Oy Naukri

India Jobs. Read. Talk. Share.



Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-13 14:02:11)

yeah....but scores will vary greatly.. because quality of ans will vary greatly . probably last time variation was less..


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-13 13:53:30)

this time every one was happy post exam..

Re: @Sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-13 13:50:29)

yes . no direct thinker but there was enough sociology in papers. unlike last time when questions were not very sociological in nature.
about scoring ... i dont know .... last time 100+ were a bit rare as per my info....in 2009 sociology was well rewarded ..not in 2013. probably paper was sociologically difficult last time. this time you can score decent if you have kept a sociological perspective and used thinkers whereever possible.
normally ppl have tendency to use thinkers indiscriminately which i personally think is counter productive...
lets see how sociology fares this time. a lot depends upon checking pattern otherwise everybody was happy post sociology exam at the centre.

Re: @socio

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-13 11:51:11)

Socio is however one of the most rewarded optional in HCS

Re: @sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-13 11:40:52)

How was the paper???

Re: sociology

Posted by sociology, (2016-05-13 11:36:59)

sociology paper was very disy..no direct thinker..what say..??


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-12 21:56:37)

All corruption..... what else. these vermins at HPSC are just adjusting their family members.. elite self recruitment..

Re: @ Cut Off

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-12 20:55:32)

It was 432 for general category but not sure for Exe Post as Commission didn't put it on its site. neither the marks of all selected candidates nor that of all interview call candidates. At east in 2011 they put marks of those who went to interview stage.


Re: @DU

Posted by MgL5Y, (2016-05-12 19:48:53)

No defined pattern in interview marks. what was the marks of topper written/post interview last time if you know. as far as i know 470 was cut off for HCS EB and 430 GEN cut off

Re: @ Physics Optional

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-12 19:43:43)


Theoretically there are 32 candidates who opted for Physics as their optional in mains. So safely it could be predicted 25-30 would have written mains and most of these would either be from teaching profession or in academics, hence no one is expected to be full time civils oriented candidate. Thus it is of not much consequence to lose sleep on expected high marks in Physics optional.

And yes the interview marks in Haryana are not following any pattern as it varies with the other calculations, like last time are only 5-10 candidates with very low marks as interview marks were of least consequences and hence given liberally. On the contrary in 2012 as high as 94 candidates were given so low marks that they lie between 395 and 405( it was cut off).

So you can not gauge the significance of interview score stand alone but it should be viewed as holistically with range of mains score.



Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-12 19:20:20)

how many of the aspirants of this blog have attended last interview and what was the written score... I did mine was 385 written 415 post interview.

Re: @physics optional

Posted by abc, (2016-05-12 16:47:19)

physics' candidates were seen complaining about an unusual paper. i met a few ppl who are apprehensive about their score in physics only

Re: @physics

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-12 12:23:42)

I heard that physics is v very scoring in mains...

I mean 130+ is not uncommon..

how was the paper for physics/maths etc...

was it easy to score 130-140 easily or it was tough....


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-11 18:47:22)

not many physics optional candidates were there

Re: physics optional

Posted by jyoti, (2016-05-11 12:18:25)

hello...is here anyone with physics optional...there was error in the thermodynamics section as temperature at which rms speed is to evaluate hs been nt given...any representation by anybody???

Re: physics optional

Posted by jyoti, (2016-05-11 12:17:52)

hello...is here anyone with physics optional...there was error in the thermodynamics section as temperature at which rms speed is to evaluate hs been nt given...any representation by anybody???

Re: @DU

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-10 22:02:08)

I dont agree with you on the type of candidates selected in chautala and hooda regime. there were less recruitment in HCS during hooda regime just because he waited for HPSC member to retire to resign/remove thru presidential reference. otherwise type of candidates are same in both selections. they are from kith/kin/higher Bureaucracy and some specific regions are given undue advantages in both recruitment. There is direct manipulation at the highest level . ONly difference was that Hooda govt was more careful and has done the corruption in such a way that it is difficult to challange on paper while chautala didnt care about even paper work . Hooda was careful in this sense. otherwise if u see that he gave spl dispensation to HCS candidates to join them on the same date the govt issued appointment letter, no medical , no character antecedent checkings

it is intresting , how candidates who were working in some other govt jobs joined on the same day. how they resigned their previous jobs etc. etc. until unless they were not aware of their selection beforehand

Re: @DU and others

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-10 21:21:38)

Ya that's what I meant by guts.... Don't take it as positive aspect of guts...u perfectly explained it in ur last para...

Anyways... I think those of us who can, should go to HPSC to get idea about result...tomorrow by chance i m going to Chandigarh so I will try to inquire at Panchkula....though such an exercise is somewhat futile but this anxiety is wanting me to do so

Re: correction

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 21:02:00)

In last line please read, those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power lacks knowledge. Hence it might be fair HCS selection.


Re: @ qaz and ors

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-10 20:59:17)


If you will analyse the pattern of HCS and other related exams and their selections then you would notice that Hooda Govt. has marked difference from Chautala regime as in Hooda govt the highest echelons like CM etc were least bothered about selections of their own ppl and it was IAS and other functionaries who ruled the roost and it was seen with apathy of govt in conducting HCS, in 9.5 yrs only two exams were conducted, those too marred by litigation and quality of papers was poor deliberately to facilitate officers to get their wards and manipulations done for cash.

As compared to this in Chautala's tenure, govt was keen and focused to get maximum no. of HCS batches- 1999,2002, 2003 and 2004 that too in 6 years. And here the selection was done directly at behest of CM and highest party officials but no cash for post was involved.

It's true that both were having high level of nepotism but this can't be ruled out in present govt as it's general apathy of govt towards these matters which allows officials to manipulate.

Yet it's not guts but the fact that those who have knowledge to manipulate are not in power and those who have power to manipulate are not in power. Hence it might be fair enough yet might be not sure.



Posted by 6HBzs, (2016-05-10 19:49:18)

dont talk about guts
the two cm u mentioned are outright criminal.. one has been given certificate by court. other is waiting

Re: Paid seats

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-10 19:41:33)

Either there will be no paid candidates or most of hcs exec seats will be paid/spoiled.
And as far as my experience with Khattar govt is concerned, they don't have the guts to do what Hooda and Chautala did.


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-10 19:30:15)

yes.. thats the beauty of the exam this time. ..everybody has a feeling that they will get interview ... yet there are only 160 odd calls to be given
one of the most hopeful HCS till date...
anyways .. coming to the point, As someone on this blog raised the pt of paid candidates...I feel this time this evil might not be there .....1-2 candidates does not make a huge difference .compare it with last time .... 2/3rd were VVIPs of Hooda govt.
lets have a positive mind set....and hope for the best.
PS: I believe result will be out by june 10.

Re: All

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-10 19:12:06)

Interesting to see that candidates, though not selected till now, yet are converned about promotional aspects. Bhai logon, pehle select to ho jao. Promotion toh baad mein hogi!

Re: @ Rohit

Posted by DU, (2016-05-10 14:59:21)


That's a good news that they are working overtime to get the things sorted at earliest possible date and in these circumstances result may come soon.

However I wish to ask you to talk to your source again about 2-3 candidates who are expected to get very high marks in mains. I mean if we know then we can guard against them by sending representations. Please remember nothing can be done afterwards.

And one thing more last time still one cushion was that of high total seats but this time it is not so, hence even one paid candidate can mar our chances of interview call or day selection.

Therefore I stress that please take up this issue with your source and try to reveal such candidates, even if there is something like this so that it could be nipped in bud.


Re: @Aditya

Posted by Rohit, (2016-05-10 13:26:41)

My source has no news on NT exam....even if there was a slight development on that issue I would inform you guys here....anyways hpsc is fully focused on checking on hcs mains answer sheets...Secretary is personally handling this process of checking part of hcs sheets...some commission staff is coming to office even on sundays which is rare in govt jobs ...so you can get the idea of urgency of commission in completing this recruitment cycle...good luck with interview preparations

Re: @DU @Rohit

Posted by Aditya, (2016-05-10 12:57:30)

Any news from your source regarding NT exam.

Re: @DU @Rohit

Posted by Aditya, (2016-05-10 12:57:28)

Any news from your source regarding NT exam.


Posted by LALIT KUMAR , (2016-05-10 12:51:23)


Re: @DU @Rohit

Posted by Aditya, (2016-05-10 12:32:52)

Any news from your source regarding NT exam.


Posted by Third and final, (2016-05-10 11:35:57)

We don't need to be cautious while predicting about mains result.be straight it shall come out anytime after 20th may and probably on 24th. Because who know hpsc better than one who is struggling for last 12 years


Posted by qaz, (2016-05-10 11:21:02)

High probability around 10th June....

Re: @ mains result

Posted by DU, (2016-05-10 10:47:38)


I heard a grapevine, apparently a strong one, "mains result will be coming out soon", by soon we can presume safely that it can be as early as first week of June itself.

Though I can't verify the veracity of this contention independently but if it's viewed along with the same kind of versions put up here earlier then it's likely to be a good piece of information.


Re: सामान्य ज्ञान प्रतियोगिता

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-10 07:27:39)

सामान्य ज्ञान प्रतियोगिता

1st Prize: Rs.11000/-

2nd Prize:Rs. 5100/-

3rd Prize:Rs.3100/-


Re: All

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-09 21:27:13)

Interesting to see that candidates, though not selected till now, yet are converned about promotional aspects. Bhai logon, pehle select to ho jao. Promotion toh baad mein hogi!

Re: @DU

Posted by Rakesh, (2016-05-09 19:17:04)

Age limit is 54...changed in 2015

Re: @ promotion

Posted by DU, (2016-05-09 19:07:11)


Well it's truly appropriate as stated by qaz and others here that promotional issue is still last one to be bothered about at this stage.

But for sake of knowledge please know that most of these guys who are part of this list is in on higher margin of age and thus don't have any promotion chances. Since to be promoted to IAS there has an age bar that means along with 15-16 years as HCS plus age bar of not being above 52 years, I'm not sure though it's 52 or 50. Hence these guys are not in that contention simply because of higher age at time of induction. Yes if they are given retrospective seniority then they would be up over all and may be promoted in 3-4 years.


Re: @qaz

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-09 11:16:07)

sahi baat hai bhai promotion bahut dur ki baat hai

just telling the impact in general....

karte karte result will go into july.....

we should not expect result in 1-2 months.

keep 3 months window in mind....


Posted by qaz, (2016-05-09 11:13:55)

Result kab aa raha hai?
Promotions toh bohot door ki baat hai abhi


Posted by qaz, (2016-05-09 11:13:34)

Result kab aa raha hai?
Promotions toh bohot door ki baat hai abhi

Re: Delay in promotion

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-09 11:06:50)

This fear is also unfounded because in the coming years there are large number of retirements. Also Government of India is contemplating the increase in quota of promotion from 33% to around 50%.


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-09 10:40:36)

only impact these 23 appointees will have is they will have seniority in promotion as compared to this batch. It may delay promotion by 2-3 years....

Re: 23 selected in HCS

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-09 08:25:14)

Someone on this blog has said that all 23 would join. This is not true only 18 of these 23 would join because others have been selected on higher posts. Even after 18 vacancies are utilized there are 10 more vacancies as on today and after 30 HCS are promoted which can happen any time there will 30 more vacancies. So do not bother about the vacancies. Work hard, have trust in God, have enthusiasm and you will succeed. All the best.

Re: @Rohit

Posted by Aditya, (2016-05-09 07:51:43)

Sir, Any news regarding NT exam plz share..

Re: @DU & qaz

Posted by Rohit, (2016-05-09 07:20:54)

Nearly all paid candidates got selected last time as proper HCS or DSP whereas meritous candidates got allied services like ETO,tehsildar etc...this time exam checking process is mostly fair...however one can't discount the possibility of 2-3 candidates again getting high marks in mains as I have got suspicions about that hearing from one of the source...anyways good luck with interviews...I am expecting call for interview as my mains went better than last time

Re: @DU

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-09 00:00:25)

The same thought is going on in my mind since pre result. But due to too less ppl qualifying pre this time, exchange of info is less. I know very few candidates who gave mains but all those were those who have taken UPSC mains too, and all are from humble background. Most of those I knew since college and coaching days couldnot clear pre.

I don't know what was the scenario last time.

Though general public's and officers of Haryana govt are of the view that the govt is "trying" to make this recruitment totally fair.

Re: @ paid candidates

Posted by DU, (2016-05-08 22:59:14)


I want to now about any concrete information about any "paid" candidate, that one who you think is not competent and yet is so confidant of being selected or something like one who wish to get into through unfair means. We have seen such candidates last time so there can be this time too.

So we need to take guarded position from the beginning of such people. So I request all to keep eyes and ears open for such info on such people and then share it here.



Posted by qaz, (2016-05-08 21:42:52)

No it won't ... There are vacancies


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-08 16:58:43)

these 23 will eat up the next vacancy in HCS(Ex Br)..if there is any in pipeline.

Re: @rakesh

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-07 17:09:10)

That has nothing to do with the current process

Re: HCS excecutive

Posted by Rakesh, (2016-05-07 14:47:29)

Total 23 person are selected for HCS on 6th May.


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-07 10:02:18)



Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-07 10:00:15)


Re: hcs ki training

Posted by Rishi, (2016-05-07 00:25:09)

Haryana Institute of Public Administration, Gurgaon, Haryana, HIPA, Administration, Public, Institute, Training.

Re: @DU

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-06 23:51:10)

HPPSC releases answer keys after pre exam for which representations are invited. This takes time.
My point is not that mains result will be out in June end only, it might be declared in May itself. Even I , in fact everyone wants early result. But expecting result in a months time from hpsc in impractical and will only create anxiety in case of delayed result.
On this blog itself there used to be guy who sometimes came out with correct infos. Was he nn ? What is his stand regarding this ?

Re: @ appointment letters

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-06 22:55:47)


Please be assured these are not new candidates but these are of 2004 batch who have won case in HC on 27th Feb 2016 for joining the services.

Thus instead of being new these are some where a decade old.

And these won't have any competition with the fresh batch for which most of us gave exams.

Yes at the most now seats of any new notification will surely likely to take hit as these posts are to be reduced from them.


Re: @ qaz

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-06 22:50:18)


I don't think that comparing different commissions can help out in determining the period of result deceleration as if we go by the this yardstick process then this year UPSC mains finished on 24th Dec and result of mains came on 19th Feb and it have around 14k candidates and 9 exams.

And in case of Himachal Pradesh which you have quoted as being more efficient than HPSC, I would like you to note that in same exam following facts are worth mentioning:-

PT Exam date = 07/06/2015

PT result = 24/07/2015

Now compare it 'slow and lethargic' HPSC Pre 2014

Pre date = 03/08/2014

Result = 29/08/2014

Hence these are not proper yardsticks to measure the proper time line for results.




Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-06 22:26:31)

New candidates got appointment letters today for HCS(Executive Branch)

Re: @qaz

Posted by Rakesh, (2016-05-06 18:52:14)

Thank you bro

Re: @rakesh

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-06 18:47:55)

English :
1. Film censorship
2. Pollution
3. Morning shows the day
4. The child is father of man

1. Raajbhasha Hindi ki vartman stithi
2. Soochna pradyogiki aur yuva peedhi
3. Paryavaran pradooshan
4. Hindi cinema dasha aur Disha
5. Shiksha aur samaaj

Any one had to be written in both

Re: @qaz

Posted by Rakesh, (2016-05-06 18:28:18)

What are the topics?

Re: @rakesh

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-06 18:25:06)

There is no separate essay paper in hcs...only essay questions in English and Hindi paper...

Re: Essay Mains Paper @DU @qaz and others

Posted by Rakesh, (2016-05-06 18:09:27)

Can you please share the essay topics in HCS main exam this time please share.

Re: @DU

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-06 17:23:19)


Go through this doc of HPAS mains result.... The press statement says that result was declared in record time...460 odd candidates appeared in mains and result declared in 2 months. And HPPSC is very efficient and professional. Everybody knows how our hpsc is. Considering this, it is unbelievable that this time result will be declared in May.

Re: @DU

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-06 17:14:49)

Thanks for clearing rechecking query...that mean that clause will have no impact on result declaration.... 680 was concrete as confirmed by nn too....regarding geog having 380 candidates, I saw it on the seating arrangement sheet pasted out side dav 8 school. Figure of 320 is derived ( if 826 becomes 688, 380 becomes 320).
And yes Sectt talks are mostly rumours" as I already mentioned.


Posted by nn, (2016-05-06 17:06:37)

Candidates present in mains were 688...
And we can expect an early result as thr are short no of copies to be chkd plus gvn presently active hpsc in all prospectus.

For training it is hipa I.e in Gurgaon.

All the best guys.

Re: Training

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-06 16:53:44)

HCS ki training Kahan hoti h....does anybody know .?

Re: @ qaz

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-06 15:39:11)


I want to ask/highlight following points:-

1. From where does this figure of 320 is achieved, is it an assumption or some concrete info.

2. Please don't pay much attention about the rumours of training of new batch etc as these are just not feasible for any such info from official channel as HCS training is not high key affair for secretariat and nor does it has been ever discussed prior in Sect. in earlier batches.

3. The new batch rumours are been said for over an year now so there is nothing major there. Though it will gain some traction now due to recent pattern change of Pre in HCS.

4. Though agreed work in HPSC is done by manual process majorly but this time we witnessed the new computerisation with online uploading etc. Hence we can see that some sort of outsourcing can be done as seen at center of mains.

5. If we go by your figures then also these are modest figures of 680 even by manual sorting hence not 2-2.5 months as suggested by you.

6. Lastly you might have misinterpreted my "rechecking" as by this i mean that after compiling the merit list for mains there is rechecking done to rule out any error of grading for interview call.

That 'rechecking' mentioned by you is a separate process which begins after one receive his/her mark sheet after mains result (in case one fails in mains)or final result and then one has 15 days to file for this 'rechecking' option which is just re-totaling of entire marks.

Also if you are saying that this July - August is schedule for mains result than I don't agree and if its for final result than still its bit off mark by 2-3 weeks at maximum. I present last year schedule for your consideration:-

24th April Last mains exam 2013

03rd Sept mains result

Interviews from 24th Sept to 19th Oct 2013

19th Oct last interviews

28th Oct final result.

But Total Candidates for mains 3100 approx

Total Candidates for interview 453 approx.


Re: Result

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-06 15:14:36)

Some points of consideration:

-Not more than 680 candidates appeared.
-Highest candidates were from geography ie 380 of whom 320 appeared, hence speed of result depends upon the speed with which geog papers are checked.
-As far as I remember in the brochure it was mentioned that ₹100 will be charged per paper for rechecking/retotaling. It's unclear whether mains result will be compiled post rechecking or before that.
-in HPSC everything is done manually, that takes time. Clerical staff there is toooooooooooooooooooooooo lethargic and inefficient (bidi piyu types)
-In Haryana Sectt Chd rumours are that training of this batch will commence sept onwards and new advt for hcs will be out soon.

In my opinion June mid to July first week is the most probable window

Re: @ result

Posted by DU, (2016-05-06 14:30:09)


There is 50-50 chance of early result of the mains in May itself but it could also equally possible for its extension into later half of June. I don't have any insider information on this though I'm sure no insider can even say it for sure due to very secretiveness surrounding the examination process, but on the basis of public facts and past experience one can bring out certain assumptions and assertions:-

1. Case for early release of result

• the limited number of people in mains, only 750 (assuming at least 75 abstentions) it is quite easy for early results.

• no use of scaling and moderation process which shortens the entire process as it just involves normal compilation and rechecking of result and thus determining the cutoff.

• fixed number of interview calls i.e. three times and hence its a mechanical exercise to pick top 165 candidates (one or two bracketed ones) out of 750 total. Unlike in UPSC where each year there is slight variations in number of people called for interview ranging from 2.3 to 2.7 times each year and hence high level deliberations and flactuations in cut off.

• general promptness displayed by HPSC and the quality papers with contemporary questions set within short period, yes it was short period since they announced the mains tentative schedule in January (at least by HPSC standards), indicates that there are possibilities of quick release of mains result.

• lastly the entire mains process is also in house mechanism since they don't have to invite outside experts as in case of interviews nor there is any pending sanctions from outside authority.

The points against early result:-

• due to several other lined up exams such as Naib T., assistant professor etc the focus and energy of commission may be dissipated at multiple levels, which might lead to little delay on breaucratic levels

• there might be delay in examining process itself due to cautious approach of HPSC to avoid any controversy

• any other angle which we might miss while looking at time schedule.

Thus this is summing up of entire pro and cons of each assertion.

Yes this is though clear that once mains result comes then one a month is for sure enough for final result.



Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 20:51:31)

Wrong information.


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 19:28:03)

yaar.. what is the source. i seriously doubt about result in May.


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 19:07:33)

Mains result probable on 29 May.

Re: @ qaz

Posted by DU, (2016-05-05 14:59:27)


There is no way one could find out about the marking process and that of inequality of marks as unlike UPSC there is no set panel of experts to examine and more there are any standard guidelines. It will be result of individual examiners checking out papers and allocating marks.

Yes that's possible that by second half of this month picture may appear that when result is scheduled and when is interview being started as it involves clerical staff and thus chances of information coming out.

Prior to that all result dates and final results etc are just predictions nothing much.

Also safely it could be presumed that in total only 750 candidates appeared in all papers as there were absentees in each room of the centres.



Posted by Rakesh, (2016-05-05 13:15:54)

ग्रेड C, D परीक्षा पर मोदी सरकार के निर्देश के बावजूद

nपीटीआई, नई दिल्ली : एशिया पैसिफिक के दूसरे देशों के मुकाबले इंडिया के ज्यादातर एंप्लॉयीज वर्किंग कंडीशंस से संतुष्ट हैं। एक स्टडी के मुताबिक, वर्कफोर्स के बड़े हिस्से को उम्मीद है कि अगले 12 महीनों में उन्हें प्रमोशन मिलेगा। देश के चार मेट्रो शहरों के अलग-अलग सेक्टर्स और संस्थान के मिड-सीनियर लेवल के 688 एंप्लॉयीज के रिस्पॉन्स के मुताबिक, 62% एंप्लॉयीज वर्किंग कंडीशंस से संतुष्ट हैं जबकि एशिया पैसिफिक के लिए यह आंकड़ा 54% है। माइकल पेज इंडियाज जॉब कॉन्फिडेंस इंडेक्स के मुताबिक 73% भारतीयों को उम्मीद है कि अगले 12 महीनों में उनकी तरक्की हो जाएगी। बेंगलुरु के 75%, मुंबई के 62% और दिल्ली के 58% एंप्लॉयीज काम के माहौल से संतुष्ट हैं।
भारतीयों को 12 महीनों में प्रमोशन की उम्मीद
दिल्ली और आंध्र प्रदेश ने नहीं रखा अपना मत

ग्रुप सी और डी की नौकरी के सिलेक्शन प्रोसेस में इंटरव्यू को खत्म करने के केंद्र सरकार के फैसले से हरियाणा की बीजेपी सरकार सहमत नहीं है। राज्य ने इसे लागू करने से इनकार कर दिया है। इंटरव्यू खत्म करने के फैसले को पीएम मोदी का अहम फैसला माना जाता है। हरियाणा सरकार का यह मत तब सामने आया जब इस मामले में सभी राज्यों के प्रिंसिपल सेक्रेटरी की एक मीटिंग आयोजित की गई। दूसरी ओर इस मामले पर दिल्ली की केजरीवाल सरकार ने अब तक कोई पहल नहीं की है और ना ही केंद्र को अपने रुख की जानकारी दी।

पीएम नरेंद्र मोदी ने पिछले साल 15 अगस्त को लाल किले से अपने संबोधन में ग्रेड सी और डी की नौकरियों के लिए सिलेक्शन प्रोसेस से इंटरव्यू खत्म करने का ऐलान किया था। इसके बाद इस साल 1 जनवरी से केंद्र ने लगभग सभी परीक्षाओं में इसे लागू किया और राज्यों को भी पहल करने को कहा था। ज्यादातर बीजेपी शासित राज्यों में इसे लागू कर दिया गया है। लेकिन हरियाणा का इस प्रक्रिया से असहमत होना और मध्य प्रदेश में इसके अब तक लागू नहीं होने से पीएम मोदी की कोशिश को झटका लगा है। हरियाणा के अलावा केवल मिजोरम ऐसा राज्य है, जिसने इंटरव्यू को खत्म करने से मना किया है। हरियाणा ने अपने जवाब में कहा, ‘हम इंटरव्यू को पूरी तरह हटाने के पक्ष में नहीं हैं, लेकिन इसके लिए निर्धारित अंक को कम करने की दिशा में पहल कर रहे हैं।’ सूत्रों के अनुसार दिल्ली सहित दूसरे राज्यों से केंद्र सरकार फिर आग्रह करेगी कि सी और डी ग्रेड की नौकरी से इंटरव्यू खत्म किए जाएं।
10 प्रक्रिया में

इन राज्यों ने किया लागू
उत्तर प्रदेश, अरुणाचल प्रदेश, असम, ओडिसा, जम्मू-कश्मीर, मध्य प्रदेश, मणिपुर, सिक्कम, त्रिपुरा।

बिहार, छत्तीसगढ़, गोवा, गुजरात, छत्तीसगढ़, कर्नाटक, केरल, पुडुचेरी, पंजाब, राजस्थान, तमिलनाडु, तेलंगाना, उत्तराखंड, दादर एंड नागर हवेली, दमन।


Posted by qaz, (2016-05-05 11:43:30)

Only thing that can be said about geography is that it was lengthy. Level of questions was similar to last years. But more number of questions meant difficulty in choosing 4 out of 8 ques.

As there is niether scaling nor same marking standards followed in hpsc so it's absurd to talk about scoring / less scoring etc.

Only thing that this blog currently should be concerned with is drawing insider info from hpsc regarding expected result date and interviews, issue of inequitable marking etc.

Re: Geography...

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 11:32:18)

coming to geography.....

how was the paper guys......

to start with:

having 15 markers each as compared to 30 marker:

Can it be seen as an opportunity to award more marks for more number of questions..


it should be seen as an attempt for checker to have more options to cut more marks due to more number of questions..

In short pattern with 15 marker is :

1) more scoring than conventional
2)Less scoring viz 30 markers one....


Posted by qaz, (2016-05-05 11:12:23)

Ya more points addressing the question fetch more marks than one point being explained and linked to current. Pub ad questions were wide, so many dimensions had to be written.

Re: 80 marks

Posted by soulhunter, (2016-05-05 11:10:04)

Yes, i was also given advise to write simple,basic and long answers by some of the aspirants. And I have also heard this 80 marks theory. Basically the evaluators are mostly MDU,KUK type professors who prefer simple answers. I have tried. Lets see how much it works.


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 10:31:24)

hawabazi: zyada samajhdaar banke current se relate karke, examples ye yukta, points me bharpoor, thode points jo checker also didn't know, analytical, innovative answer.



Posted by qaz, (2016-05-05 10:29:20)

Hawabaazi as in ?


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 10:22:45)

With all this,

one thing is also true,

" ye HCS exam hai, zyada hawabaazi se answer likhoge to 80 number milte hai"

It is a notion that is attached with this exam, based on previous attempts and what people say.....

so, mains evaluation is a sort of a gamble....


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 10:12:39)

As far as 73/74 goes:

not only municipal bonds for large M. corporations

but also POOLED FUUNDS for less credit worthy small bodies

Funds (Untied funds based on panchayat matrix, Devolution index, ability to look inwards to generate self fund + protection from embezzlement, propoer accounting etc)

Functions (based on principle of subsidiarity, scales of econmomy, Managerial capability, Historical preferences, Applicability of services etc)

Functionaries( to make official responsible to elected ones + at the same time protect them from intimidation and harassment due to local elite capature)

How to make Gram sabha a genuine Village parliament ( to become discussion centre, discourse centre, conflict resolution centre, in formation centre, social audit agency etc)

Technical/Managerial capacity building of first time illiterate entrants in local governance

Bu domination : friend philosopher guide rather than inspector, ombudsman, corrector

Pol will: Fiscal constraints etc

PPPP model.

Age of City Managers

there are 20 points in this question: but time was just 30 minutes.

so these questions have very high scope to express.....

Re: @DU and others

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 10:02:59)

In reform question, not only CRC FC recent, but as the question demanded, have to brief

ARC-1: Lokpal/Lokayukta, Functional specialization of generalist service in 8 sub categories (BOTH were not accepted due to political apathy and BU resistance)

Similarly Sarkaria C-S relations not accepted

Indrajit committee on State funding never accepted

How executive treat reports of constitutional bodies like UPSC,FC or others like HR commission, PAC etc...

Problems of Admin reforms in INDIA.

ARC-2 is a recent phenomena

Non implementation of reforms is a character of our Elitist structure......

so form of answers will vary to a great extent.. How much the checker will appreciate it, is anybody's guess....


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 09:55:54)

in my class as well out of 22 , 4/5 were absent....

but absentees hardly influence competition.
even if they would have given exam wont make any difference.

real competition will only be in 200 (general)

Re: Attendance

Posted by qaz , (2016-05-05 07:53:10)

Geography 380 candidates
Pun Ad 320
According to seating arrangement chart outside centre.

Can u all share attendance in ur rooms.
In mine it was 5-5-4-4 absent in 4 days


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 06:57:36)

pubAD candidates were close to 480.

Re: @DU

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 06:16:00)

Hey DU ...do you belong to reserved category or general one..?


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-05 03:29:14)

For new vacancies, HCS preliminary test has been set to same as UPSC. Mains will remains same??

Re: Tarak Mehta ka Oolta Chashma

Posted by qaz, (2016-05-05 01:01:30)

Does any body has any idea why Iyer is seeking divorce from Babita despite the fact that he loves her?

Re: @ Pub Ad and NITI

Posted by D.U., (2016-05-04 22:04:40)


Yes it is imperative for getting goods to use these recommendations but please understand that for quoting as recent as 14th FC, Muni Bonds etc one needs to be updating notes on continuous basis as these are more current affairs based stuff and I think most of candidates out there are working ones who don't have that luxury. Moot point is how many out there of total 371 Pub Ad candidates have this level of answers, if majority does, than surely it will be a close call.

Secondly if one has gone through the basic structure of NITI and also its positives as mentioned on its website one can write a decent answer. But its true that if you haven't prepared it then its little bit ambiguous to approach and hence best to avoid.


Re: Fast Track Course for Naib Tehsildar Exam 2016

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-04 21:57:03)


Re: Fast Track Course for Naib Tehsildar Exam 2016

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-04 21:56:08)



Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-04 21:01:52)

regarding NITI aayog.. policy wise a lot is still fluid and govt has not concretized its structure . for ex NDC vs Governing council of NITI aayog is not clearcut. similarly strategic policy integration into national priorities is still not clear. actually i didnt attempted NITI aayog as lots of loose end there .

Re: @DU

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-04 20:57:51)

the pointer that u have mentioned , i am assuming a good candidate must have mentioned these. ARC/FC is a must for pub Ad. and 14th FC rpt is watershed vis a vis PRI/ULB. similarly local bonds/ local ombudsman 3Fs, property reforms etc must be mentioned there ...
there is no doubt that ARC-II/FC were important this time in pub ad paper and if you have mentioned their recos , only then u can expect good marks in pubAD i.e. 110+...

Re: @ pub ad

Posted by DU, (2016-05-04 20:11:48)


I tend to differ from view pt that PUB AD was easier paper and that it's almost same for everyone. Let me illustrate this point:-

1. In section A if you have read ARC 2nd especially 10th report and have good knowledge about factual data of various committees right from Appleby committee to that of 2nd arc then Reforms question was quite scoring as here one could even suggest the reforms in this regard by ARC.

2. Like wise Local Self Govt question has lot of scope to write quality answer about especially if you have gone through the data given by ARC 2nd and 14th FC about devolution of 3Fs and also Devolution Index along with few improvements like Municipal Bonds allowed by Sebi last year.

3. Those who appeared for UPSC last year or this year certainly read about NITI Aayog and it was quite factual for straight answer if one is aware about comparative analysis of both PC and NiTi and if fact it came in UPSC too although in little bit different language.

4. Similarly Minimum Govt question is straight lifted from UPSC 2015 mains and it could fetch good marks with appropriate examples.

Thus those who have read it extensively and could only write relevant answers and if there will be standard checking of this optional as it appeared from standard paper then many will be surprised that Pub Ad scores won't reflect the expectations. As in post 2012 UPSC Pub Ad has shown that now marks are only for a exact answer not like earlier days when any attempt will fetch good marks.

Though it can't be ruled out that my predictions can go haywire and pub ad as a whole score good marks as it last year mainly due to bias that it's knowledge is good for an administrators.



Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-04 19:49:27)

Yeah. agreed paper was easy. scoring will definitely dependent upon the contents since everybody has something to write in these questions. probably ARC-II recos, haryana examples will be helpful in scoring better but still it depends upon how examiner interpret... i believe anything above 110 will be a good score in pubAD.


Posted by soulhunter, (2016-05-04 17:25:51)

The question paper level was definitely better than last time. I hope checking level is also better than last time.

Re: @ soulhunter

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-04 17:11:09)


but there is lot of scope in these question to express...

last time paper was more general. this time as per me Pub Ad paper gave more bandwidth to students to give their views in each question...

so type of answers will vary to a great extent..

only thing is the checker to pay dividend to good points.....


Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2016-05-04 17:08:08)