom I like to tell you all that there is nothing to fear about HCS exam or for that matter any other test of like variety. Why I would say this, as because everyone of us already know the consequences- either pass or fail. There couldn't be any different conclusion and hence there shouldn't be any room for fear even. And despite the fact that your exam went well there could be 50 more facts which could simultaneously go against your selection rendering into a negative result like culling of your optional etc. Thus it is neither a test of competence especially in light of no scaling and no level playing field nor it is something that most of us have made as sole purpose of life (though we must have strong feelings for being clear but I'm pretty sure Hcs is not something for which ppl sit back and prepare for years like in IAS).

Hence be prepared about either of the two consequences like if pass then prepare well for interview or if negative then next round of PT with changed pattern, if you're still keen on taking exam.

And speaking rationally, ball is now out of your court, whether you worry and feel anxious or be calm and productive, it won't change the consequences as its sealed off on last day of your mains paper.

So be calm and composed and believe in yourself- success or failure shouldn't change your views about yourself.

Regards

Re: correction
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 21:02:00)
In last line please read, those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power lacks knowledge. Hence it might be fair HCS selection.

Regards
Re: @ qaz and ors
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 20:59:17)
Hi

If you will analyse the pattern of HCS and other related exams and their selections then you would notice that Hooda Govt. has marked difference from Chautala regime as in Hooda govt the highest echelons like CM etc were least bothered about selections of their own ppl and it was IAS and other functionaries who ruled the roost and it was seen with apathy of govt in conducting HCS, in 9.5 yrs only two exams were conducted, those too marred by litigation and quality of papers was poor deliberately to facilitate officers to get their wards and manipulations done for cash.

As compared to this in Chautala's tenure, govt was keen and focused to get maximum no. of HCS batches- 1999,2002, 2003 and 2004 that too in 6 years. And here the selection was done directly at behest of CM and highest party officials but no cash for post was involved.

It's true that both were having high level of nepotism but this can't be ruled out in present govt as it's general apathy of govt towards these matters which allows officials to manipulate.

Yet it's not guts but the fact that those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power to manipulate are not in power. Hence it might be fair enough yet might be not sure.

Regards

Re: @ Rohit
Posted by DU, (2016-05-10 14:59:21)
Hi

That's a good news that they are working overtime to get the things sorted at earliest possible date and in these circumstances result may come soon.

However I wish to ask you to talk to your source again about 2-3 candidates who are expected to get very high marks in mains. I mean if we know then we can guard against them by sending representations. Please remember nothing can be done afterwards.

And one thing more last time still one cushion was that of high total seats but this time it is not so, hence even one paid candidate can mar our chances of interview call or day selection.

Therefore I stress that please take up this issue with your source and try to reveal such candidates, even if there is something like this so that it could be nipped in bud.

Regards

Re: @ qaz
Posted by DU, (2016-05-05 14:59:27)
Hi

There is no way one could find out about the marking process and that of inequality of marks as unlike UPSC there is no set panel of experts to examine and more there are any standard guidelines. It will be result of individual examiners checking out papers and allocating marks.

Yes that's possible that by second half of this month picture may appear that when result is scheduled and when is interview being started as it involves clerical staff and thus chances of information coming out.

Prior to that all result dates and final results etc are just predictions nothing much.

Also safely it could be presumed that in total only 750 candidates appeared in all papers as there were absentees in each room of the centres.

Regards

Re: @ Pub Ad and NITI
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-04 22:04:40)
Hi

Yes it is imperative for getting goods to use these recommendations but please understand that for quoting as recent as 14th FC, Muni Bonds etc one needs to be updating notes on continuous basis as these are more current affairs based stuff and I think most of candidates out there are working ones who don't have that luxury. Moot point is how many out there of total 371 Pub Ad candidates have this level of answers, if majority does, than surely it will be a close call.

Secondly if one has gone through the basic structure of NITI and also its positives as mentioned on its website one can write a decent answer. But its true that if you haven't prepared it then its little bit ambiguous to approach and hence best to avoid.

Regards

Re: @ pub ad
Posted by DU, (2016-05-04 20:11:48)
Hi

I tend to differ from view pt that PUB AD was easier paper and that it's almost same for everyone. Let me illustrate this point:-

1. In section A if you have read ARC 2nd especially 10th report and have good knowledge about factual data of various committees right from Appleby committee to that of 2nd arc then Reforms question was quite scoring as here one could even suggest the reforms in this regard by ARC.

2. Like wise Local Self Govt question has lot of scope to write quality answer about especially if you have gone through the data given by ARC 2nd and 14th FC about devolution of 3Fs and also Devolution Index along with few improvements like Municipal Bonds allowed by Sebi last year.

3. Those who appeared for UPSC last year or this year certainly read about NITI Aayog and it was quite factual for straight answer if one is aware about comparative analysis of both PC and NiTi and if fact it came in UPSC too although in little bit different language.

4. Similarly Minimum Govt question is straight lifted from UPSC 2015 mains and it could fetch good marks with appropriate examples.

Thus those who have read it extensively and could only write relevant answers and if there will be standard checking of this optional as it appeared from standard paper then many will be surprised that Pub Ad scores won't reflect the expectations. As in post 2012 UPSC Pub Ad has shown that now marks are only for a exact answer not like earlier days when any attempt will fetch good marks.

Though it can't be ruled out that my predictions can go haywire and pub ad as a whole score good marks as it last year mainly due to bias that it's knowledge is good for an administrators.

Regards

Re: @ show stopper
Posted by D.U., (2016-04-30 11:23:09)
Hi

I agree with your keen observation that there was no signature on sheet by invigilator as it is done in UPSC mains.

I also agree about your contention regarding it but I like to point out that it could be also seen as a potential safeguard.

Let's presume that there is invigilator signature on that sheet in an area which is not to be torn off, it will make your sheet quite identifiable as you can only have to focus on 24 off sheets with same signature and thus open to manipulation.

And if there is invigilator's signature on torn off piece then still it will not serve any purpose as it will be torn off anyway.

I think this sheet issue is not that big that it could lead to huge level corruption and escalation of cut off as you have predicted.

Regards

Re: @PU and others
Posted by DU, (2016-04-28 17:31:37)
Hi

Sorry for being late in replying, I would like to say this much about last batch is that some officers of that batch are not due to their performance but for something else. Even though some of officers are indeed very good, over all luck played a much bigger role than any other factor be it knowledge, link, personality etc mainly due to lack of scaling in mains. It's not that UPSC doesn't have luck it also does but in HPSC main factor is luck and everything else is secondary.

To illustrate my point I would like to remind all those who cleared PT with geography this time, it was mainly luck for few with geography optional as paper was easy and cumulative score went up. Where as many very bright Law optional candidates especially in General Category thrown out just because of their luck as their paper was extremely tough.

Thus in nutshell HCS is huge gamble of luck and it is unfortunately true this time too. Yes last year there were many approchee which will be absent this time hopefully. However HCS is still test of your skills and your astrology.

I would request you to please don't add suffix like Sir while referring to me as we all are equal here - candidates of HCS.

Regards

Re: @ yash and qaz and ors
Posted by DU, (2016-04-22 17:22:34)
Hi

Sorry for hurting your feelings about your attempts to quantify the cut offs. It's not my intention as we all do some sort of guess work. But let me illustrate my point of it's being futile exercise :-

1. For a valid approximate cut off first and foremost requirement is idea about the marking patern and range of marks in each subject. For example in UPSC the range of marks vary from 130-150 for an outstanding attempt out of 250 but more than that except one or two brilliant cases. THIS IS ENTIRELY LACKING IN HCS AS IN 2009 LAW OPTIONAL SAW MAXIMUM 74-85 BUT IN 2013 everyone knows.

2. UPSC or any PCS have range of marks for common subjects too. For example till 2009 Hindi, English and GS were main determinants of rank and any one who is acquainted to this fact 70s were common for good candidates in GS and higher 60's for language papers.
YET IN HCS 2013 GS MARKS WERE NO WHERE IN PICTURE EVEN THOUGH PPL WROTE GOOD ANSWERS. HINDI WAS MARKED BY EXCEPTIONAL LOSE MARKING AND ENGLISH OPPOSITE TO IT.

3. All UPSC panel and even in PCS like Rajasthan there is a fixed panel of examiners with experience and standing instructions which ensures continuity in marking and hence in cut off. THIS IS ENTIRELY LACKING HERE IN HPSC.

Thus it is like shooting blindly that too in darkness when we attempt to quantify a cutoff for Hcs mains. On top of it there is no scaling.

Lastly I'm not against the fact that people demanding scaling from HPSC but I'm just explaining that it is not in rules of HPSC. And one dear fellow said that anti scaling is there for PT only, to him I suggest to please go through conduct rules of HPSC listed on site.

Hence it would be naïve to presume that it will be done through our representations. Yet there is no harm in writing these representations. I just been telling for all that it's not here neither I'm opposed to any such representations and nor I'm stand to gain by opposing such progressive step. But truth is staring us in our face.

Lastly its for sure that there will be new notification of HCS soon but with reduced number of Exe posts due to this batch and that of 2004 one. But yes there will be notification this year itself.

Results will be at breakneck pace, within two months final result will be out.

Regards

Re: Few Realities
Posted by D.U., (2016-04-21 14:16:40)
Hi frds

Since mains are over and there have been rounds of intense discussions about the HCS mains let me highlight some points:-

1. About Scaling and moderation

It must be understood by all of us who appeared in HCS mains that its openly disclosed by HPSC that they don't such scaling operations and hence take into account raw marks only for deciding cut off. This has been so since first exam of HCS. Hence it will be futile to expect and write letters for same to HPSC at this stage.

More over it is impertinent of understand that those who had geography as optional in PT has made into mains due to very fact that there is not scaling in HCS and Geography paper was easy than most other options.

Thus just have to understand and accept the inherently unjust system of HPSC and also the high element of luck in this exam due to scaling which is known to all since day one.

2. Out of syllabus GS paper

This goes out to those who read between lines and allege that Medieval History question was not in tune with syllabus. Please refer to the previous papers that are for first time listed by HPSC on its site, there are questions on Vedic Civilizations, Jainism etc which gave us an ample hint that whole history is covered by examiner and hence prepare accordingly.

Just for information GS is overlapping and its all inclusive for interdisciplinary nature, where all have weakness and have advantages in their respective fields so its not fair to allege that its out of syllabus and give an unfair advantage to one section. Though personally I don't have history option but still its not unfair.

3. Results

Yes there are very high chance of early declaration of results since only 800 (26 could be safely presumed to be absent) copies are to be corrected and there is no issue of moderation and scaling. Hence result is feasible for all practical purposes in a month or so.

Interview call will be of approx 165-170 candidates (keeping in view bracketed candidates) which will be over in a week as last time they took 30 candidates each day 15 each in morning and evening sessions.

4. Cut off

Please bear it mind no sane person can predict the same in HCS as marking pattern changes each year. For example mains cut off was in 350s in 2009 and it was 373 in 2013. Final cutoff too varies accordingly as it was 433 in 2013 and 403-404 in 2009.

So please don't be speculative about cut off its of no use.

5. Marking pattern

On a whole all i can pray for is this that there should be qualitative attitude in checking of exams where enriched answers and one containing relevant factual data like for example ARC 2nd, 14th FC recommendations in Pub Ad and so on should be rewarded more rather than mundane answers.

But this will surely depend upon the examiner and hence can't be surely predicted.

6. Standard

On a whole surely this year standard for mains is much better than last two times and thus HPSC staff deserves a pat for hard work in setting good questions and also right steps in checking unfair means.

These views are strictly personal and hence open to criticism and discuss.

Regards

Re: @ mains
Posted by D.U., (2016-03-15 22:55:27)
Hi

Please be calm and focused for next few days and prepare hard. All you can do is to prepare and attempt, hence don't think of outcome at this stage.

One more thing remember HCS is always have a huge portion for luck as there is no scaling inter subjects and hence one tough paper or tight marking in one optional can make u sit out. As those in HCS 2013 batch can tell how 'law' optional ruled the roost then and u can see how Law was washed out in 2014 pre...

In short prepare well and rest leave things and worry there is examination center on last exam. Don't bring anything home but just satisfaction of good efforts.

All the very best and do well.

Regards

Re: @ for all

Posted by D.U., (2016-07-15 10:26:39)

Hi

I have confirmed with lawyers and i along with few friends are hopefully filling a writ petition for specific payer of directions to HPSC for some sort of scaling pattern to be adopted by HPSC and hence revision of result on basis of that. Found out a huge tranche of cases on upsc.gov.in (COURT JUDGEMENT COMPILATION SECTION) in which SC has held that scaling is inherently important tool to establish inter subject parity.

I request few friends like qaz and others aggrieved ones who haven't mailed yet to get in touch and be party to case. It's not about money and don't need it too but about the strength of petition that this negligence on part of HPSC to fail to adopt scaling has hit us all.

Looking forward to your responses.

Regards

Re: @ Pub Ad marking

Posted by Adi, (2016-07-15 10:22:53)

got to know following marks in Public Admn.:

90

92

85

85

none of the above qualified...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 08:02:22)

Re: @ HCS selection
Posted by DU, (2016-05-15 16:51:35)
Hi

These are my private views and expressed here to waylaying the anxiety that is been growing up among all of us. In no way these are to belittle anyone's efforts and hopes with this exam process. If someone is not agree with this viewpoint then reject them but it's not a personal level comment.

As word of wisdom I like to tell you all that there is nothing to fear about HCS exam or for that matter any other test of like variety. Why I would say this, as because everyone of us already know the consequences- either pass or fail. There couldn't be any different conclusion and hence there shouldn't be any room for fear even. And despite the fact that your exam went well there could be 50 more facts which could simultaneously go against your selection rendering into a negative result like culling of your optional etc. Thus it is neither a test of competence especially in light of no scaling and no level playing field nor it is something that most of us have made as sole purpose of life (though we must have strong feelings for being clear but I'm pretty sure Hcs is not something for which ppl sit back and prepare for years like in IAS).

Hence be prepared about either of the two consequences like if pass then prepare well for interview or if negative then next round of PT with changed pattern, if you're still keen on taking exam.

And speaking rationally, ball is now out of your court, whether you worry and feel anxious or be calm and productive, it won't change the consequences as its sealed off on last day of your mains paper.

So be calm and composed and believe in yourself- success or failure shouldn't change your views about yourself.

Regards

Re: correction
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 21:02:00)
In last line please read, those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power lacks knowledge. Hence it might be fair HCS selection.

Regards
Re: @ qaz and ors
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 20:59:17)
Hi

If you will analyse the pattern of HCS and other related exams and their selections then you would notice that Hooda Govt. has marked difference from Chautala regime as in Hooda govt the highest echelons like CM etc were least bothered about selections of their own ppl and it was IAS and other functionaries who ruled the roost and it was seen with apathy of govt in conducting HCS, in 9.5 yrs only two exams were conducted, those too marred by litigation and quality of papers was poor deliberately to facilitate officers to get their wards and manipulations done for cash.

As compared to this in Chautala's tenure, govt was keen and focused to get maximum no. of HCS batches- 1999,2002, 2003 and 2004 that too in 6 years. And here the selection was done directly at behest of CM and highest party officials but no cash for post was involved.

It's true that both were having high level of nepotism but this can't be ruled out in present govt as it's general apathy of govt towards these matters which allows officials to manipulate.

Yet it's not guts but the fact that those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power to manipulate are not in power. Hence it might be fair enough yet might be not sure.

Regards

Re: @ Rohit
Posted by DU, (2016-05-10 14:59:21)
Hi

That's a good news that they are working overtime to get the things sorted at earliest possible date and in these circumstances result may come soon.

However I wish to ask you to talk to your source again about 2-3 candidates who are expected to get very high marks in mains. I mean if we know then we can guard against them by sending representations. Please remember nothing can be done afterwards.

And one thing more last time still one cushion was that of high total seats but this time it is not so, hence even one paid candidate can mar our chances of interview call or day selection.

Therefore I stress that please take up this issue with your source and try to reveal such candidates, even if there is something like this so that it could be nipped in bud.

Regards

Re: @ qaz
Posted by DU, (2016-05-05 14:59:27)
Hi

There is no way one could find out about the marking process and that of inequality of marks as unlike UPSC there is no set panel of experts to examine and more there are any standard guidelines. It will be result of individual examiners checking out papers and allocating marks.

Yes that's possible that by second half of this month picture may appear that when result is scheduled and when is interview being started as it involves clerical staff and thus chances of information coming out.

Prior to that all result dates and final results etc are just predictions nothing much.

Also safely it could be presumed that in total only 750 candidates appeared in all papers as there were absentees in each room of the centres.

Regards

Re: @ Pub Ad and NITI
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-04 22:04:40)
Hi

Yes it is imperative for getting goods to use these recommendations but please understand that for quoting as recent as 14th FC, Muni Bonds etc one needs to be updating notes on continuous basis as these are more current affairs based stuff and I think most of candidates out there are working ones who don't have that luxury. Moot point is how many out there of total 371 Pub Ad candidates have this level of answers, if majority does, than surely it will be a close call.

Secondly if one has gone through the basic structure of NITI and also its positives as mentioned on its website one can write a decent answer. But its true that if you haven't prepared it then its little bit ambiguous to approach and hence best to avoid.

Regards

Re: @ pub ad
Posted by DU, (2016-05-04 20:11:48)
Hi

I tend to differ from view pt that PUB AD was easier paper and that it's almost same for everyone. Let me illustrate this point:-

1. In section A if you have read ARC 2nd especially 10th report and have good knowledge about factual data of various committees right from Appleby committee to that of 2nd arc then Reforms question was quite scoring as here one could even suggest the reforms in this regard by ARC.

2. Like wise Local Self Govt question has lot of scope to write quality answer about especially if you have gone through the data given by ARC 2nd and 14th FC about devolution of 3Fs and also Devolution Index along with few improvements like Municipal Bonds allowed by Sebi last year.

3. Those who appeared for UPSC last year or this year certainly read about NITI Aayog and it was quite factual for straight answer if one is aware about comparative analysis of both PC and NiTi and if fact it came in UPSC too although in little bit different language.

4. Similarly Minimum Govt question is straight lifted from UPSC 2015 mains and it could fetch good marks with appropriate examples.

Thus those who have read it extensively and could only write relevant answers and if there will be standard checking of this optional as it appeared from standard paper then many will be surprised that Pub Ad scores won't reflect the expectations. As in post 2012 UPSC Pub Ad has shown that now marks are only for a exact answer not like earlier days when any attempt will fetch good marks.

Though it can't be ruled out that my predictions can go haywire and pub ad as a whole score good marks as it last year mainly due to bias that it's knowledge is good for an administrators.

Regards

Re: @ show stopper
Posted by D.U., (2016-04-30 11:23:09)
Hi

I agree with your keen observation that there was no signature on sheet by invigilator as it is done in UPSC mains.

I also agree about your contention regarding it but I like to point out that it could be also seen as a potential safeguard.

Let's presume that there is invigilator signature on that sheet in an area which is not to be torn off, it will make your sheet quite identifiable as you can only have to focus on 24 off sheets with same signature and thus open to manipulation.

And if there is invigilator's signature on torn off piece then still it will not serve any purpose as it will be torn off anyway.

I think this sheet issue is not that big that it could lead to huge level corruption and escalation of cut off as you have predicted.

Regards

Re: @PU and others
Posted by DU, (2016-04-28 17:31:37)
Hi

Sorry for being late in replying, I would like to say this much about last batch is that some officers of that batch are not due to their performance but for something else. Even though some of officers are indeed very good, over all luck played a much bigger role than any other factor be it knowledge, link, personality etc mainly due to lack of scaling in mains. It's not that UPSC doesn't have luck it also does but in HPSC main factor is luck and everything else is secondary.

To illustrate my point I would like to remind all those who cleared PT with geography this time, it was mainly luck for few with geography optional as paper was easy and cumulative score went up. Where as many very bright Law optional candidates especially in General Category thrown out just because of their luck as their paper was extremely tough.

Thus in nutshell HCS is huge gamble of luck and it is unfortunately true this time too. Yes last year there were many approchee which will be absent this time hopefully. However HCS is still test of your skills and your astrology.

I would request you to please don't add suffix like Sir while referring to me as we all are equal here - candidates of HCS.

Regards

Re: @ yash and qaz and ors
Posted by DU, (2016-04-22 17:22:34)
Hi

Sorry for hurting your feelings about your attempts to quantify the cut offs. It's not my intention as we all do some sort of guess work. But let me illustrate my point of it's being futile exercise :-

1. For a valid approximate cut off first and foremost requirement is idea about the marking patern and range of marks in each subject. For example in UPSC the range of marks vary from 130-150 for an outstanding attempt out of 250 but more than that except one or two brilliant cases. THIS IS ENTIRELY LACKING IN HCS AS IN 2009 LAW OPTIONAL SAW MAXIMUM 74-85 BUT IN 2013 everyone knows.

2. UPSC or any PCS have range of marks for common subjects too. For example till 2009 Hindi, English and GS were main determinants of rank and any one who is acquainted to this fact 70s were common for good candidates in GS and higher 60's for language papers.
YET IN HCS 2013 GS MARKS WERE NO WHERE IN PICTURE EVEN THOUGH PPL WROTE GOOD ANSWERS. HINDI WAS MARKED BY EXCEPTIONAL LOSE MARKING AND ENGLISH OPPOSITE TO IT.

3. All UPSC panel and even in PCS like Rajasthan there is a fixed panel of examiners with experience and standing instructions which ensures continuity in marking and hence in cut off. THIS IS ENTIRELY LACKING HERE IN HPSC.

Thus it is like shooting blindly that too in darkness when we attempt to quantify a cutoff for Hcs mains. On top of it there is no scaling.

Lastly I'm not against the fact that people demanding scaling from HPSC but I'm just explaining that it is not in rules of HPSC. And one dear fellow said that anti scaling is there for PT only, to him I suggest to please go through conduct rules of HPSC listed on site.

Hence it would be naïve to presume that it will be done through our representations. Yet there is no harm in writing these representations. I just been telling for all that it's not here neither I'm opposed to any such representations and nor I'm stand to gain by opposing such progressive step. But truth is staring us in our face.

Lastly its for sure that there will be new notification of HCS soon but with reduced number of Exe posts due to this batch and that of 2004 one. But yes there will be notification this year itself.

Results will be at breakneck pace, within two months final result will be out.

Regards

Re: Few Realities
Posted by D.U., (2016-04-21 14:16:40)
Hi frds

Since mains are over and there have been rounds of intense discussions about the HCS mains let me highlight some points:-

1. About Scaling and moderation

It must be understood by all of us who appeared in HCS mains that its openly disclosed by HPSC that they don't such scaling operations and hence take into account raw marks only for deciding cut off. This has been so since first exam of HCS. Hence it will be futile to expect and write letters for same to HPSC at this stage.

More over it is impertinent of understand that those who had geography as optional in PT has made into mains due to very fact that there is not scaling in HCS and Geography paper was easy than most other options.

Thus just have to understand and accept the inherently unjust system of HPSC and also the high element of luck in this exam due to scaling which is known to all since day one.

2. Out of syllabus GS paper

This goes out to those who read between lines and allege that Medieval History question was not in tune with syllabus. Please refer to the previous papers that are for first time listed by HPSC on its site, there are questions on Vedic Civilizations, Jainism etc which gave us an ample hint that whole history is covered by examiner and hence prepare accordingly.

Just for information GS is overlapping and its all inclusive for interdisciplinary nature, where all have weakness and have advantages in their respective fields so its not fair to allege that its out of syllabus and give an unfair advantage to one section. Though personally I don't have history option but still its not unfair.

3. Results

Yes there are very high chance of early declaration of results since only 800 (26 could be safely presumed to be absent) copies are to be corrected and there is no issue of moderation and scaling. Hence result is feasible for all practical purposes in a month or so.

Interview call will be of approx 165-170 candidates (keeping in view bracketed candidates) which will be over in a week as last time they took 30 candidates each day 15 each in morning and evening sessions.

4. Cut off

Please bear it mind no sane person can predict the same in HCS as marking pattern changes each year. For example mains cut off was in 350s in 2009 and it was 373 in 2013. Final cutoff too varies accordingly as it was 433 in 2013 and 403-404 in 2009.

So please don't be speculative about cut off its of no use.

5. Marking pattern

On a whole all i can pray for is this that there should be qualitative attitude in checking of exams where enriched answers and one containing relevant factual data like for example ARC 2nd, 14th FC recommendations in Pub Ad and so on should be rewarded more rather than mundane answers.

But this will surely depend upon the examiner and hence can't be surely predicted.

6. Standard

On a whole surely this year standard for mains is much better than last two times and thus HPSC staff deserves a pat for hard work in setting good questions and also right steps in checking unfair means.

These views are strictly personal and hence open to criticism and discuss.

Regards

Re: @ mains
Posted by D.U., (2016-03-15 22:55:27)
Hi

Please be calm and focused for next few days and prepare hard. All you can do is to prepare and attempt, hence don't think of outcome at this stage.

One more thing remember HCS is always have a huge portion for luck as there is no scaling inter subjects and hence one tough paper or tight marking in one optional can make u sit out. As those in HCS 2013 batch can tell how 'law' optional ruled the roost then and u can see how Law was washed out in 2014 pre...

In short prepare well and rest leave things and worry there is examination center on last exam. Don't bring anything home but just satisfaction of good efforts.

All the very best and do well.

Regards

Re: HCS INTERVIEW QUESTIONS FREE DOWNLOAD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-15 07:28:37)

“अगर बहुत अधिक पढ़ाई करने के बावजूद आप अपने आपको और अपने ज्ञान को प्रस्तुत करना नहीं जानते तो हो सकता है कि साक्षात्कार की कठिन दौड़ में आप पीछे रह जाये ?”

LINK:
http://kushmanda.com/?p=4388

forward massage to your friends

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-14 23:50:25)

Anyone else with more than 350 and still not qualified?

Re: 315

Posted by 315, (2016-07-14 23:44:10)

Hindi- 49
Eng - 67
GS - 44
Geo - 78
Pub Ad - 77
Last time appeared in interview. There is hardly any difference in questions, difficulty level, pattern or in my efforts between these two attempts except the big difference in total... Hard to introspect...

Re: EVERYONE TO READ

Posted by Logic, (2016-07-14 23:42:45)

On a different note, would like to say fee points:
1. This is only an exam. Not all HCS or IAS are happy. It is not that Happiness can not exist without HCS/IAS.
2. This is only an exam for a job. Nothing more. And exam should be left to remain only as an exam.
3. And those who think HCS/IAS are next to gods or powerful authorities, please mend your thinking. Times have changed now. Who saw IAS/HCS moving on cycles and doing campaigns before 10-15 years?
They are only an officer in huge govt. and now, people question them also. People no more accord respect only for the fact that u r an HCS/IAS officer.
Or jo bhai log kehte hai hame samaaj sewa karni hai. Then, HCS/IAS is not the only means to contribute to society or nation.
4. Life is a game of success and failure. You may succeed with 99 units of efforts. And who knows? You may fail also with 100 units of efforts.
Although we have scientific temper developed in us. But i would like to quote our highly revered "Geeta".
Karma kar. Phal ki ichha mat kar.

Probably, it was said by lord Krishna because he had everything in his control. He knew that humans will not always succeed despite best efforts. And just like there are acts by legislatures, the principles and laws laid down by almighty, silently governing the human kind are little known.

It shall not be the case always that every selected candidate did more hard work/more intelligent than left ones. I have seen sincere, intelligent and hard working people having nothing in their hands. Every Time lagging by 1-2 marks. No one has control over luck.

So, guys think deeply. However, i am not to label anyone, whether du, qaz, hcsbaba or selected candidate as on wrong side.

Views are only personal. And no intention to hurt anyone.

Re: EVERYONE TO READ

Posted by Logic, (2016-07-14 23:39:54)

On a different note, would like to say fee points:
1. This is only an exam. Not all HCS or IAS are happy. It is not that Happiness can not exist without HCS/IAS.
2. This is only an exam for a job. Nothing more. And exam should be left to remain only as an exam.
3. And those who think HCS/IAS are next to gods or powerful authorities, please mend your thinking. Times have changed now. Who saw IAS/HCS moving on cycles and doing campaigns before 10-15 years?
They are only an officer in huge govt. and now, people question them also. People no more accord respect only for the fact that u r an HCS/IAS officer.
Or jo bhai log kehte hai hame samaaj sewa karni hai. Then, HCS/IAS is not the only means to contribute to society or nation.
4. Life is a game of success and failure. You may succeed with 99 units of efforts. And who knows? You may fail also with 100 units of efforts.
Although we have scientific temper developed in us. But i would like to quote our highly revered "Geeta".
Karma kar. Phal ki ichha mat kar.

Probably, it was said by lord Krishna because he had everything in his control. He knew that humans will not always succeed despite best efforts. And just like there are acts by legislatures, the principles and laws laid down by almighty, silently governing the human kind are little known.

It shall not be the case always that every selected candidate did more hard work/more intelligent than left ones. I have seen sincere, intelligent and hard working people having nothing in their hands. Every Time lagging by 1-2 marks. No one has control over luck.

So, guys think deeply. However, i am not to label anyone, whether du, qaz, hcsbaba or selected candidate as on wrong side.

Views are only personal. And no intention to hurt anyone.

Re: oye stupid anonymous

Posted by Yash, (2016-07-14 23:16:09)

Go to hell & be there until you learn to comment on any post "without" any knowledge..you intelligent case calling me dumb has surely failed in exam & if not will fail further because your impulsiveness is so ugly...ugh..!!

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-14 22:37:37)

Huh! It is really really hard to believe ...

People could be so dumb!!!!!!!!!!

Re: WHY MODERATION

Posted by Yash, (2016-07-14 22:19:20)

Public administration & geography optionals are deliberately culled BECAUSE former secretary hpsc leaked these Q papers to 20-25 candidates, and present secy came to know about it after the exam...n thus all of us pub admn & geog candidates suffered..(may be -30 or -40 formula throughout in both subjects applied).
I dont know how i am in...may be on margin...anyone got 90+ in either subjects??

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-14 19:41:23)

Padh liye apne views?!!!!

Chalo ab maan liye DU bhai....aapko public administration mei 50 number aur diye ( vaise milega 1 bhi nahi fir bhi maan liya)

Ab bhi kya ukhhad logey?!!!

Re: HCS INTERVIEW QUESTIONS FREE DOWNLOAD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-14 19:41:08)

“अगर बहुत अधिक पढ़ाई करने के बावजूद आप अपने आपको और अपने ज्ञान को प्रस्तुत करना नहीं जानते तो हो सकता है कि साक्षात्कार की कठिन दौड़ में आप पीछे रह जाये ?”

LINK:
http://kushmanda.com/?p=4388

forward massage to your friends

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-14 18:54:26)

PARTS I NEEDED YOU TO FOCUS DIDN'T GET HIGHLIGHTED....

SO NOW U HAVE TO READ IT THROUGH TO GRASP THE FUTILITY OF YOUR EFFORTS....

ITS JUST DU'S OWN VIEWS....

HE CAN'T DENY THESE...

I HOPE ATLEAST NOW GOOD SENSE WILL PREVAIL...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-14 18:51:34)

These are views of DU before Mains result....

I advise DU and others who think that he is right to go throuh the highlighted parts please...

time for introspection....futile attempt will only marr and delay next notification jeopardizing future of many.....

Re: @ HCS selection
Posted by DU, (2016-05-15 16:51:35)
Hi

These are my private views and expressed here to waylaying the anxiety that is been growing up among all of us. In no way these are to belittle anyone's efforts and hopes with this exam process. If someone is not agree with this viewpoint then reject them but it's not a personal level comment.

As word of wisdom I like to tell you all that there is nothing to fear about HCS exam or for that matter any other test of like variety. Why I would say this, as because everyone of us already know the consequences- either pass or fail. There couldn't be any different conclusion and hence there shouldn't be any room for fear even. And despite the fact that your exam went well there could be 50 more facts which could simultaneously go against your selection rendering into a negative result like culling of your optional etc. Thus it is neither a test of competence especially in light of no scaling and no level playing field nor it is something that most of us have made as sole purpose of life (though we must have strong feelings for being clear but I'm pretty sure Hcs is not something for which ppl sit back and prepare for years like in IAS).

Hence be prepared about either of the two consequences like if pass then prepare well for interview or if negative then next round of PT with changed pattern, if you're still keen on taking exam.

And speaking rationally, ball is now out of your court, whether you worry and feel anxious or be calm and productive, it won't change the consequences as its sealed off on last day of your mains paper.

So be calm and composed and believe in yourself- success or failure shouldn't change your views about yourself.

Regards

Re: correction
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 21:02:00)
In last line please read, those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power lacks knowledge. Hence it might be fair HCS selection.

Regards
Re: @ qaz and ors
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 20:59:17)
Hi

If you will analyse the pattern of HCS and other related exams and their selections then you would notice that Hooda Govt. has marked difference from Chautala regime as in Hooda govt the highest echelons like CM etc were least bothered about selections of their own ppl and it was IAS and other functionaries who ruled the roost and it was seen with apathy of govt in conducting HCS, in 9.5 yrs only two exams were conducted, those too marred by litigation and quality of papers was poor deliberately to facilitate officers to get their wards and manipulations done for cash.

As compared to this in Chautala's tenure, govt was keen and focused to get maximum no. of HCS batches- 1999,2002, 2003 and 2004 that too in 6 years. And here the selection was done directly at behest of CM and highest party officials but no cash for post was involved.

It's true that both were having high level of nepotism but this can't be ruled out in present govt as it's general apathy of govt towards these matters which allows officials to manipulate.

Yet it's not guts but the fact that those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power to manipulate are not in power. Hence it might be fair enough yet might be not sure.

Regards

Re: @ Rohit
Posted by DU, (2016-05-10 14:59:21)
Hi

That's a good news that they are working overtime to get the things sorted at earliest possible date and in these circumstances result may come soon.

However I wish to ask you to talk to your source again about 2-3 candidates who are expected to get very high marks in mains. I mean if we know then we can guard against them by sending representations. Please remember nothing can be done afterwards.

And one thing more last time still one cushion was that of high total seats but this time it is not so, hence even one paid candidate can mar our chances of interview call or day selection.

Therefore I stress that please take up this issue with your source and try to reveal such candidates, even if there is something like this so that it could be nipped in bud.

Regards

Re: @ qaz
Posted by DU, (2016-05-05 14:59:27)
Hi

There is no way one could find out about the marking process and that of inequality of marks as unlike UPSC there is no set panel of experts to examine and more there are any standard guidelines. It will be result of individual examiners checking out papers and allocating marks.

Yes that's possible that by second half of this month picture may appear that when result is scheduled and when is interview being started as it involves clerical staff and thus chances of information coming out.

Prior to that all result dates and final results etc are just predictions nothing much.

Also safely it could be presumed that in total only 750 candidates appeared in all papers as there were absentees in each room of the centres.

Regards

Re: @ Pub Ad and NITI
Posted by D.U., (2016-05-04 22:04:40)
Hi

Yes it is imperative for getting goods to use these recommendations but please understand that for quoting as recent as 14th FC, Muni Bonds etc one needs to be updating notes on continuous basis as these are more current affairs based stuff and I think most of candidates out there are working ones who don't have that luxury. Moot point is how many out there of total 371 Pub Ad candidates have this level of answers, if majority does, than surely it will be a close call.

Secondly if one has gone through the basic structure of NITI and also its positives as mentioned on its website one can write a decent answer. But its true that if you haven't prepared it then its little bit ambiguous to approach and hence best to avoid.

Regards

Re: @ pub ad
Posted by DU, (2016-05-04 20:11:48)
Hi

I tend to differ from view pt that PUB AD was easier paper and that it's almost same for everyone. Let me illustrate this point:-

1. In section A if you have read ARC 2nd especially 10th report and have good knowledge about factual data of various committees right from Appleby committee to that of 2nd arc then Reforms question was quite scoring as here one could even suggest the reforms in this regard by ARC.

2. Like wise Local Self Govt question has lot of scope to write quality answer about especially if you have gone through the data given by ARC 2nd and 14th FC about devolution of 3Fs and also Devolution Index along with few improvements like Municipal Bonds allowed by Sebi last year.

3. Those who appeared for UPSC last year or this year certainly read about NITI Aayog and it was quite factual for straight answer if one is aware about comparative analysis of both PC and NiTi and if fact it came in UPSC too although in little bit different language.

4. Similarly Minimum Govt question is straight lifted from UPSC 2015 mains and it could fetch good marks with appropriate examples.

Thus those who have read it extensively and could only write relevant answers and if there will be standard checking of this optional as it appeared from standard paper then many will be surprised that Pub Ad scores won't reflect the expectations. As in post 2012 UPSC Pub Ad has shown that now marks are only for a exact answer not like earlier days when any attempt will fetch good marks.

Though it can't be ruled out that my predictions can go haywire and pub ad as a whole score good marks as it last year mainly due to bias that it's knowledge is good for an administrators.

Regards

Re: @ show stopper
Posted by D.U., (2016-04-30 11:23:09)
Hi

I agree with your keen observation that there was no signature on sheet by invigilator as it is done in UPSC mains.

I also agree about your contention regarding it but I like to point out that it could be also seen as a potential safeguard.

Let's presume that there is invigilator signature on that sheet in an area which is not to be torn off, it will make your sheet quite identifiable as you can only have to focus on 24 off sheets with same signature and thus open to manipulation.

And if there is invigilator's signature on torn off piece then still it will not serve any purpose as it will be torn off anyway.

I think this sheet issue is not that big that it could lead to huge level corruption and escalation of cut off as you have predicted.

Regards

Re: @PU and others
Posted by DU, (2016-04-28 17:31:37)
Hi

Sorry for being late in replying, I would like to say this much about last batch is that some officers of that batch are not due to their performance but for something else. Even though some of officers are indeed very good, over all luck played a much bigger role than any other factor be it knowledge, link, personality etc mainly due to lack of scaling in mains. It's not that UPSC doesn't have luck it also does but in HPSC main factor is luck and everything else is secondary.

To illustrate my point I would like to remind all those who cleared PT with geography this time, it was mainly luck for few with geography optional as paper was easy and cumulative score went up. Where as many very bright Law optional candidates especially in General Category thrown out just because of their luck as their paper was extremely tough.

Thus in nutshell HCS is huge gamble of luck and it is unfortunately true this time too. Yes last year there were many approchee which will be absent this time hopefully. However HCS is still test of your skills and your astrology.

I would request you to please don't add suffix like Sir while referring to me as we all are equal here - candidates of HCS.

Regards

Re: @ yash and qaz and ors
Posted by DU, (2016-04-22 17:22:34)
Hi

Sorry for hurting your feelings about your attempts to quantify the cut offs. It's not my intention as we all do some sort of guess work. But let me illustrate my point of it's being futile exercise :-

1. For a valid approximate cut off first and foremost requirement is idea about the marking patern and range of marks in each subject. For example in UPSC the range of marks vary from 130-150 for an outstanding attempt out of 250 but more than that except one or two brilliant cases. THIS IS ENTIRELY LACKING IN HCS AS IN 2009 LAW OPTIONAL SAW MAXIMUM 74-85 BUT IN 2013 everyone knows.

2. UPSC or any PCS have range of marks for common subjects too. For example till 2009 Hindi, English and GS were main determinants of rank and any one who is acquainted to this fact 70s were common for good candidates in GS and higher 60's for language papers.
YET IN HCS 2013 GS MARKS WERE NO WHERE IN PICTURE EVEN THOUGH PPL WROTE GOOD ANSWERS. HINDI WAS MARKED BY EXCEPTIONAL LOSE MARKING AND ENGLISH OPPOSITE TO IT.

3. All UPSC panel and even in PCS like Rajasthan there is a fixed panel of examiners with experience and standing instructions which ensures continuity in marking and hence in cut off. THIS IS ENTIRELY LACKING HERE IN HPSC.

Thus it is like shooting blindly that too in darkness when we attempt to quantify a cutoff for Hcs mains. On top of it there is no scaling.

Lastly I'm not against the fact that people demanding scaling from HPSC but I'm just explaining that it is not in rules of HPSC. And one dear fellow said that anti scaling is there for PT only, to him I suggest to please go through conduct rules of HPSC listed on site.

Hence it would be naïve to presume that it will be done through our representations. Yet there is no harm in writing these representations. I just been telling for all that it's not here neither I'm opposed to any such representations and nor I'm stand to gain by opposing such progressive step. But truth is staring us in our face.

Lastly its for sure that there will be new notification of HCS soon but with reduced number of Exe posts due to this batch and that of 2004 one. But yes there will be notification this year itself.

Results will be at breakneck pace, within two months final result will be out.

Regards

Re: Few Realities
Posted by D.U., (2016-04-21 14:16:40)
Hi frds

Since mains are over and there have been rounds of intense discussions about the HCS mains let me highlight some points:-

1. About Scaling and moderation

It must be understood by all of us who appeared in HCS mains that its openly disclosed by HPSC that they don't such scaling operations and hence take into account raw marks only for deciding cut off. This has been so since first exam of HCS. Hence it will be futile to expect and write letters for same to HPSC at this stage.

More over it is impertinent of understand that those who had geography as optional in PT has made into mains due to very fact that there is not scaling in HCS and Geography paper was easy than most other options.

Thus just have to understand and accept the inherently unjust system of HPSC and also the high element of luck in this exam due to scaling which is known to all since day one.

2. Out of syllabus GS paper

This goes out to those who read between lines and allege that Medieval History question was not in tune with syllabus. Please refer to the previous papers that are for first time listed by HPSC on its site, there are questions on Vedic Civilizations, Jainism etc which gave us an ample hint that whole history is covered by examiner and hence prepare accordingly.

Just for information GS is overlapping and its all inclusive for interdisciplinary nature, where all have weakness and have advantages in their respective fields so its not fair to allege that its out of syllabus and give an unfair advantage to one section. Though personally I don't have history option but still its not unfair.

3. Results

Yes there are very high chance of early declaration of results since only 800 (26 could be safely presumed to be absent) copies are to be corrected and there is no issue of moderation and scaling. Hence result is feasible for all practical purposes in a month or so.

Interview call will be of approx 165-170 candidates (keeping in view bracketed candidates) which will be over in a week as last time they took 30 candidates each day 15 each in morning and evening sessions.

4. Cut off

Please bear it mind no sane person can predict the same in HCS as marking pattern changes each year. For example mains cut off was in 350s in 2009 and it was 373 in 2013. Final cutoff too varies accordingly as it was 433 in 2013 and 403-404 in 2009.

So please don't be speculative about cut off its of no use.

5. Marking pattern

On a whole all i can pray for is this that there should be qualitative attitude in checking of exams where enriched answers and one containing relevant factual data like for example ARC 2nd, 14th FC recommendations in Pub Ad and so on should be rewarded more rather than mundane answers.

But this will surely depend upon the examiner and hence can't be surely predicted.

6. Standard

On a whole surely this year standard for mains is much better than last two times and thus HPSC staff deserves a pat for hard work in setting good questions and also right steps in checking unfair means.

These views are strictly personal and hence open to criticism and discuss.

Regards

Re: @ mains
Posted by D.U., (2016-03-15 22:55:27)
Hi

Please be calm and focused for next few days and prepare hard. All you can do is to prepare and attempt, hence don't think of outcome at this stage.

One more thing remember HCS is always have a huge portion for luck as there is no scaling inter subjects and hence one tough paper or tight marking in one optional can make u sit out. As those in HCS 2013 batch can tell how 'law' optional ruled the roost then and u can see how Law was washed out in 2014 pre...

In short prepare well and rest leave things and worry there is examination center on last exam. Don't bring anything home but just satisfaction of good efforts.

All the very best and do well.

Regards

Re: correction

Posted by KM, (2016-07-14 18:49:05)

English and Hindi Mains 2014

Re: Hindi and English Mains 2016

Posted by KM, (2016-07-14 18:47:39)

https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0BwgoX4RuPhDsbFNSZDVheW1uVnc&usp=sharing

Re: @WRIT

Posted by KK, (2016-07-14 18:41:22)

PUB AD MEIN TOATL Appeared candidates 371....seats 55.....interview call hui 165 ke arround....ab in sab ka pub ad subject maan lo...fail kitne honge =205 ....D.U. AUR USKE BHAI LOG INHI 205 MEIN HAIN....
YE DU KI FRUSTRATION HAI...BHAI ALL THE BEST FOR UR FUTURE PLAN.....
LAST TIME INKA VERSION THA...MAINS KE AAGEY AUR BHI DUNIYA HAI...WE MUST MOVE ON ...BLA BLA....WHY? ?? KYONKI D.U. KI INTERVIEW CALL HO Gi thi...kahi sala koi writ laga ke baharti ka kabada na karde...
Sab logon ko move on mobve on bol ke ch.tia kaat diya...

Or Is baar DU apni floweri bhasha se examiner ko rijha nahi paya tau INJUSTICE HO GYA....pucho us se last time ki allied post kon se subject ne dilwayi thi usko...
Move ON MR. DU...MOVE ON

DUSRON KA NUKSAAN MAT KARO...HOGA KUCH BHI NAHI BUS...RESULT JO AUGUST MEI AANA HAI...WO OCT NOV TAK KHICH JAYEGA....SOCHO YE KITNE LOGON KA BAHALA KARNE JA RHA HAI...
AAJ TAK KISI COMMISSION NE RECHECKING KI HAI JO YE KARWA DEGA..,,SUPREME COURT AND HIGH COURT ISE YA TAU PAHLE JHATKE MEIN BAHAR KAREGA NAHI TAU HPSC KE REPLY KE BAAD TURANT...

ALL THE BEST MR DU....

Re: mains question paper

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-07-14 17:31:50)

dear all,
could any of you upload the question paper!!