Oy Naukri

India Jobs. Read. Talk. Share.

Advertisements

Re: Please response to below link so that we can have an idea of cutoff

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 20:23:54)

Dear Friends,
Please response to this short survey so that we can have an idea of the cutoff.

It will not take more than 1 minute.

https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/SHZMGQQ

Thanks!!

Re: revised answer key

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 19:34:37)

will HPSC be publishing revised answer key after considering representation?
how much they have progressed on representations till date? does anyone have clue on that?

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 19:30:26)

the revise cut off was 128-gen 127-bc,114-sc.check dis out
http://www.hpsc.gov.in/Result/Press_Note_HCS_(Percentile).pdf

Re: cut off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 19:16:53)

gen 134
bc-124

Re: what was the cutoff last time?

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 19:15:45)

Does anybody know what was the cutoff last time for Pre-Exam?

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 19:08:53)

then looking at the low turnout ,we can assume almost similar cutoff as the last hcs exam pre or more??wat do u say guyz....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 18:52:12)

if it is so then cut off wont go more than 130 keeping in mind the toughness of gs paper and low student turnout

Re: @AK

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 18:46:42)

exact figure as per this news is 4810 out of 12890.

Re: @AK

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 18:42:49)

In ambala across all the center just above 4000 candidates appeared against the total of around 11500 candidates. This news was published in The Tribune.

check this:
http://www.tribuneindia.com/2014/20140804/haryana.htm#13

under "Low turnout of candidates for HCS exam in Ambala"

Re: @ Result wala bhaiya

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 18:28:12)

bhaiya g result to n aaya. Purane result ki detail jaroor c. hada di

bhaiya g agla muhuroot kab ka h result ka . ye b bata dijiye puch k

Re: @ Result wala bhaiya

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 18:27:11)

bhaiya g result to n aaya. Purane result ki detail jaroor c. hada di

bhaiya g agla muhuroot kab ka h result ka . ye b bata dijiye puch k

Re:

Posted by aks, (2014-08-14 16:48:44)

@ak,
Less candidates appeared in HCS than last time. Exam was held in only 3 districts compared to last time's 6. Also many candidates skipped pre, attendance was low.

Re:

Posted by ak, (2014-08-14 16:05:15)

does anyone know how many candidate appeared in hcs 2014 (aprrox)??was it was more or less then tha last time candidate appeared in same exam???

Re: no of candidate

Posted by ak, (2014-08-14 16:02:35)

hey any one knows how many no of candidates (aprox)appeared in hcs 2014...it was more or less then the last time??

Re: pk

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 14:53:03)

now link is working

Re: @SNEHA

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 14:45:57)

that link is not working since last night

If they were to upload today it will be after 4.30pm

Re: link is not working

Posted by Sneha, (2014-08-14 14:19:53)

result link isnt opening at HPSC site.
may be they are uploading.

Re: @dsp

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 11:41:51)

If result coming today then one must be having a clue of cut off..any idea.

Re: @dsp

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-14 10:26:59)

really.....

is result coming today

Re: @DSP

Posted by DU, (2014-08-13 20:24:35)

I sincerely hope that your news regarding result is true.

I agree with this fact that till now there has been no injunction or direction from court in this regard. So theoretically HPSC can go ahead as I stated in my previous post.

However I pray and expect that HPSC has taken note of all representations abt wrong ans and taken appropriate action in this regard. Otherwise it will lead to plethora of litigation and years of wait.

All the best to u and all others and thx for sharing some useful news

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-13 19:06:30)

which book to refer for pub add and geo optional...

Re: Pub Ad

Posted by DSP, (2014-08-13 18:55:45)

Result likely to be announced tomorrow. Rest, let's see what happens.
HPSC will proceed keeping in backdrop of the fact that no injunction of any kind has been imposed by Honourable High Court. Nonetheless, the whole recruitment process will be subject to Court's judgment.
All the very best.

Re: Pub Ad

Posted by DSP, (2014-08-13 18:53:03)

Result likely to be announced tomorrow. Rest, let's see what happens.
HPSC will proceed keeping in backdrop of the fact that no injunction of any kind has been imposed by Honourable High Court. Nonetheless, the whole recruitment process will be subject to Court's judgment.
All the very best.

Re: hi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-13 15:52:46)

I am not talking in legal term. I want to state about the candidate who says that he studies in Hindi medium up to PG level. Then he must have passed English Paper also(in Graduation) and he can very well understand his subject in English also. In case of candidate from UP or other states we can say as English is an optional subject.

Re: pt result

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-13 15:52:04)

Anyone please share info on pt result.

Re: English core

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-13 15:04:52)

Bhai Saab nobody is going to ask which is core subject in Haryana English or punjabi as it is not matter which is core subject.

It's a case where it is argued that hpsc has gone back on their commitment in notification as in legal terms it was a contract between hpsc and candidates that these r terms of exam and hence u apply accordingly.

However now due to ambiguity of language of that notification it is up to judiciary to decide to whom benefit of doubt to be given to petitioner or to respondent.

Hope I have cleared your doubts in this case......

Re: hi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-13 11:52:45)

In Haryana English is core subject upto Graduation level. So stating that someone is hindi medium student doesn't carry much weight.

Re: Result

Posted by DU, (2014-08-13 11:48:04)

Please share any update about declaration of result of PT by hpsc as it is futile to argue about case here. Only judge knows what he will do and there are arguments both against and for....

So just one thing that is impt is does any one have any bloody clue on hpsc or not ?? If not then it's a request to those who can to find it out .....

Regards

Re: hi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-13 11:25:29)

In Haryana English is core subject upto Graduation level. So stating that someone is hindi medium student doesn't carry much weight.

Re: hmt

Posted by manoj, (2014-08-13 00:09:34)

what can be the cut of for prelims

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 22:34:50)

117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014
Vinay

Re: Result

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 21:45:05)

Anyone having info please tell this when and if HPSC is coming out with result of PT

Bhai Saab aap keh rahe hai to jaroor cancel hoga isn't it?

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 21:39:28)

exam cancel hoga

Re: High Court Decision on 12/08/2014

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 20:35:12)

http://phhc.gov.in:8080/pdf/io/CWP_15565_2014_12_08_2014_INTERIM_ORDER.pdf

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 13:31:11)

anybody please tell when result will come???

Re: corrections

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-12 13:28:30)

Please do take note of following corrections in my previous post which crept into inadvertently by auto correction:-

3rd paragraph
Moreover if they want to make their case stronger then they should declare it as then HPSC can say after two three more dates like this that.....

3rd last paragraph
.....when HPSC prayed against single judge bench decision in double bench and got relief.

And you r welcome

Regards

Re: @DU

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 13:18:21)

thanx for info

Re: Result

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-12 13:16:11)

Hi as far as it goes result deceleration is an admin matter and until unless court prohibits HPSC from declaring it due to subjudice matter it can declare the same.

If u look at precedent as in last time they declared result when it became clear that high court has not stayed that.

So I think they can declare result like last time without any problem. Moreover if they want to make their case stronger then they should declare it as then it can say after two there more dates like this that as whole process is in advance stage cancellation will derail whole recruitment process and jeopardise future of candidates.

Precisely this has been stand taken by hpsc last time when I prayed against single judge bench decision in double bench and got relief.

But this just my personal understanding based on preceding events, how things will turn out will be clear in court only.

Anyone in court room please share

Re: @DU

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 13:01:06)

can HPSC go ahead and declare PT result before verdict of this case

are they allowed to do so??

Re: High court

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-12 12:59:15)

Bullshit by mr ZZ please check the Punjab and Haryana high court site and click on case status with CWP and 15565 of year 2014. There it is clearly mentioned case pending and next date 21 August. The link of daily order is not available so don't know that but it has not been cancelled as otherwise case would have closed by stating that relief granted as prayed to petitioner. What will next date is for?

So don't believe these stupid rumourmongers

Re: hcs 2014 case

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 12:56:34)

Cwp no. 15565 of 2014.. Next hearing on 21/08/2014

Re: Court date

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-12 12:50:47)

Hi friends new date has been given in HCS PT matter on 21st of this month.

No clue of any observation by court.

If it goes like this then it appears that HPSC may have a last laugh as by next date, they may have PT result out and mains process started.

Last time though court quashed PT result but then charges were very severe with no ambiguity like this time. And then too single judge bench took 5-6 months to decide that.

This time matter is not that grave due to ambiguity moreover HPSC has at least been transparent in answer key etc.

Thus far it appears the so called 100% quash and open and shut case is not so open and shut and certain.

Re: SAD News

Posted by ZZ, (2014-08-12 12:50:30)

high court has cancelled the HCS Prelms....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 12:47:01)

where can we see the case in HC listing

Re: Court hearing

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 12:44:57)

Aaj ki hearing to complete ho chuki hai.
It was in court no. 64 (Urgent Case No. 115) instead of Justice Masih, it has heard in court of Justice Jaswant Singh.
Any Update.....

Re: 182.64.52.125

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 11:20:17)

you r so right

last mains LAW subject no one got less dan 110

marking was skewed to such level dat if LAW student attempted only 2 questions out of 5 still he got 120-125 out of 150 (hope u guys r getting the irony)

MAX geography students were literally thrown out of competition in last mains

NOW LAW STUDS ARE INTERPRETING THE LANGUAGE AND WANT CANCELLATION

WHAT A SHAME.......................

Re: @ Law Graduate

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 11:12:02)

I agree with my views of my predecessor in this context.

All Law Graduates if allowed would have had quashed this paper there and then in Examination centre only.

Secondly all these law graduates forget so easily that last HCS mains was heavily in their favour and all other optionals cried like they r doing now. So life is like a full circle.

Anyway apart from this emotional issue let me ask our LAW GRADUATE that where is written that this notification is for PT only, and in which state PCS mains Notification comes out separately???

Notification is always one only which gives scheme of examination and posts etc so it is bloody non sense LAW INTERPRETATION that it was PT Notification

Sorry for being personal but I cant resist, were you sick in the TERM they taught interpretation of statues, because I think u were.

My dear friend please prepare well for Civil Services otherwise legal career is not an option for u...

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 10:47:32)

Ya very true

people will law subject will interpret this only

PT didn't go good for them this time dats y

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 10:32:51)

I am getting 135 total. But as law graduate interpreted the language of advertisement. The notification was for preliminary exam so it applies to prelims. The word bilingual seems to be written or can be interpreted for prelims.

Re: update???

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-12 10:18:09)

any update guys??

abt Court case

PT result

PT cut of?????

Re: Mains

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-11 21:43:41)

Hi

I agree with this point of view that theoretically it is very much possible that they may take Mains with in Sept as there is no statutory requirement of two months as such any where, yes there is need to have sufficient time for those who are working to apply through proper channel.

But in any case as now a days there is online apply for mains like in UPSC and hence HPSC can put a window of 15-20 days for Mains Form and can take mains exam in later half of Sept.

At least theoretically possible, please enlighten us in case i am missing something crucial here.

Regards

Re: expected cut off for prelims

Posted by N, (2014-08-11 19:22:52)

Plz btao expected cut off for sc students .

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-11 18:56:57)

arey...bhai main exam ke liye atleast 2 month notice to hota hi hai...jaise prelim date always 1 month phle announce ki jati h

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-11 18:20:53)

very short notice period for hcs mains... if Hpsc wins the case... very short I said... 10-15 sep se mains ki probability h...

Re: HCS PRE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-11 17:28:58)

Latest info....???

Re: Niab Tehsildar

Posted by pk, (2014-08-11 17:26:03)

Niab Tehsildar ka exam kab hoga....
Aachar shita kab laagegi???
kya aachar sahita se phele hoga....

Re: AUTHENTIC

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-11 14:55:34)

@RE
is it authentic?
share the link where u find this.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-11 12:55:01)

so Govt has replied "THERE IS NO PROVISION OF PT OTHER THAN ENGLISH"

so no cancellation of exam

result may cum within week or a two

Re: Naib tehsi.

Posted by Priya , (2014-08-10 10:26:40)

not yet finalized.

any news about hcs 2014 pt result.......

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-10 09:55:37)

Naib tehsildar ka paper kab hoga....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 23:00:56)

एच सी एस इस लिखित परीक्षा का मामला

August 09, 2014 05:05 PM

पंजाब हरियाणा हाई कोर्ट ने प्रदेश सरकार को 8 अगस्त के लिए नोटिस जारी कर माँगा जवाब ३ अगस्त को हुई थी परीक्षा जनहित याचिका में कहा की पहले कहा गया था की परीक्षा हिंदी इंग्लिश में होगी ,लेकिन प्रशन पत्र केवल इंग्लिश में ही आया।

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 22:52:06)

Re: wrong que im g s

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 22:29:42) /101.215.93.238
In 1877 the entrance age to ICS,..vo 1878 me hua tha,,,que wrong h,,,spectrum pad lo

Re:

Posted by Yakku, (2014-08-08 21:39:37) /117.220.134.216
veer mere court ch case aa ethe benefit of doubt nhi chlda ethe jo written ch hai oh chalda te advertisement ohna de ult hai is da mtlab o case hundred percent harn ge

Re: HPSC will triumph !!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 21:35:41) /27.97.242.153
i think HPSC will win the case, not easy to cancell PT so easily. Remember benefit of doubt will be given to HPSC only ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 20:42:08) /42.104.25.19
Sabhi Optionals ka difficulty level bhi itna different tha.. Geography mein sabke 80-90 aa rahe hai.. History Optional mein 70 lana bhi itna mushkil tha..
Iske khilaf bhi WRIT honi chayiye.. KOi to NORMALISATION formula hona chahiye varna is baar MAINS daine wale 90 % Geography wale honge..
HISTORY, SOCIOLOGY aur doosre Optionals ke saath dhoka ho raha hai

Re: @ Mohit

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 18:45:37) /117.238.192.248
where it is written that in PT there will be a language paper.
Interpretation ka kaam court ka h.
Tum sare pad lo na UPSC k liye ya kisi aur test k liye. Duniya me ek hi test thodi h, jo HPSC k piche haat dho ki pad gaye. Jo court ka decision hoga samne aa jayega. At least serious canditates must not waste their time
Resason to give test of HPSC is only one : Bcz er r born in Haryana
& this is evident from attendance on 3
aug. Only 11,000 students gave test as compared to previous 42,000

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 17:37:26) /202.56.229.34
kitni bhi behas kar lo

jinka score 135- hai unhe pt aur mains dono ke liye lagega

jinke 140+ hai unhe only mains ke liye lagega

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-08 17:25:33) /42.104.24.47
Kitne bahas kar lo
truth is that it was for whole exam procedure i.e. PT and main both

Re: anybody from law please clarify

Posted by आदि, (2014-08-08 17:04:32) /107.167.107.96
the phrase used for preliminary exam's purpose is 'test booklet' and for main exam's purpose is 'Question Paper'....

itni minute interpretations ki jaati hain kya..... if yes then HPSC might save its case...

any lawyer/advocate brother here please throw some light...

Re: logic

Posted by k, (2014-08-08 17:03:03) /223.176.224.223
sir,where it is written for mains only....though prelim cum mains its for both..

Re: Re: LAW

Posted by mohit, (2014-08-08 16:48:03) /117.206.187.245
Note 2: The question paper will be got printed bilingual i.e. Hindi (being regional language) & English except language papers.

Where it is written, is it for Preliminary

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 13:05:46) /42.104.24.73
Plz koi cutoff ka btai. Has Hpsc setup the committee to review answer keys.

Re: @ writ disposed off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:59:43) /202.56.229.34
please don't create rumors

Re: writ disposed off

Posted by haryana, (2014-08-08 12:55:46) /106.201.102.195
hpsc won again !!!

Re: CASE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:33:35) /182.64.165.102
It was posted in Urgent Matters at 104 no. and next date of hearing is given on 12th August
by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH

He is same judge who quashed last HCS pt on August 30th 2012

Re: Case Status as on 06th August

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-08 12:21:02) /182.64.165.102
117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014

Re: @122.161.47.218

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:09:40) /119.226.154.162
is this a confirm news

I request to kindly authenticate it

Re: PIL disposed

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:00:19) /122.161.47.218
Highcourt disposed off the PIL with instructions to hpsc to be more careful in future to avoid any ambiguities in future advertisements. Hpsc can go ahead with the selection process.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-08 11:50:13) /14.139.92.146
Thanks for a cool advice, but up only informing the facts.

Re: JUDICIARY RELATED

Posted by Priya, (2014-08-08 11:45:52) /117.206.190.226
Hello. Does anybody here has any idea as to when wud be Haryana judiciary notification would be coming? Plz reply if u genuinely have some info.Thanks

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 11:35:05) /110.232.253.169
@ESM
bhai tera mujhe mushkil lag raha hai isliye baar baar ye post kar deta hai....
aise logo ka kuch nahi hota...
padhle kuch

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-08 11:28:56) /14.139.92.146
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court on Wednesday issued notice to Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for not conducting the preliminary examination of Haryana Civil Service (HCS) in Hindi medium. The court has taken cognizance of the issue after hearing a petition filed by one Amit Kumar of Mundhal village in Hisar district.

The petitioner has alleged that in its instructions, HPSC had mentioned that the medium of examination for HCS would be Hindi as well as English. He further argued that despite its own instructions, the HPSC conducted the preliminary examination on August 3 in English medium only.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/City/Chandigarh

The petitioner stated that he was also a candidate for the said examination but could not perform well because he had done his studies in Hindi medium, while the examination was in English medium. He has sought directions from the court to set aside the preliminary examination held on August 3.

Re: sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 10:00:00) /59.98.224.91
anybody from sociology????how was the paper?????any predictions of merit????/

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 23:16:58) /42.104.27.91
Mai writ file karuga HC m Ye to English medium valo k sath anyai hai pichla main cancel ho hindi valo ko jayada number deye hai English valo ki % ger rahi hai final selection m
new VERMA committee bane ge haaaaaaaaa.......

By the way what r u getting this time in PT just 4 da speculation of cut off....

Re:

Posted by RT, (2014-08-07 21:09:27) /110.232.254.32
@payal
wats ur total in mains?and marks in interview
howz ur paper this tym?kitne expecting?

Re: ordinary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 20:55:23) /42.104.24.67
I hve written mains in hindi. And i prefer jha n srimali for ancient h.c verma for medevalent n modern manikant notes.

Re: MARKS

Posted by chance, (2014-08-07 20:11:27) /182.64.77.169
GS 58 AND HISTORY 59 CAT. GEN ANY CHANCE...

Re:

Posted by RE, (2014-08-07 20:07:00) /182.64.77.169
HISTORY 59 N GS 58 GN CAT

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 18:34:06) /110.232.253.9
itna sannata kyun hai bhai?

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 16:09:02) /14.139.92.146
http://www.tatkalnews.com/news/43996

पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा
August 07, 2014 02:05 PM
पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा है। एक याचिका पर सुनवाई करते हुए बुधवार को चंडीगढ़ में पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने ये फैसला किया । गौरतलब है कि तीन अगस्त को 54 पदों के लिए एचसीएस की परीक्षा हुई थी। जिसमें अभ्यार्थीयों को प्रश्न-पत्र केवल अंग्रेजी भाषा में मिला था।लेकिन आवेदन पत्र के विज्ञापन में प्रश्न पत्र के दोनों भाषा यानि अंग्रेजी और हिंदी में होने का विकल्प दिया हुआ था। इस मामले में हिसार के अमित ने हाईकोर्ट में याचिका डाली थी और हाईकोर्ट ने याचिका पर फैसला सुनाते हुए हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी कर 8 अगस्त तक जवाब मांगा है।अदालत ने नोटिस में कहा कि है कि एचपीएससी ने भर्ती के लिए दिए गए विज्ञापन के नियमों की अवहेलना की है इसी के चलते क्यों ना परीक्षा रद्द कर दी जाए।

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:59:56) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:58:55) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-07 15:33:57) /14.139.92.146
Dear Big Brothers, why you all worried? Be cool. Result is coming next week.

Re: 2 cr.

Posted by executive in waiting, (2014-08-07 12:35:03) /117.206.176.73
IS baar executive post ka rate 1 hi rahega ya 2 cr. ho jayega . b coz post km h ????????????

Re: MARKS

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:59:08) /110.232.253.137
total 141
SBC

Re: zoology

Posted by Dr. Don, (2014-08-07 11:38:24) /121.245.40.20
Zoology- m getting 77 and written to hpsc about 7 questions . Answers debatable in set C. Avg scor in zoo will b in 70s

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:38:09) /202.56.229.34
nothings gonna happen
no cancellation

Re: hcs

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:31:29) /42.104.24.232
This hcs exam will be scrapped for sure. Concentrate on upsc. Forget abt cut off n result.

Because court always judges the legal view not the common sense view. Hpsc surely caught this time. It's better that process ends here only otherwise it could have been more frustrating if it had happened after result declaration.

Re: likely cut of SBC

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 11:02:27) /223.176.240.20
i scored 125 as per keys of HPSC..is there any chance

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:59:46) /202.56.229.34
are bhai since times immemorial PT English me hi hota hai

Note 2 bhi ye hi keh raha hai except language papers paper will b bilingual

language se PT jab hota hi nahi to ye understood hai ki mains ke liye likha hai

few ass holes will always crib come what may

coz when its time to study they neva study

Re: when pre result is likely to be out

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 10:58:48) /223.176.240.20
pre.ka result kab out ho raha hai....

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:53:42) /42.104.25.153
Are inhoone notice b khud type ni kiya kahi ka copy paste kiya h question papers ki tharah
ye to in ko aab pata chala hoga ki ye to blander ho gaya

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:49:21) /42.104.25.153
It's not like that
language of notice clearly say it's for both PT and main
but cancel of exam will not be useful to any one till back door entry system remain.....

Re: bilingual

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:45:21) /42.104.24.232
In 2011 notification Hpsc has mentioned that pre will be in English only. But in. 2014 notification Hpsc has itself mentioned about bilingual paper.
Providing strong point in favour of writ Filed. upsc also provides for bilingual pre exam.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:30:26) /119.226.154.162
bilingual is and always was for mains not PT

nothing gonna cancel

halwa nahi hai paper me phati aur chale court

Re: zoology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:29:34) /42.104.24.232
Not 2 but 5 questions wrong & 2 debatable.
Bindin protein.
Sterile female.
Brunner in duodenum.
Hepatic portal in all.
Parathormone, were definite wrong answers & role of Diaphragm n glucose from fat debatable.
I hv done many silly mistakes in paper n as of now getting 68.

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:10:47) /42.104.26.236
History 89 geography 80 eng 55 hindi 65 gs 51 ......340
and out
what ur medium of writing hindi or English ..... as I had written exceptionally well I read history from op singh notes he provide research data much higher level than balayan(insight) ..... geography from ensemble and alok ranjan note but still get these while I never write any word in hindi after my 10th but there 65 even to my surprise and eng only 55 but some genuine candidates make out to interview like u so my parents blame me
I even feel that whole marks sheet belong to someone else
but this time being a jat of haryana my category change from general to sbc category may be 1-2mark grace but still my score is too less I fell ..... 128 by this key if corrected than go to 136-138
by the way how much u got in pt this time from this key

Re: Law of Logic

Posted by PK, (2014-08-07 09:56:58) /125.63.73.68
As per HPSC notification all papers will be bilingual except language paper. As there is no language paper in the pre exam so it can be in turn inferred that this particular statement is for mains exam only. What u guys say about this??

Re: exam will be cancelled

Posted by worried, (2014-08-07 09:28:07) /117.214.161.178
what can be done by those who appeared and have a chance of clearing it as it looks like the exam will be cancelled?can we file case for mental harrasment or financial loss due to cost incurred for giving exam?why should serious students suffer the mistake of hpsc?

Re: oridnary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 08:01:59) /42.104.25.145
History 100 hindi lt 116 eng 57 hindi 71 gs 44 total 388 given interview and you

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 01:03:02) /42.104.25.208
How many u got in history main last time

Re: @jago wale bhaiya

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:49:06) /141.0.11.136
bhaiya ji aap jag gae ho to writ file kar do,post kam hai nai to mai bhi karta

Re: jaago bhai hindi vaalo

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:13:15) /101.215.57.232
20.2.14 note 2-saaf saaf likha ,.,,,the question paper willbe got printed bilingual i.e.hindi(being regional lang)and english except lang paper,.,.,therefor apply writs,,,,fight for ur rights,,,when center could do,,,,y not state,,,,,jaago bhai jaago

Re: Psychology

Posted by Psychology representation, (2014-08-06 23:04:12) /125.19.7.99
I hv sent a representation regarding wrong answers in Psychology but haven't got any reply back from HPSC.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:56:02) /141.0.11.179
zoology-70

Re: ZOOLOGY

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:31:43) /117.208.95.29
anybody with zoology optional? how much marks expected in this optional? 2 questions were definitely wrong

Re: time over

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:52:54) /117.197.143.157
time to file representation is gone
ab vaise hi discuss karlo

Re: mech.

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-06 20:51:09) /42.104.24.105
Movmt of cell ----OSMOSIS
osmosis is.....membrane----- ALL STMT wrong

These two also have wrong answers in key

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:04:52) /117.197.143.157
result wd be out before 14 definately.. .

Re: hindi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:24:46) /117.241.32.14
Koi case nahi hai w.r.t. hindi.
Hindi wallo ko angregi bhi to aati hai

Whats the big issue
Paper hindi ke piche tp dubara na hota bahiyo

Re: hcs exam under scanner!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:21:48) /42.104.27.106
न्यायालयों से

एच सी एस इस लिखित परीक्षा का मामला

August 06, 2014 05:05 PM

पंजाब हरियाणा हाई कोर्ट ने प्रदेश सरकार को 8 अगस्त के लिए नोटिस जारी कर माँगा जवाब ३ अगस्त को हुई थी परीक्षा जनहित याचिका में कहा की पहले कहा गया था की परीक्षा हिंदी इंग्लिश में होगी ,लेकिन प्रशन पत्र केवल इंग्लिश में ही आया।

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:58) /180.214.147.191
RIT daal di h kya kisi ne highcourt mein..????

Re: Case

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:19) /117.206.186.102
Please tell the details of the case or any information about what HPSC has replied?

Re: Representation of Errors (Mech Engg)

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:26:12) /117.197.159.234
My Score GS: 52 & Mech: 68
Total: 120 (General Category)

I have represented for the following question, please share any other error except these (esp. in Mech Engg)

Errors in General Studies
Que 1) Encyclopaedia Britannica is useful for ready references
Ans: Micropaedia

Que 2) Alipore Bomb case
Ans: Aurobindo Ghosh

Que 3) Which part of the Indian Constitution provides for establishing Indian as a Welfare State
Ans: Both (Preamble & Directive Principle of State Policy)

Que 4) Seed plant technique
Ans: Paddy

Que 5) The major fungi that affect food-grains in storage
Ans Aspergillus

Errors in Mechanical Engineering
Que 1) If the slenderness ratio for a column is 100, then it is said to be a _____ column?
Ans: medium

Que 2) The maximum diameter of the hole that can be punched from a plate of maximum shear stress 1/4th of its maximum crushing stress of punch, is equal to (where t= thickness of the plate)?
Ans: t

Que 3) When a rectangular beam is loaded transversely, the maximum compressive stress is developed on the
Ans: Both (Top Layer & Bottom layer) depending on direction of transversely applied load whether its upward force or downward force

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:22:12) /49.201.14.34
Arre bhaion kisi ko pta h ye naib tehsildar ka exam kab hoga. Btao bion

Re: PIL in HC...

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:29) /171.78.125.214
click http://tatkalnews.com/

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:22) /119.226.154.162
hpsc ne jawaab de bhi diya hai today evening

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:11:24) /202.56.229.34
kaun sa news channel bhai

Re: hcs 2014 pre case

Posted by hpsc secretary, (2014-08-06 17:09:20) /1.38.16.59
Dosto breaking news... Haryana & Punjabhigh court ne hcs 2014 pre exam Hindi m nahi dene ke liye haryana government se 2 din m jawab manga... Check haryana local news channel..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:34) /202.56.229.34
134 it was

Re: cut off of 2011 prelims

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:05) /117.206.186.102
Please confirm the cutoff of exam held on 25march2013 general category..was it 134 or 143..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:03) /202.56.229.34
scoring 65 or more is too good and u will surely make it.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:05:17) /119.226.154.162
a friend of mine :

scoring 131 told me very few students dis time cut off may be arnd 120-125

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:01:32) /110.232.254.98
mine 142
optional geo-77
gs-65

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:59:40) /119.226.154.162
how much time this committee gonna take

I mean when can the result b expected....

Re: Mechanical Engg

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:57:46) /171.78.125.214
Guys anybody from Mech Engg. here give ur feedback how was optional paper...average or easy ...tell ur score...if any question/answer wrong pls share here...

Re: score

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:56:18) /117.197.159.47
post ur marks idea ho jaega cut off ka.
mine are 138 with present key

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:49:57) /42.104.26.116
Thanks.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:49:10) /42.104.27.252
Only some optional were easy or all.wht abt science subjects. Zoology also had many wrong answers.in 2009 cutoff was 119 & 134 in 2011. This time it Can't be higher than this.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:45:44) /202.56.229.34
from where u got dis figure 11500 candidates

how can it b so low

dat means cut off can be as low as 120

gs was tough.....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:44:08) /202.56.229.34
total 128

any chance
result when???

Re: total candidates

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:42:08) /117.206.186.102
total around 11,500 candidates appeared
Is hpsc sending any confirmation of the mail sent for representation?

Re: email for representation

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:39:10) /117.206.186.102
info.hpsc@gmail.com

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:34:18) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:33:51) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re: cancellation of hcs pre

Posted by hcs aspirant, (2014-08-06 16:33:47) /42.104.25.62
Dear friends:
Main apko batana chahta hoon ki pehli hearing per hi pre exam cancel hoga.Hume apne haq ke liye khud ladna hoga.jab brochure m diya h ki is baar pre Hindi m hoga to hpsc keval English medium m exam kaise le skta h.meri appeal sbhi Hindi medium students se h ki sath Milkar case file kre nhi to hpsc result declare kr degi.

Re: Pub Ad

Posted by RPS, (2014-08-06 15:27:37) /49.249.174.2
Any idea how many candidates appeared in Pre Exam.4811 is the figure for Ambala. What about Panchkula and Chandigarh.
Surprisingly, more than 41,000 appeared in 2012 Pre exam. And this time, it is said too less number of candidates appeared.

Re: law

Posted by law, (2014-08-06 15:22:06) /14.98.129.124
yes i send 2

Re: Representation wrt Law

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:17:29) /122.176.169.71
is anyone sending reprsn wrt Law?

Re: pub add representaion

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:05:17) /117.197.159.47
acc to managerial view of administration :
B should be answer instead of A

Re: Results

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /182.64.129.64
Hello every body does anybody have any idea to when result of PT is expected this time. As in 2009 it came within two days and in 2012 after one and half month.

Supposedly today is last day for submission of wrong Questions and it might take a week by experts to sort out objections.

So can we safely presume that result will come in 6-10 days from now???

ANYBODY HAVING ANY INFO ON THIS PLZ SHARE...

Re: Pub Ad represntation

Posted by spn, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /202.56.222.222
Yes for three questions.
1. Difference between Public and Pvt admin
2. Criticism of Riggs Agraria-Transitia-Industria model
3. 74th constitution amendment act

You also send

Re: PUB ADD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:54:09) /117.197.159.47
any! sending representation in pub add ?? ?
Re:
Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 22:32:22) /117.198.127.115
Re: wrong que im g s

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 22:29:42) /101.215.93.238
In 1877 the entrance age to ICS,..vo 1878 me hua tha,,,que wrong h,,,spectrum pad lo

Re:

Posted by Yakku, (2014-08-08 21:39:37) /117.220.134.216
veer mere court ch case aa ethe benefit of doubt nhi chlda ethe jo written ch hai oh chalda te advertisement ohna de ult hai is da mtlab o case hundred percent harn ge

Re: HPSC will triumph !!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 21:35:41) /27.97.242.153
i think HPSC will win the case, not easy to cancell PT so easily. Remember benefit of doubt will be given to HPSC only ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 20:42:08) /42.104.25.19
Sabhi Optionals ka difficulty level bhi itna different tha.. Geography mein sabke 80-90 aa rahe hai.. History Optional mein 70 lana bhi itna mushkil tha..
Iske khilaf bhi WRIT honi chayiye.. KOi to NORMALISATION formula hona chahiye varna is baar MAINS daine wale 90 % Geography wale honge..
HISTORY, SOCIOLOGY aur doosre Optionals ke saath dhoka ho raha hai

Re: @ Mohit

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 18:45:37) /117.238.192.248
where it is written that in PT there will be a language paper.
Interpretation ka kaam court ka h.
Tum sare pad lo na UPSC k liye ya kisi aur test k liye. Duniya me ek hi test thodi h, jo HPSC k piche haat dho ki pad gaye. Jo court ka decision hoga samne aa jayega. At least serious canditates must not waste their time
Resason to give test of HPSC is only one : Bcz er r born in Haryana
& this is evident from attendance on 3
aug. Only 11,000 students gave test as compared to previous 42,000

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 17:37:26) /202.56.229.34
kitni bhi behas kar lo

jinka score 135- hai unhe pt aur mains dono ke liye lagega

jinke 140+ hai unhe only mains ke liye lagega

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-08 17:25:33) /42.104.24.47
Kitne bahas kar lo
truth is that it was for whole exam procedure i.e. PT and main both

Re: anybody from law please clarify

Posted by आदि, (2014-08-08 17:04:32) /107.167.107.96
the phrase used for preliminary exam's purpose is 'test booklet' and for main exam's purpose is 'Question Paper'....

itni minute interpretations ki jaati hain kya..... if yes then HPSC might save its case...

any lawyer/advocate brother here please throw some light...

Re: logic

Posted by k, (2014-08-08 17:03:03) /223.176.224.223
sir,where it is written for mains only....though prelim cum mains its for both..

Re: Re: LAW

Posted by mohit, (2014-08-08 16:48:03) /117.206.187.245
Note 2: The question paper will be got printed bilingual i.e. Hindi (being regional language) & English except language papers.

Where it is written, is it for Preliminary

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 13:05:46) /42.104.24.73
Plz koi cutoff ka btai. Has Hpsc setup the committee to review answer keys.

Re: @ writ disposed off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:59:43) /202.56.229.34
please don't create rumors

Re: writ disposed off

Posted by haryana, (2014-08-08 12:55:46) /106.201.102.195
hpsc won again !!!

Re: CASE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:33:35) /182.64.165.102
It was posted in Urgent Matters at 104 no. and next date of hearing is given on 12th August
by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH

He is same judge who quashed last HCS pt on August 30th 2012

Re: Case Status as on 06th August

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-08 12:21:02) /182.64.165.102
117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014

Re: @122.161.47.218

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:09:40) /119.226.154.162
is this a confirm news

I request to kindly authenticate it

Re: PIL disposed

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:00:19) /122.161.47.218
Highcourt disposed off the PIL with instructions to hpsc to be more careful in future to avoid any ambiguities in future advertisements. Hpsc can go ahead with the selection process.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-08 11:50:13) /14.139.92.146
Thanks for a cool advice, but up only informing the facts.

Re: JUDICIARY RELATED

Posted by Priya, (2014-08-08 11:45:52) /117.206.190.226
Hello. Does anybody here has any idea as to when wud be Haryana judiciary notification would be coming? Plz reply if u genuinely have some info.Thanks

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 11:35:05) /110.232.253.169
@ESM
bhai tera mujhe mushkil lag raha hai isliye baar baar ye post kar deta hai....
aise logo ka kuch nahi hota...
padhle kuch

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-08 11:28:56) /14.139.92.146
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court on Wednesday issued notice to Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for not conducting the preliminary examination of Haryana Civil Service (HCS) in Hindi medium. The court has taken cognizance of the issue after hearing a petition filed by one Amit Kumar of Mundhal village in Hisar district.

The petitioner has alleged that in its instructions, HPSC had mentioned that the medium of examination for HCS would be Hindi as well as English. He further argued that despite its own instructions, the HPSC conducted the preliminary examination on August 3 in English medium only.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/City/Chandigarh

The petitioner stated that he was also a candidate for the said examination but could not perform well because he had done his studies in Hindi medium, while the examination was in English medium. He has sought directions from the court to set aside the preliminary examination held on August 3.

Re: sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 10:00:00) /59.98.224.91
anybody from sociology????how was the paper?????any predictions of merit????/

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 23:16:58) /42.104.27.91
Mai writ file karuga HC m Ye to English medium valo k sath anyai hai pichla main cancel ho hindi valo ko jayada number deye hai English valo ki % ger rahi hai final selection m
new VERMA committee bane ge haaaaaaaaa.......

By the way what r u getting this time in PT just 4 da speculation of cut off....

Re:

Posted by RT, (2014-08-07 21:09:27) /110.232.254.32
@payal
wats ur total in mains?and marks in interview
howz ur paper this tym?kitne expecting?

Re: ordinary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 20:55:23) /42.104.24.67
I hve written mains in hindi. And i prefer jha n srimali for ancient h.c verma for medevalent n modern manikant notes.

Re: MARKS

Posted by chance, (2014-08-07 20:11:27) /182.64.77.169
GS 58 AND HISTORY 59 CAT. GEN ANY CHANCE...

Re:

Posted by RE, (2014-08-07 20:07:00) /182.64.77.169
HISTORY 59 N GS 58 GN CAT

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 18:34:06) /110.232.253.9
itna sannata kyun hai bhai?

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 16:09:02) /14.139.92.146
http://www.tatkalnews.com/news/43996

पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा
August 07, 2014 02:05 PM
पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा है। एक याचिका पर सुनवाई करते हुए बुधवार को चंडीगढ़ में पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने ये फैसला किया । गौरतलब है कि तीन अगस्त को 54 पदों के लिए एचसीएस की परीक्षा हुई थी। जिसमें अभ्यार्थीयों को प्रश्न-पत्र केवल अंग्रेजी भाषा में मिला था।लेकिन आवेदन पत्र के विज्ञापन में प्रश्न पत्र के दोनों भाषा यानि अंग्रेजी और हिंदी में होने का विकल्प दिया हुआ था। इस मामले में हिसार के अमित ने हाईकोर्ट में याचिका डाली थी और हाईकोर्ट ने याचिका पर फैसला सुनाते हुए हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी कर 8 अगस्त तक जवाब मांगा है।अदालत ने नोटिस में कहा कि है कि एचपीएससी ने भर्ती के लिए दिए गए विज्ञापन के नियमों की अवहेलना की है इसी के चलते क्यों ना परीक्षा रद्द कर दी जाए।

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:59:56) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:58:55) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-07 15:33:57) /14.139.92.146
Dear Big Brothers, why you all worried? Be cool. Result is coming next week.

Re: 2 cr.

Posted by executive in waiting, (2014-08-07 12:35:03) /117.206.176.73
IS baar executive post ka rate 1 hi rahega ya 2 cr. ho jayega . b coz post km h ????????????

Re: MARKS

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:59:08) /110.232.253.137
total 141
SBC

Re: zoology

Posted by Dr. Don, (2014-08-07 11:38:24) /121.245.40.20
Zoology- m getting 77 and written to hpsc about 7 questions . Answers debatable in set C. Avg scor in zoo will b in 70s

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:38:09) /202.56.229.34
nothings gonna happen
no cancellation

Re: hcs

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:31:29) /42.104.24.232
This hcs exam will be scrapped for sure. Concentrate on upsc. Forget abt cut off n result.

Because court always judges the legal view not the common sense view. Hpsc surely caught this time. It's better that process ends here only otherwise it could have been more frustrating if it had happened after result declaration.

Re: likely cut of SBC

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 11:02:27) /223.176.240.20
i scored 125 as per keys of HPSC..is there any chance

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:59:46) /202.56.229.34
are bhai since times immemorial PT English me hi hota hai

Note 2 bhi ye hi keh raha hai except language papers paper will b bilingual

language se PT jab hota hi nahi to ye understood hai ki mains ke liye likha hai

few ass holes will always crib come what may

coz when its time to study they neva study

Re: when pre result is likely to be out

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 10:58:48) /223.176.240.20
pre.ka result kab out ho raha hai....

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:53:42) /42.104.25.153
Are inhoone notice b khud type ni kiya kahi ka copy paste kiya h question papers ki tharah
ye to in ko aab pata chala hoga ki ye to blander ho gaya

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:49:21) /42.104.25.153
It's not like that
language of notice clearly say it's for both PT and main
but cancel of exam will not be useful to any one till back door entry system remain.....

Re: bilingual

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:45:21) /42.104.24.232
In 2011 notification Hpsc has mentioned that pre will be in English only. But in. 2014 notification Hpsc has itself mentioned about bilingual paper.
Providing strong point in favour of writ Filed. upsc also provides for bilingual pre exam.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:30:26) /119.226.154.162
bilingual is and always was for mains not PT

nothing gonna cancel

halwa nahi hai paper me phati aur chale court

Re: zoology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:29:34) /42.104.24.232
Not 2 but 5 questions wrong & 2 debatable.
Bindin protein.
Sterile female.
Brunner in duodenum.
Hepatic portal in all.
Parathormone, were definite wrong answers & role of Diaphragm n glucose from fat debatable.
I hv done many silly mistakes in paper n as of now getting 68.

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:10:47) /42.104.26.236
History 89 geography 80 eng 55 hindi 65 gs 51 ......340
and out
what ur medium of writing hindi or English ..... as I had written exceptionally well I read history from op singh notes he provide research data much higher level than balayan(insight) ..... geography from ensemble and alok ranjan note but still get these while I never write any word in hindi after my 10th but there 65 even to my surprise and eng only 55 but some genuine candidates make out to interview like u so my parents blame me
I even feel that whole marks sheet belong to someone else
but this time being a jat of haryana my category change from general to sbc category may be 1-2mark grace but still my score is too less I fell ..... 128 by this key if corrected than go to 136-138
by the way how much u got in pt this time from this key

Re: Law of Logic

Posted by PK, (2014-08-07 09:56:58) /125.63.73.68
As per HPSC notification all papers will be bilingual except language paper. As there is no language paper in the pre exam so it can be in turn inferred that this particular statement is for mains exam only. What u guys say about this??

Re: exam will be cancelled

Posted by worried, (2014-08-07 09:28:07) /117.214.161.178
what can be done by those who appeared and have a chance of clearing it as it looks like the exam will be cancelled?can we file case for mental harrasment or financial loss due to cost incurred for giving exam?why should serious students suffer the mistake of hpsc?

Re: oridnary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 08:01:59) /42.104.25.145
History 100 hindi lt 116 eng 57 hindi 71 gs 44 total 388 given interview and you

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 01:03:02) /42.104.25.208
How many u got in history main last time

Re: @jago wale bhaiya

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:49:06) /141.0.11.136
bhaiya ji aap jag gae ho to writ file kar do,post kam hai nai to mai bhi karta

Re: jaago bhai hindi vaalo

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:13:15) /101.215.57.232
20.2.14 note 2-saaf saaf likha ,.,,,the question paper willbe got printed bilingual i.e.hindi(being regional lang)and english except lang paper,.,.,therefor apply writs,,,,fight for ur rights,,,when center could do,,,,y not state,,,,,jaago bhai jaago

Re: Psychology

Posted by Psychology representation, (2014-08-06 23:04:12) /125.19.7.99
I hv sent a representation regarding wrong answers in Psychology but haven't got any reply back from HPSC.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:56:02) /141.0.11.179
zoology-70

Re: ZOOLOGY

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:31:43) /117.208.95.29
anybody with zoology optional? how much marks expected in this optional? 2 questions were definitely wrong

Re: time over

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:52:54) /117.197.143.157
time to file representation is gone
ab vaise hi discuss karlo

Re: mech.

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-06 20:51:09) /42.104.24.105
Movmt of cell ----OSMOSIS
osmosis is.....membrane----- ALL STMT wrong

These two also have wrong answers in key

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:04:52) /117.197.143.157
result wd be out before 14 definately.. .

Re: hindi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:24:46) /117.241.32.14
Koi case nahi hai w.r.t. hindi.
Hindi wallo ko angregi bhi to aati hai

Whats the big issue
Paper hindi ke piche tp dubara na hota bahiyo

Re: hcs exam under scanner!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:21:48) /42.104.27.106
न्यायालयों से

एच सी एस इस लिखित परीक्षा का मामला

August 06, 2014 05:05 PM

पंजाब हरियाणा हाई कोर्ट ने प्रदेश सरकार को 8 अगस्त के लिए नोटिस जारी कर माँगा जवाब ३ अगस्त को हुई थी परीक्षा जनहित याचिका में कहा की पहले कहा गया था की परीक्षा हिंदी इंग्लिश में होगी ,लेकिन प्रशन पत्र केवल इंग्लिश में ही आया।

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:58) /180.214.147.191
RIT daal di h kya kisi ne highcourt mein..????

Re: Case

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:19) /117.206.186.102
Please tell the details of the case or any information about what HPSC has replied?

Re: Representation of Errors (Mech Engg)

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:26:12) /117.197.159.234
My Score GS: 52 & Mech: 68
Total: 120 (General Category)

I have represented for the following question, please share any other error except these (esp. in Mech Engg)

Errors in General Studies
Que 1) Encyclopaedia Britannica is useful for ready references
Ans: Micropaedia

Que 2) Alipore Bomb case
Ans: Aurobindo Ghosh

Que 3) Which part of the Indian Constitution provides for establishing Indian as a Welfare State
Ans: Both (Preamble & Directive Principle of State Policy)

Que 4) Seed plant technique
Ans: Paddy

Que 5) The major fungi that affect food-grains in storage
Ans Aspergillus

Errors in Mechanical Engineering
Que 1) If the slenderness ratio for a column is 100, then it is said to be a _____ column?
Ans: medium

Que 2) The maximum diameter of the hole that can be punched from a plate of maximum shear stress 1/4th of its maximum crushing stress of punch, is equal to (where t= thickness of the plate)?
Ans: t

Que 3) When a rectangular beam is loaded transversely, the maximum compressive stress is developed on the
Ans: Both (Top Layer & Bottom layer) depending on direction of transversely applied load whether its upward force or downward force

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:22:12) /49.201.14.34
Arre bhaion kisi ko pta h ye naib tehsildar ka exam kab hoga. Btao bion

Re: PIL in HC...

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:29) /171.78.125.214
click http://tatkalnews.com/

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:22) /119.226.154.162
hpsc ne jawaab de bhi diya hai today evening

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:11:24) /202.56.229.34
kaun sa news channel bhai

Re: hcs 2014 pre case

Posted by hpsc secretary, (2014-08-06 17:09:20) /1.38.16.59
Dosto breaking news... Haryana & Punjabhigh court ne hcs 2014 pre exam Hindi m nahi dene ke liye haryana government se 2 din m jawab manga... Check haryana local news channel..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:34) /202.56.229.34
134 it was

Re: cut off of 2011 prelims

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:05) /117.206.186.102
Please confirm the cutoff of exam held on 25march2013 general category..was it 134 or 143..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:03) /202.56.229.34
scoring 65 or more is too good and u will surely make it.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:05:17) /119.226.154.162
a friend of mine :

scoring 131 told me very few students dis time cut off may be arnd 120-125

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:01:32) /110.232.254.98
mine 142
optional geo-77
gs-65

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:59:40) /119.226.154.162
how much time this committee gonna take

I mean when can the result b expected....

Re: Mechanical Engg

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:57:46) /171.78.125.214
Guys anybody from Mech Engg. here give ur feedback how was optional paper...average or easy ...tell ur score...if any question/answer wrong pls share here...

Re: score

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:56:18) /117.197.159.47
post ur marks idea ho jaega cut off ka.
mine are 138 with present key

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:49:57) /42.104.26.116
Thanks.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:49:10) /42.104.27.252
Only some optional were easy or all.wht abt science subjects. Zoology also had many wrong answers.in 2009 cutoff was 119 & 134 in 2011. This time it Can't be higher than this.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:45:44) /202.56.229.34
from where u got dis figure 11500 candidates

how can it b so low

dat means cut off can be as low as 120

gs was tough.....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:44:08) /202.56.229.34
total 128

any chance
result when???

Re: total candidates

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:42:08) /117.206.186.102
total around 11,500 candidates appeared
Is hpsc sending any confirmation of the mail sent for representation?

Re: email for representation

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:39:10) /117.206.186.102
info.hpsc@gmail.com

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:34:18) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:33:51) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re: cancellation of hcs pre

Posted by hcs aspirant, (2014-08-06 16:33:47) /42.104.25.62
Dear friends:
Main apko batana chahta hoon ki pehli hearing per hi pre exam cancel hoga.Hume apne haq ke liye khud ladna hoga.jab brochure m diya h ki is baar pre Hindi m hoga to hpsc keval English medium m exam kaise le skta h.meri appeal sbhi Hindi medium students se h ki sath Milkar case file kre nhi to hpsc result declare kr degi.

Re: Pub Ad

Posted by RPS, (2014-08-06 15:27:37) /49.249.174.2
Any idea how many candidates appeared in Pre Exam.4811 is the figure for Ambala. What about Panchkula and Chandigarh.
Surprisingly, more than 41,000 appeared in 2012 Pre exam. And this time, it is said too less number of candidates appeared.

Re: law

Posted by law, (2014-08-06 15:22:06) /14.98.129.124
yes i send 2

Re: Representation wrt Law

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:17:29) /122.176.169.71
is anyone sending reprsn wrt Law?

Re: pub add representaion

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:05:17) /117.197.159.47
acc to managerial view of administration :
B should be answer instead of A

Re: Results

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /182.64.129.64
Hello every body does anybody have any idea to when result of PT is expected this time. As in 2009 it came within two days and in 2012 after one and half month.

Supposedly today is last day for submission of wrong Questions and it might take a week by experts to sort out objections.

So can we safely presume that result will come in 6-10 days from now???

ANYBODY HAVING ANY INFO ON THIS PLZ SHARE...

Re: Pub Ad represntation

Posted by spn, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /202.56.222.222
Yes for three questions.
1. Difference between Public and Pvt admin
2. Criticism of Riggs Agraria-Transitia-Industria model
3. 74th constitution amendment act

You also send

Re: PUB ADD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:54:09) /117.197.159.47
any! sending representation in pub add ?? ?
Re:
Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 22:30:32) /117.198.127.115
Re: wrong que im g s

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 22:29:42) /101.215.93.238
In 1877 the entrance age to ICS,..vo 1878 me hua tha,,,que wrong h,,,spectrum pad lo

Re:

Posted by Yakku, (2014-08-08 21:39:37) /117.220.134.216
veer mere court ch case aa ethe benefit of doubt nhi chlda ethe jo written ch hai oh chalda te advertisement ohna de ult hai is da mtlab o case hundred percent harn ge

Re: HPSC will triumph !!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 21:35:41) /27.97.242.153
i think HPSC will win the case, not easy to cancell PT so easily. Remember benefit of doubt will be given to HPSC only ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 20:42:08) /42.104.25.19
Sabhi Optionals ka difficulty level bhi itna different tha.. Geography mein sabke 80-90 aa rahe hai.. History Optional mein 70 lana bhi itna mushkil tha..
Iske khilaf bhi WRIT honi chayiye.. KOi to NORMALISATION formula hona chahiye varna is baar MAINS daine wale 90 % Geography wale honge..
HISTORY, SOCIOLOGY aur doosre Optionals ke saath dhoka ho raha hai

Re: @ Mohit

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 18:45:37) /117.238.192.248
where it is written that in PT there will be a language paper.
Interpretation ka kaam court ka h.
Tum sare pad lo na UPSC k liye ya kisi aur test k liye. Duniya me ek hi test thodi h, jo HPSC k piche haat dho ki pad gaye. Jo court ka decision hoga samne aa jayega. At least serious canditates must not waste their time
Resason to give test of HPSC is only one : Bcz er r born in Haryana
& this is evident from attendance on 3
aug. Only 11,000 students gave test as compared to previous 42,000

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 17:37:26) /202.56.229.34
kitni bhi behas kar lo

jinka score 135- hai unhe pt aur mains dono ke liye lagega

jinke 140+ hai unhe only mains ke liye lagega

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-08 17:25:33) /42.104.24.47
Kitne bahas kar lo
truth is that it was for whole exam procedure i.e. PT and main both

Re: anybody from law please clarify

Posted by आदि, (2014-08-08 17:04:32) /107.167.107.96
the phrase used for preliminary exam's purpose is 'test booklet' and for main exam's purpose is 'Question Paper'....

itni minute interpretations ki jaati hain kya..... if yes then HPSC might save its case...

any lawyer/advocate brother here please throw some light...

Re: logic

Posted by k, (2014-08-08 17:03:03) /223.176.224.223
sir,where it is written for mains only....though prelim cum mains its for both..

Re: Re: LAW

Posted by mohit, (2014-08-08 16:48:03) /117.206.187.245
Note 2: The question paper will be got printed bilingual i.e. Hindi (being regional language) & English except language papers.

Where it is written, is it for Preliminary

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 13:05:46) /42.104.24.73
Plz koi cutoff ka btai. Has Hpsc setup the committee to review answer keys.

Re: @ writ disposed off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:59:43) /202.56.229.34
please don't create rumors

Re: writ disposed off

Posted by haryana, (2014-08-08 12:55:46) /106.201.102.195
hpsc won again !!!

Re: CASE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:33:35) /182.64.165.102
It was posted in Urgent Matters at 104 no. and next date of hearing is given on 12th August
by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH

He is same judge who quashed last HCS pt on August 30th 2012

Re: Case Status as on 06th August

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-08 12:21:02) /182.64.165.102
117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014

Re: @122.161.47.218

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:09:40) /119.226.154.162
is this a confirm news

I request to kindly authenticate it

Re: PIL disposed

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:00:19) /122.161.47.218
Highcourt disposed off the PIL with instructions to hpsc to be more careful in future to avoid any ambiguities in future advertisements. Hpsc can go ahead with the selection process.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-08 11:50:13) /14.139.92.146
Thanks for a cool advice, but up only informing the facts.

Re: JUDICIARY RELATED

Posted by Priya, (2014-08-08 11:45:52) /117.206.190.226
Hello. Does anybody here has any idea as to when wud be Haryana judiciary notification would be coming? Plz reply if u genuinely have some info.Thanks

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 11:35:05) /110.232.253.169
@ESM
bhai tera mujhe mushkil lag raha hai isliye baar baar ye post kar deta hai....
aise logo ka kuch nahi hota...
padhle kuch

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-08 11:28:56) /14.139.92.146
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court on Wednesday issued notice to Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for not conducting the preliminary examination of Haryana Civil Service (HCS) in Hindi medium. The court has taken cognizance of the issue after hearing a petition filed by one Amit Kumar of Mundhal village in Hisar district.

The petitioner has alleged that in its instructions, HPSC had mentioned that the medium of examination for HCS would be Hindi as well as English. He further argued that despite its own instructions, the HPSC conducted the preliminary examination on August 3 in English medium only.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/City/Chandigarh

The petitioner stated that he was also a candidate for the said examination but could not perform well because he had done his studies in Hindi medium, while the examination was in English medium. He has sought directions from the court to set aside the preliminary examination held on August 3.

Re: sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 10:00:00) /59.98.224.91
anybody from sociology????how was the paper?????any predictions of merit????/

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 23:16:58) /42.104.27.91
Mai writ file karuga HC m Ye to English medium valo k sath anyai hai pichla main cancel ho hindi valo ko jayada number deye hai English valo ki % ger rahi hai final selection m
new VERMA committee bane ge haaaaaaaaa.......

By the way what r u getting this time in PT just 4 da speculation of cut off....

Re:

Posted by RT, (2014-08-07 21:09:27) /110.232.254.32
@payal
wats ur total in mains?and marks in interview
howz ur paper this tym?kitne expecting?

Re: ordinary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 20:55:23) /42.104.24.67
I hve written mains in hindi. And i prefer jha n srimali for ancient h.c verma for medevalent n modern manikant notes.

Re: MARKS

Posted by chance, (2014-08-07 20:11:27) /182.64.77.169
GS 58 AND HISTORY 59 CAT. GEN ANY CHANCE...

Re:

Posted by RE, (2014-08-07 20:07:00) /182.64.77.169
HISTORY 59 N GS 58 GN CAT

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 18:34:06) /110.232.253.9
itna sannata kyun hai bhai?

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 16:09:02) /14.139.92.146
http://www.tatkalnews.com/news/43996

पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा
August 07, 2014 02:05 PM
पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा है। एक याचिका पर सुनवाई करते हुए बुधवार को चंडीगढ़ में पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने ये फैसला किया । गौरतलब है कि तीन अगस्त को 54 पदों के लिए एचसीएस की परीक्षा हुई थी। जिसमें अभ्यार्थीयों को प्रश्न-पत्र केवल अंग्रेजी भाषा में मिला था।लेकिन आवेदन पत्र के विज्ञापन में प्रश्न पत्र के दोनों भाषा यानि अंग्रेजी और हिंदी में होने का विकल्प दिया हुआ था। इस मामले में हिसार के अमित ने हाईकोर्ट में याचिका डाली थी और हाईकोर्ट ने याचिका पर फैसला सुनाते हुए हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी कर 8 अगस्त तक जवाब मांगा है।अदालत ने नोटिस में कहा कि है कि एचपीएससी ने भर्ती के लिए दिए गए विज्ञापन के नियमों की अवहेलना की है इसी के चलते क्यों ना परीक्षा रद्द कर

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 22:34:31)

Re: wrong que im g s

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 22:29:42) /101.215.93.238
In 1877 the entrance age to ICS,..vo 1878 me hua tha,,,que wrong h,,,spectrum pad lo

Re:

Posted by Yakku, (2014-08-08 21:39:37) /117.220.134.216
veer mere court ch case aa ethe benefit of doubt nhi chlda ethe jo written ch hai oh chalda te advertisement ohna de ult hai is da mtlab o case hundred percent harn ge

Re: HPSC will triumph !!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 21:35:41) /27.97.242.153
i think HPSC will win the case, not easy to cancell PT so easily. Remember benefit of doubt will be given to HPSC only ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 20:42:08) /42.104.25.19
Sabhi Optionals ka difficulty level bhi itna different tha.. Geography mein sabke 80-90 aa rahe hai.. History Optional mein 70 lana bhi itna mushkil tha..
Iske khilaf bhi WRIT honi chayiye.. KOi to NORMALISATION formula hona chahiye varna is baar MAINS daine wale 90 % Geography wale honge..
HISTORY, SOCIOLOGY aur doosre Optionals ke saath dhoka ho raha hai

Re: @ Mohit

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 18:45:37) /117.238.192.248
where it is written that in PT there will be a language paper.
Interpretation ka kaam court ka h.
Tum sare pad lo na UPSC k liye ya kisi aur test k liye. Duniya me ek hi test thodi h, jo HPSC k piche haat dho ki pad gaye. Jo court ka decision hoga samne aa jayega. At least serious canditates must not waste their time
Resason to give test of HPSC is only one : Bcz er r born in Haryana
& this is evident from attendance on 3
aug. Only 11,000 students gave test as compared to previous 42,000

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 17:37:26) /202.56.229.34
kitni bhi behas kar lo

jinka score 135- hai unhe pt aur mains dono ke liye lagega

jinke 140+ hai unhe only mains ke liye lagega

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-08 17:25:33) /42.104.24.47
Kitne bahas kar lo
truth is that it was for whole exam procedure i.e. PT and main both

Re: anybody from law please clarify

Posted by आदि, (2014-08-08 17:04:32) /107.167.107.96
the phrase used for preliminary exam's purpose is 'test booklet' and for main exam's purpose is 'Question Paper'....

itni minute interpretations ki jaati hain kya..... if yes then HPSC might save its case...

any lawyer/advocate brother here please throw some light...

Re: logic

Posted by k, (2014-08-08 17:03:03) /223.176.224.223
sir,where it is written for mains only....though prelim cum mains its for both..

Re: Re: LAW

Posted by mohit, (2014-08-08 16:48:03) /117.206.187.245
Note 2: The question paper will be got printed bilingual i.e. Hindi (being regional language) & English except language papers.

Where it is written, is it for Preliminary

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 13:05:46) /42.104.24.73
Plz koi cutoff ka btai. Has Hpsc setup the committee to review answer keys.

Re: @ writ disposed off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:59:43) /202.56.229.34
please don't create rumors

Re: writ disposed off

Posted by haryana, (2014-08-08 12:55:46) /106.201.102.195
hpsc won again !!!

Re: CASE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:33:35) /182.64.165.102
It was posted in Urgent Matters at 104 no. and next date of hearing is given on 12th August
by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH

He is same judge who quashed last HCS pt on August 30th 2012

Re: Case Status as on 06th August

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-08 12:21:02) /182.64.165.102
117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014

Re: @122.161.47.218

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:09:40) /119.226.154.162
is this a confirm news

I request to kindly authenticate it

Re: PIL disposed

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:00:19) /122.161.47.218
Highcourt disposed off the PIL with instructions to hpsc to be more careful in future to avoid any ambiguities in future advertisements. Hpsc can go ahead with the selection process.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-08 11:50:13) /14.139.92.146
Thanks for a cool advice, but up only informing the facts.

Re: JUDICIARY RELATED

Posted by Priya, (2014-08-08 11:45:52) /117.206.190.226
Hello. Does anybody here has any idea as to when wud be Haryana judiciary notification would be coming? Plz reply if u genuinely have some info.Thanks

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 11:35:05) /110.232.253.169
@ESM
bhai tera mujhe mushkil lag raha hai isliye baar baar ye post kar deta hai....
aise logo ka kuch nahi hota...
padhle kuch

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-08 11:28:56) /14.139.92.146
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court on Wednesday issued notice to Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for not conducting the preliminary examination of Haryana Civil Service (HCS) in Hindi medium. The court has taken cognizance of the issue after hearing a petition filed by one Amit Kumar of Mundhal village in Hisar district.

The petitioner has alleged that in its instructions, HPSC had mentioned that the medium of examination for HCS would be Hindi as well as English. He further argued that despite its own instructions, the HPSC conducted the preliminary examination on August 3 in English medium only.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/City/Chandigarh

The petitioner stated that he was also a candidate for the said examination but could not perform well because he had done his studies in Hindi medium, while the examination was in English medium. He has sought directions from the court to set aside the preliminary examination held on August 3.

Re: sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 10:00:00) /59.98.224.91
anybody from sociology????how was the paper?????any predictions of merit????/

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 23:16:58) /42.104.27.91
Mai writ file karuga HC m Ye to English medium valo k sath anyai hai pichla main cancel ho hindi valo ko jayada number deye hai English valo ki % ger rahi hai final selection m
new VERMA committee bane ge haaaaaaaaa.......

By the way what r u getting this time in PT just 4 da speculation of cut off....

Re:

Posted by RT, (2014-08-07 21:09:27) /110.232.254.32
@payal
wats ur total in mains?and marks in interview
howz ur paper this tym?kitne expecting?

Re: ordinary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 20:55:23) /42.104.24.67
I hve written mains in hindi. And i prefer jha n srimali for ancient h.c verma for medevalent n modern manikant notes.

Re: MARKS

Posted by chance, (2014-08-07 20:11:27) /182.64.77.169
GS 58 AND HISTORY 59 CAT. GEN ANY CHANCE...

Re:

Posted by RE, (2014-08-07 20:07:00) /182.64.77.169
HISTORY 59 N GS 58 GN CAT

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 18:34:06) /110.232.253.9
itna sannata kyun hai bhai?

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 16:09:02) /14.139.92.146
http://www.tatkalnews.com/news/43996

पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा
August 07, 2014 02:05 PM
पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा है। एक याचिका पर सुनवाई करते हुए बुधवार को चंडीगढ़ में पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने ये फैसला किया । गौरतलब है कि तीन अगस्त को 54 पदों के लिए एचसीएस की परीक्षा हुई थी। जिसमें अभ्यार्थीयों को प्रश्न-पत्र केवल अंग्रेजी भाषा में मिला था।लेकिन आवेदन पत्र के विज्ञापन में प्रश्न पत्र के दोनों भाषा यानि अंग्रेजी और हिंदी में होने का विकल्प दिया हुआ था। इस मामले में हिसार के अमित ने हाईकोर्ट में याचिका डाली थी और हाईकोर्ट ने याचिका पर फैसला सुनाते हुए हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी कर 8 अगस्त तक जवाब मांगा है।अदालत ने नोटिस में कहा कि है कि एचपीएससी ने भर्ती के लिए दिए गए विज्ञापन के नियमों की अवहेलना की है इसी के चलते क्यों ना परीक्षा रद्द कर दी जाए।

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:59:56) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:58:55) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-07 15:33:57) /14.139.92.146
Dear Big Brothers, why you all worried? Be cool. Result is coming next week.

Re: 2 cr.

Posted by executive in waiting, (2014-08-07 12:35:03) /117.206.176.73
IS baar executive post ka rate 1 hi rahega ya 2 cr. ho jayega . b coz post km h ????????????

Re: MARKS

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:59:08) /110.232.253.137
total 141
SBC

Re: zoology

Posted by Dr. Don, (2014-08-07 11:38:24) /121.245.40.20
Zoology- m getting 77 and written to hpsc about 7 questions . Answers debatable in set C. Avg scor in zoo will b in 70s

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:38:09) /202.56.229.34
nothings gonna happen
no cancellation

Re: hcs

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:31:29) /42.104.24.232
This hcs exam will be scrapped for sure. Concentrate on upsc. Forget abt cut off n result.

Because court always judges the legal view not the common sense view. Hpsc surely caught this time. It's better that process ends here only otherwise it could have been more frustrating if it had happened after result declaration.

Re: likely cut of SBC

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 11:02:27) /223.176.240.20
i scored 125 as per keys of HPSC..is there any chance

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:59:46) /202.56.229.34
are bhai since times immemorial PT English me hi hota hai

Note 2 bhi ye hi keh raha hai except language papers paper will b bilingual

language se PT jab hota hi nahi to ye understood hai ki mains ke liye likha hai

few ass holes will always crib come what may

coz when its time to study they neva study

Re: when pre result is likely to be out

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 10:58:48) /223.176.240.20
pre.ka result kab out ho raha hai....

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:53:42) /42.104.25.153
Are inhoone notice b khud type ni kiya kahi ka copy paste kiya h question papers ki tharah
ye to in ko aab pata chala hoga ki ye to blander ho gaya

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:49:21) /42.104.25.153
It's not like that
language of notice clearly say it's for both PT and main
but cancel of exam will not be useful to any one till back door entry system remain.....

Re: bilingual

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:45:21) /42.104.24.232
In 2011 notification Hpsc has mentioned that pre will be in English only. But in. 2014 notification Hpsc has itself mentioned about bilingual paper.
Providing strong point in favour of writ Filed. upsc also provides for bilingual pre exam.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:30:26) /119.226.154.162
bilingual is and always was for mains not PT

nothing gonna cancel

halwa nahi hai paper me phati aur chale court

Re: zoology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:29:34) /42.104.24.232
Not 2 but 5 questions wrong & 2 debatable.
Bindin protein.
Sterile female.
Brunner in duodenum.
Hepatic portal in all.
Parathormone, were definite wrong answers & role of Diaphragm n glucose from fat debatable.
I hv done many silly mistakes in paper n as of now getting 68.

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:10:47) /42.104.26.236
History 89 geography 80 eng 55 hindi 65 gs 51 ......340
and out
what ur medium of writing hindi or English ..... as I had written exceptionally well I read history from op singh notes he provide research data much higher level than balayan(insight) ..... geography from ensemble and alok ranjan note but still get these while I never write any word in hindi after my 10th but there 65 even to my surprise and eng only 55 but some genuine candidates make out to interview like u so my parents blame me
I even feel that whole marks sheet belong to someone else
but this time being a jat of haryana my category change from general to sbc category may be 1-2mark grace but still my score is too less I fell ..... 128 by this key if corrected than go to 136-138
by the way how much u got in pt this time from this key

Re: Law of Logic

Posted by PK, (2014-08-07 09:56:58) /125.63.73.68
As per HPSC notification all papers will be bilingual except language paper. As there is no language paper in the pre exam so it can be in turn inferred that this particular statement is for mains exam only. What u guys say about this??

Re: exam will be cancelled

Posted by worried, (2014-08-07 09:28:07) /117.214.161.178
what can be done by those who appeared and have a chance of clearing it as it looks like the exam will be cancelled?can we file case for mental harrasment or financial loss due to cost incurred for giving exam?why should serious students suffer the mistake of hpsc?

Re: oridnary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 08:01:59) /42.104.25.145
History 100 hindi lt 116 eng 57 hindi 71 gs 44 total 388 given interview and you

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 01:03:02) /42.104.25.208
How many u got in history main last time

Re: @jago wale bhaiya

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:49:06) /141.0.11.136
bhaiya ji aap jag gae ho to writ file kar do,post kam hai nai to mai bhi karta

Re: jaago bhai hindi vaalo

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:13:15) /101.215.57.232
20.2.14 note 2-saaf saaf likha ,.,,,the question paper willbe got printed bilingual i.e.hindi(being regional lang)and english except lang paper,.,.,therefor apply writs,,,,fight for ur rights,,,when center could do,,,,y not state,,,,,jaago bhai jaago

Re: Psychology

Posted by Psychology representation, (2014-08-06 23:04:12) /125.19.7.99
I hv sent a representation regarding wrong answers in Psychology but haven't got any reply back from HPSC.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:56:02) /141.0.11.179
zoology-70

Re: ZOOLOGY

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:31:43) /117.208.95.29
anybody with zoology optional? how much marks expected in this optional? 2 questions were definitely wrong

Re: time over

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:52:54) /117.197.143.157
time to file representation is gone
ab vaise hi discuss karlo

Re: mech.

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-06 20:51:09) /42.104.24.105
Movmt of cell ----OSMOSIS
osmosis is.....membrane----- ALL STMT wrong

These two also have wrong answers in key

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:04:52) /117.197.143.157
result wd be out before 14 definately.. .

Re: hindi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:24:46) /117.241.32.14
Koi case nahi hai w.r.t. hindi.
Hindi wallo ko angregi bhi to aati hai

Whats the big issue
Paper hindi ke piche tp dubara na hota bahiyo

Re: hcs exam under scanner!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:21:48) /42.104.27.106
न्यायालयों से

एच सी एस इस लिखित परीक्षा का मामला

August 06, 2014 05:05 PM

पंजाब हरियाणा हाई कोर्ट ने प्रदेश सरकार को 8 अगस्त के लिए नोटिस जारी कर माँगा जवाब ३ अगस्त को हुई थी परीक्षा जनहित याचिका में कहा की पहले कहा गया था की परीक्षा हिंदी इंग्लिश में होगी ,लेकिन प्रशन पत्र केवल इंग्लिश में ही आया।

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:58) /180.214.147.191
RIT daal di h kya kisi ne highcourt mein..????

Re: Case

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:19) /117.206.186.102
Please tell the details of the case or any information about what HPSC has replied?

Re: Representation of Errors (Mech Engg)

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:26:12) /117.197.159.234
My Score GS: 52 & Mech: 68
Total: 120 (General Category)

I have represented for the following question, please share any other error except these (esp. in Mech Engg)

Errors in General Studies
Que 1) Encyclopaedia Britannica is useful for ready references
Ans: Micropaedia

Que 2) Alipore Bomb case
Ans: Aurobindo Ghosh

Que 3) Which part of the Indian Constitution provides for establishing Indian as a Welfare State
Ans: Both (Preamble & Directive Principle of State Policy)

Que 4) Seed plant technique
Ans: Paddy

Que 5) The major fungi that affect food-grains in storage
Ans Aspergillus

Errors in Mechanical Engineering
Que 1) If the slenderness ratio for a column is 100, then it is said to be a _____ column?
Ans: medium

Que 2) The maximum diameter of the hole that can be punched from a plate of maximum shear stress 1/4th of its maximum crushing stress of punch, is equal to (where t= thickness of the plate)?
Ans: t

Que 3) When a rectangular beam is loaded transversely, the maximum compressive stress is developed on the
Ans: Both (Top Layer & Bottom layer) depending on direction of transversely applied load whether its upward force or downward force

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:22:12) /49.201.14.34
Arre bhaion kisi ko pta h ye naib tehsildar ka exam kab hoga. Btao bion

Re: PIL in HC...

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:29) /171.78.125.214
click http://tatkalnews.com/

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:22) /119.226.154.162
hpsc ne jawaab de bhi diya hai today evening

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:11:24) /202.56.229.34
kaun sa news channel bhai

Re: hcs 2014 pre case

Posted by hpsc secretary, (2014-08-06 17:09:20) /1.38.16.59
Dosto breaking news... Haryana & Punjabhigh court ne hcs 2014 pre exam Hindi m nahi dene ke liye haryana government se 2 din m jawab manga... Check haryana local news channel..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:34) /202.56.229.34
134 it was

Re: cut off of 2011 prelims

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:05) /117.206.186.102
Please confirm the cutoff of exam held on 25march2013 general category..was it 134 or 143..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:03) /202.56.229.34
scoring 65 or more is too good and u will surely make it.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:05:17) /119.226.154.162
a friend of mine :

scoring 131 told me very few students dis time cut off may be arnd 120-125

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:01:32) /110.232.254.98
mine 142
optional geo-77
gs-65

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:59:40) /119.226.154.162
how much time this committee gonna take

I mean when can the result b expected....

Re: Mechanical Engg

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:57:46) /171.78.125.214
Guys anybody from Mech Engg. here give ur feedback how was optional paper...average or easy ...tell ur score...if any question/answer wrong pls share here...

Re: score

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:56:18) /117.197.159.47
post ur marks idea ho jaega cut off ka.
mine are 138 with present key

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:49:57) /42.104.26.116
Thanks.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:49:10) /42.104.27.252
Only some optional were easy or all.wht abt science subjects. Zoology also had many wrong answers.in 2009 cutoff was 119 & 134 in 2011. This time it Can't be higher than this.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:45:44) /202.56.229.34
from where u got dis figure 11500 candidates

how can it b so low

dat means cut off can be as low as 120

gs was tough.....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:44:08) /202.56.229.34
total 128

any chance
result when???

Re: total candidates

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:42:08) /117.206.186.102
total around 11,500 candidates appeared
Is hpsc sending any confirmation of the mail sent for representation?

Re: email for representation

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:39:10) /117.206.186.102
info.hpsc@gmail.com

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:34:18) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:33:51) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re: cancellation of hcs pre

Posted by hcs aspirant, (2014-08-06 16:33:47) /42.104.25.62
Dear friends:
Main apko batana chahta hoon ki pehli hearing per hi pre exam cancel hoga.Hume apne haq ke liye khud ladna hoga.jab brochure m diya h ki is baar pre Hindi m hoga to hpsc keval English medium m exam kaise le skta h.meri appeal sbhi Hindi medium students se h ki sath Milkar case file kre nhi to hpsc result declare kr degi.

Re: Pub Ad

Posted by RPS, (2014-08-06 15:27:37) /49.249.174.2
Any idea how many candidates appeared in Pre Exam.4811 is the figure for Ambala. What about Panchkula and Chandigarh.
Surprisingly, more than 41,000 appeared in 2012 Pre exam. And this time, it is said too less number of candidates appeared.

Re: law

Posted by law, (2014-08-06 15:22:06) /14.98.129.124
yes i send 2

Re: Representation wrt Law

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:17:29) /122.176.169.71
is anyone sending reprsn wrt Law?

Re: pub add representaion

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:05:17) /117.197.159.47
acc to managerial view of administration :
B should be answer instead of A

Re: Results

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /182.64.129.64
Hello every body does anybody have any idea to when result of PT is expected this time. As in 2009 it came within two days and in 2012 after one and half month.

Supposedly today is last day for submission of wrong Questions and it might take a week by experts to sort out objections.

So can we safely presume that result will come in 6-10 days from now???

ANYBODY HAVING ANY INFO ON THIS PLZ SHARE...

Re: Pub Ad represntation

Posted by spn, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /202.56.222.222
Yes for three questions.
1. Difference between Public and Pvt admin
2. Criticism of Riggs Agraria-Transitia-Industria model
3. 74th constitution amendment act

You also send

Re: PUB ADD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:54:09) /117.197.159.47
any! sending representation in pub add ?? ?

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 22:32:22)

Re: wrong que im g s

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 22:29:42) /101.215.93.238
In 1877 the entrance age to ICS,..vo 1878 me hua tha,,,que wrong h,,,spectrum pad lo

Re:

Posted by Yakku, (2014-08-08 21:39:37) /117.220.134.216
veer mere court ch case aa ethe benefit of doubt nhi chlda ethe jo written ch hai oh chalda te advertisement ohna de ult hai is da mtlab o case hundred percent harn ge

Re: HPSC will triumph !!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 21:35:41) /27.97.242.153
i think HPSC will win the case, not easy to cancell PT so easily. Remember benefit of doubt will be given to HPSC only ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 20:42:08) /42.104.25.19
Sabhi Optionals ka difficulty level bhi itna different tha.. Geography mein sabke 80-90 aa rahe hai.. History Optional mein 70 lana bhi itna mushkil tha..
Iske khilaf bhi WRIT honi chayiye.. KOi to NORMALISATION formula hona chahiye varna is baar MAINS daine wale 90 % Geography wale honge..
HISTORY, SOCIOLOGY aur doosre Optionals ke saath dhoka ho raha hai

Re: @ Mohit

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 18:45:37) /117.238.192.248
where it is written that in PT there will be a language paper.
Interpretation ka kaam court ka h.
Tum sare pad lo na UPSC k liye ya kisi aur test k liye. Duniya me ek hi test thodi h, jo HPSC k piche haat dho ki pad gaye. Jo court ka decision hoga samne aa jayega. At least serious canditates must not waste their time
Resason to give test of HPSC is only one : Bcz er r born in Haryana
& this is evident from attendance on 3
aug. Only 11,000 students gave test as compared to previous 42,000

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 17:37:26) /202.56.229.34
kitni bhi behas kar lo

jinka score 135- hai unhe pt aur mains dono ke liye lagega

jinke 140+ hai unhe only mains ke liye lagega

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-08 17:25:33) /42.104.24.47
Kitne bahas kar lo
truth is that it was for whole exam procedure i.e. PT and main both

Re: anybody from law please clarify

Posted by आदि, (2014-08-08 17:04:32) /107.167.107.96
the phrase used for preliminary exam's purpose is 'test booklet' and for main exam's purpose is 'Question Paper'....

itni minute interpretations ki jaati hain kya..... if yes then HPSC might save its case...

any lawyer/advocate brother here please throw some light...

Re: logic

Posted by k, (2014-08-08 17:03:03) /223.176.224.223
sir,where it is written for mains only....though prelim cum mains its for both..

Re: Re: LAW

Posted by mohit, (2014-08-08 16:48:03) /117.206.187.245
Note 2: The question paper will be got printed bilingual i.e. Hindi (being regional language) & English except language papers.

Where it is written, is it for Preliminary

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 13:05:46) /42.104.24.73
Plz koi cutoff ka btai. Has Hpsc setup the committee to review answer keys.

Re: @ writ disposed off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:59:43) /202.56.229.34
please don't create rumors

Re: writ disposed off

Posted by haryana, (2014-08-08 12:55:46) /106.201.102.195
hpsc won again !!!

Re: CASE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:33:35) /182.64.165.102
It was posted in Urgent Matters at 104 no. and next date of hearing is given on 12th August
by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH

He is same judge who quashed last HCS pt on August 30th 2012

Re: Case Status as on 06th August

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-08 12:21:02) /182.64.165.102
117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014

Re: @122.161.47.218

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:09:40) /119.226.154.162
is this a confirm news

I request to kindly authenticate it

Re: PIL disposed

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:00:19) /122.161.47.218
Highcourt disposed off the PIL with instructions to hpsc to be more careful in future to avoid any ambiguities in future advertisements. Hpsc can go ahead with the selection process.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-08 11:50:13) /14.139.92.146
Thanks for a cool advice, but up only informing the facts.

Re: JUDICIARY RELATED

Posted by Priya, (2014-08-08 11:45:52) /117.206.190.226
Hello. Does anybody here has any idea as to when wud be Haryana judiciary notification would be coming? Plz reply if u genuinely have some info.Thanks

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 11:35:05) /110.232.253.169
@ESM
bhai tera mujhe mushkil lag raha hai isliye baar baar ye post kar deta hai....
aise logo ka kuch nahi hota...
padhle kuch

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-08 11:28:56) /14.139.92.146
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court on Wednesday issued notice to Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for not conducting the preliminary examination of Haryana Civil Service (HCS) in Hindi medium. The court has taken cognizance of the issue after hearing a petition filed by one Amit Kumar of Mundhal village in Hisar district.

The petitioner has alleged that in its instructions, HPSC had mentioned that the medium of examination for HCS would be Hindi as well as English. He further argued that despite its own instructions, the HPSC conducted the preliminary examination on August 3 in English medium only.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/City/Chandigarh

The petitioner stated that he was also a candidate for the said examination but could not perform well because he had done his studies in Hindi medium, while the examination was in English medium. He has sought directions from the court to set aside the preliminary examination held on August 3.

Re: sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 10:00:00) /59.98.224.91
anybody from sociology????how was the paper?????any predictions of merit????/

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 23:16:58) /42.104.27.91
Mai writ file karuga HC m Ye to English medium valo k sath anyai hai pichla main cancel ho hindi valo ko jayada number deye hai English valo ki % ger rahi hai final selection m
new VERMA committee bane ge haaaaaaaaa.......

By the way what r u getting this time in PT just 4 da speculation of cut off....

Re:

Posted by RT, (2014-08-07 21:09:27) /110.232.254.32
@payal
wats ur total in mains?and marks in interview
howz ur paper this tym?kitne expecting?

Re: ordinary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 20:55:23) /42.104.24.67
I hve written mains in hindi. And i prefer jha n srimali for ancient h.c verma for medevalent n modern manikant notes.

Re: MARKS

Posted by chance, (2014-08-07 20:11:27) /182.64.77.169
GS 58 AND HISTORY 59 CAT. GEN ANY CHANCE...

Re:

Posted by RE, (2014-08-07 20:07:00) /182.64.77.169
HISTORY 59 N GS 58 GN CAT

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 18:34:06) /110.232.253.9
itna sannata kyun hai bhai?

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 16:09:02) /14.139.92.146
http://www.tatkalnews.com/news/43996

पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा
August 07, 2014 02:05 PM
पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा है। एक याचिका पर सुनवाई करते हुए बुधवार को चंडीगढ़ में पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने ये फैसला किया । गौरतलब है कि तीन अगस्त को 54 पदों के लिए एचसीएस की परीक्षा हुई थी। जिसमें अभ्यार्थीयों को प्रश्न-पत्र केवल अंग्रेजी भाषा में मिला था।लेकिन आवेदन पत्र के विज्ञापन में प्रश्न पत्र के दोनों भाषा यानि अंग्रेजी और हिंदी में होने का विकल्प दिया हुआ था। इस मामले में हिसार के अमित ने हाईकोर्ट में याचिका डाली थी और हाईकोर्ट ने याचिका पर फैसला सुनाते हुए हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी कर 8 अगस्त तक जवाब मांगा है।अदालत ने नोटिस में कहा कि है कि एचपीएससी ने भर्ती के लिए दिए गए विज्ञापन के नियमों की अवहेलना की है इसी के चलते क्यों ना परीक्षा रद्द कर दी जाए।

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:59:56) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:58:55) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-07 15:33:57) /14.139.92.146
Dear Big Brothers, why you all worried? Be cool. Result is coming next week.

Re: 2 cr.

Posted by executive in waiting, (2014-08-07 12:35:03) /117.206.176.73
IS baar executive post ka rate 1 hi rahega ya 2 cr. ho jayega . b coz post km h ????????????

Re: MARKS

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:59:08) /110.232.253.137
total 141
SBC

Re: zoology

Posted by Dr. Don, (2014-08-07 11:38:24) /121.245.40.20
Zoology- m getting 77 and written to hpsc about 7 questions . Answers debatable in set C. Avg scor in zoo will b in 70s

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:38:09) /202.56.229.34
nothings gonna happen
no cancellation

Re: hcs

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:31:29) /42.104.24.232
This hcs exam will be scrapped for sure. Concentrate on upsc. Forget abt cut off n result.

Because court always judges the legal view not the common sense view. Hpsc surely caught this time. It's better that process ends here only otherwise it could have been more frustrating if it had happened after result declaration.

Re: likely cut of SBC

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 11:02:27) /223.176.240.20
i scored 125 as per keys of HPSC..is there any chance

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:59:46) /202.56.229.34
are bhai since times immemorial PT English me hi hota hai

Note 2 bhi ye hi keh raha hai except language papers paper will b bilingual

language se PT jab hota hi nahi to ye understood hai ki mains ke liye likha hai

few ass holes will always crib come what may

coz when its time to study they neva study

Re: when pre result is likely to be out

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 10:58:48) /223.176.240.20
pre.ka result kab out ho raha hai....

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:53:42) /42.104.25.153
Are inhoone notice b khud type ni kiya kahi ka copy paste kiya h question papers ki tharah
ye to in ko aab pata chala hoga ki ye to blander ho gaya

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:49:21) /42.104.25.153
It's not like that
language of notice clearly say it's for both PT and main
but cancel of exam will not be useful to any one till back door entry system remain.....

Re: bilingual

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:45:21) /42.104.24.232
In 2011 notification Hpsc has mentioned that pre will be in English only. But in. 2014 notification Hpsc has itself mentioned about bilingual paper.
Providing strong point in favour of writ Filed. upsc also provides for bilingual pre exam.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:30:26) /119.226.154.162
bilingual is and always was for mains not PT

nothing gonna cancel

halwa nahi hai paper me phati aur chale court

Re: zoology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:29:34) /42.104.24.232
Not 2 but 5 questions wrong & 2 debatable.
Bindin protein.
Sterile female.
Brunner in duodenum.
Hepatic portal in all.
Parathormone, were definite wrong answers & role of Diaphragm n glucose from fat debatable.
I hv done many silly mistakes in paper n as of now getting 68.

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:10:47) /42.104.26.236
History 89 geography 80 eng 55 hindi 65 gs 51 ......340
and out
what ur medium of writing hindi or English ..... as I had written exceptionally well I read history from op singh notes he provide research data much higher level than balayan(insight) ..... geography from ensemble and alok ranjan note but still get these while I never write any word in hindi after my 10th but there 65 even to my surprise and eng only 55 but some genuine candidates make out to interview like u so my parents blame me
I even feel that whole marks sheet belong to someone else
but this time being a jat of haryana my category change from general to sbc category may be 1-2mark grace but still my score is too less I fell ..... 128 by this key if corrected than go to 136-138
by the way how much u got in pt this time from this key

Re: Law of Logic

Posted by PK, (2014-08-07 09:56:58) /125.63.73.68
As per HPSC notification all papers will be bilingual except language paper. As there is no language paper in the pre exam so it can be in turn inferred that this particular statement is for mains exam only. What u guys say about this??

Re: exam will be cancelled

Posted by worried, (2014-08-07 09:28:07) /117.214.161.178
what can be done by those who appeared and have a chance of clearing it as it looks like the exam will be cancelled?can we file case for mental harrasment or financial loss due to cost incurred for giving exam?why should serious students suffer the mistake of hpsc?

Re: oridnary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 08:01:59) /42.104.25.145
History 100 hindi lt 116 eng 57 hindi 71 gs 44 total 388 given interview and you

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 01:03:02) /42.104.25.208
How many u got in history main last time

Re: @jago wale bhaiya

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:49:06) /141.0.11.136
bhaiya ji aap jag gae ho to writ file kar do,post kam hai nai to mai bhi karta

Re: jaago bhai hindi vaalo

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:13:15) /101.215.57.232
20.2.14 note 2-saaf saaf likha ,.,,,the question paper willbe got printed bilingual i.e.hindi(being regional lang)and english except lang paper,.,.,therefor apply writs,,,,fight for ur rights,,,when center could do,,,,y not state,,,,,jaago bhai jaago

Re: Psychology

Posted by Psychology representation, (2014-08-06 23:04:12) /125.19.7.99
I hv sent a representation regarding wrong answers in Psychology but haven't got any reply back from HPSC.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:56:02) /141.0.11.179
zoology-70

Re: ZOOLOGY

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:31:43) /117.208.95.29
anybody with zoology optional? how much marks expected in this optional? 2 questions were definitely wrong

Re: time over

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:52:54) /117.197.143.157
time to file representation is gone
ab vaise hi discuss karlo

Re: mech.

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-06 20:51:09) /42.104.24.105
Movmt of cell ----OSMOSIS
osmosis is.....membrane----- ALL STMT wrong

These two also have wrong answers in key

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:04:52) /117.197.143.157
result wd be out before 14 definately.. .

Re: hindi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:24:46) /117.241.32.14
Koi case nahi hai w.r.t. hindi.
Hindi wallo ko angregi bhi to aati hai

Whats the big issue
Paper hindi ke piche tp dubara na hota bahiyo

Re: hcs exam under scanner!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:21:48) /42.104.27.106
न्यायालयों से

एच सी एस इस लिखित परीक्षा का मामला

August 06, 2014 05:05 PM

पंजाब हरियाणा हाई कोर्ट ने प्रदेश सरकार को 8 अगस्त के लिए नोटिस जारी कर माँगा जवाब ३ अगस्त को हुई थी परीक्षा जनहित याचिका में कहा की पहले कहा गया था की परीक्षा हिंदी इंग्लिश में होगी ,लेकिन प्रशन पत्र केवल इंग्लिश में ही आया।

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:58) /180.214.147.191
RIT daal di h kya kisi ne highcourt mein..????

Re: Case

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:19) /117.206.186.102
Please tell the details of the case or any information about what HPSC has replied?

Re: Representation of Errors (Mech Engg)

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:26:12) /117.197.159.234
My Score GS: 52 & Mech: 68
Total: 120 (General Category)

I have represented for the following question, please share any other error except these (esp. in Mech Engg)

Errors in General Studies
Que 1) Encyclopaedia Britannica is useful for ready references
Ans: Micropaedia

Que 2) Alipore Bomb case
Ans: Aurobindo Ghosh

Que 3) Which part of the Indian Constitution provides for establishing Indian as a Welfare State
Ans: Both (Preamble & Directive Principle of State Policy)

Que 4) Seed plant technique
Ans: Paddy

Que 5) The major fungi that affect food-grains in storage
Ans Aspergillus

Errors in Mechanical Engineering
Que 1) If the slenderness ratio for a column is 100, then it is said to be a _____ column?
Ans: medium

Que 2) The maximum diameter of the hole that can be punched from a plate of maximum shear stress 1/4th of its maximum crushing stress of punch, is equal to (where t= thickness of the plate)?
Ans: t

Que 3) When a rectangular beam is loaded transversely, the maximum compressive stress is developed on the
Ans: Both (Top Layer & Bottom layer) depending on direction of transversely applied load whether its upward force or downward force

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:22:12) /49.201.14.34
Arre bhaion kisi ko pta h ye naib tehsildar ka exam kab hoga. Btao bion

Re: PIL in HC...

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:29) /171.78.125.214
click http://tatkalnews.com/

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:22) /119.226.154.162
hpsc ne jawaab de bhi diya hai today evening

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:11:24) /202.56.229.34
kaun sa news channel bhai

Re: hcs 2014 pre case

Posted by hpsc secretary, (2014-08-06 17:09:20) /1.38.16.59
Dosto breaking news... Haryana & Punjabhigh court ne hcs 2014 pre exam Hindi m nahi dene ke liye haryana government se 2 din m jawab manga... Check haryana local news channel..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:34) /202.56.229.34
134 it was

Re: cut off of 2011 prelims

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:05) /117.206.186.102
Please confirm the cutoff of exam held on 25march2013 general category..was it 134 or 143..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:03) /202.56.229.34
scoring 65 or more is too good and u will surely make it.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:05:17) /119.226.154.162
a friend of mine :

scoring 131 told me very few students dis time cut off may be arnd 120-125

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:01:32) /110.232.254.98
mine 142
optional geo-77
gs-65

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:59:40) /119.226.154.162
how much time this committee gonna take

I mean when can the result b expected....

Re: Mechanical Engg

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:57:46) /171.78.125.214
Guys anybody from Mech Engg. here give ur feedback how was optional paper...average or easy ...tell ur score...if any question/answer wrong pls share here...

Re: score

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:56:18) /117.197.159.47
post ur marks idea ho jaega cut off ka.
mine are 138 with present key

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:49:57) /42.104.26.116
Thanks.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:49:10) /42.104.27.252
Only some optional were easy or all.wht abt science subjects. Zoology also had many wrong answers.in 2009 cutoff was 119 & 134 in 2011. This time it Can't be higher than this.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:45:44) /202.56.229.34
from where u got dis figure 11500 candidates

how can it b so low

dat means cut off can be as low as 120

gs was tough.....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:44:08) /202.56.229.34
total 128

any chance
result when???

Re: total candidates

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:42:08) /117.206.186.102
total around 11,500 candidates appeared
Is hpsc sending any confirmation of the mail sent for representation?

Re: email for representation

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:39:10) /117.206.186.102
info.hpsc@gmail.com

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:34:18) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:33:51) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re: cancellation of hcs pre

Posted by hcs aspirant, (2014-08-06 16:33:47) /42.104.25.62
Dear friends:
Main apko batana chahta hoon ki pehli hearing per hi pre exam cancel hoga.Hume apne haq ke liye khud ladna hoga.jab brochure m diya h ki is baar pre Hindi m hoga to hpsc keval English medium m exam kaise le skta h.meri appeal sbhi Hindi medium students se h ki sath Milkar case file kre nhi to hpsc result declare kr degi.

Re: Pub Ad

Posted by RPS, (2014-08-06 15:27:37) /49.249.174.2
Any idea how many candidates appeared in Pre Exam.4811 is the figure for Ambala. What about Panchkula and Chandigarh.
Surprisingly, more than 41,000 appeared in 2012 Pre exam. And this time, it is said too less number of candidates appeared.

Re: law

Posted by law, (2014-08-06 15:22:06) /14.98.129.124
yes i send 2

Re: Representation wrt Law

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:17:29) /122.176.169.71
is anyone sending reprsn wrt Law?

Re: pub add representaion

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:05:17) /117.197.159.47
acc to managerial view of administration :
B should be answer instead of A

Re: Results

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /182.64.129.64
Hello every body does anybody have any idea to when result of PT is expected this time. As in 2009 it came within two days and in 2012 after one and half month.

Supposedly today is last day for submission of wrong Questions and it might take a week by experts to sort out objections.

So can we safely presume that result will come in 6-10 days from now???

ANYBODY HAVING ANY INFO ON THIS PLZ SHARE...

Re: Pub Ad represntation

Posted by spn, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /202.56.222.222
Yes for three questions.
1. Difference between Public and Pvt admin
2. Criticism of Riggs Agraria-Transitia-Industria model
3. 74th constitution amendment act

You also send

Re: PUB ADD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:54:09) /117.197.159.47
any! sending representation in pub add ?? ?

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 22:30:32)

Re: wrong que im g s

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 22:29:42) /101.215.93.238
In 1877 the entrance age to ICS,..vo 1878 me hua tha,,,que wrong h,,,spectrum pad lo

Re:

Posted by Yakku, (2014-08-08 21:39:37) /117.220.134.216
veer mere court ch case aa ethe benefit of doubt nhi chlda ethe jo written ch hai oh chalda te advertisement ohna de ult hai is da mtlab o case hundred percent harn ge

Re: HPSC will triumph !!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 21:35:41) /27.97.242.153
i think HPSC will win the case, not easy to cancell PT so easily. Remember benefit of doubt will be given to HPSC only ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 20:42:08) /42.104.25.19
Sabhi Optionals ka difficulty level bhi itna different tha.. Geography mein sabke 80-90 aa rahe hai.. History Optional mein 70 lana bhi itna mushkil tha..
Iske khilaf bhi WRIT honi chayiye.. KOi to NORMALISATION formula hona chahiye varna is baar MAINS daine wale 90 % Geography wale honge..
HISTORY, SOCIOLOGY aur doosre Optionals ke saath dhoka ho raha hai

Re: @ Mohit

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 18:45:37) /117.238.192.248
where it is written that in PT there will be a language paper.
Interpretation ka kaam court ka h.
Tum sare pad lo na UPSC k liye ya kisi aur test k liye. Duniya me ek hi test thodi h, jo HPSC k piche haat dho ki pad gaye. Jo court ka decision hoga samne aa jayega. At least serious canditates must not waste their time
Resason to give test of HPSC is only one : Bcz er r born in Haryana
& this is evident from attendance on 3
aug. Only 11,000 students gave test as compared to previous 42,000

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 17:37:26) /202.56.229.34
kitni bhi behas kar lo

jinka score 135- hai unhe pt aur mains dono ke liye lagega

jinke 140+ hai unhe only mains ke liye lagega

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-08 17:25:33) /42.104.24.47
Kitne bahas kar lo
truth is that it was for whole exam procedure i.e. PT and main both

Re: anybody from law please clarify

Posted by आदि, (2014-08-08 17:04:32) /107.167.107.96
the phrase used for preliminary exam's purpose is 'test booklet' and for main exam's purpose is 'Question Paper'....

itni minute interpretations ki jaati hain kya..... if yes then HPSC might save its case...

any lawyer/advocate brother here please throw some light...

Re: logic

Posted by k, (2014-08-08 17:03:03) /223.176.224.223
sir,where it is written for mains only....though prelim cum mains its for both..

Re: Re: LAW

Posted by mohit, (2014-08-08 16:48:03) /117.206.187.245
Note 2: The question paper will be got printed bilingual i.e. Hindi (being regional language) & English except language papers.

Where it is written, is it for Preliminary

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 13:05:46) /42.104.24.73
Plz koi cutoff ka btai. Has Hpsc setup the committee to review answer keys.

Re: @ writ disposed off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:59:43) /202.56.229.34
please don't create rumors

Re: writ disposed off

Posted by haryana, (2014-08-08 12:55:46) /106.201.102.195
hpsc won again !!!

Re: CASE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:33:35) /182.64.165.102
It was posted in Urgent Matters at 104 no. and next date of hearing is given on 12th August
by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH

He is same judge who quashed last HCS pt on August 30th 2012

Re: Case Status as on 06th August

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-08 12:21:02) /182.64.165.102
117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014

Re: @122.161.47.218

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:09:40) /119.226.154.162
is this a confirm news

I request to kindly authenticate it

Re: PIL disposed

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:00:19) /122.161.47.218
Highcourt disposed off the PIL with instructions to hpsc to be more careful in future to avoid any ambiguities in future advertisements. Hpsc can go ahead with the selection process.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-08 11:50:13) /14.139.92.146
Thanks for a cool advice, but up only informing the facts.

Re: JUDICIARY RELATED

Posted by Priya, (2014-08-08 11:45:52) /117.206.190.226
Hello. Does anybody here has any idea as to when wud be Haryana judiciary notification would be coming? Plz reply if u genuinely have some info.Thanks

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 11:35:05) /110.232.253.169
@ESM
bhai tera mujhe mushkil lag raha hai isliye baar baar ye post kar deta hai....
aise logo ka kuch nahi hota...
padhle kuch

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-08 11:28:56) /14.139.92.146
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court on Wednesday issued notice to Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for not conducting the preliminary examination of Haryana Civil Service (HCS) in Hindi medium. The court has taken cognizance of the issue after hearing a petition filed by one Amit Kumar of Mundhal village in Hisar district.

The petitioner has alleged that in its instructions, HPSC had mentioned that the medium of examination for HCS would be Hindi as well as English. He further argued that despite its own instructions, the HPSC conducted the preliminary examination on August 3 in English medium only.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/City/Chandigarh

The petitioner stated that he was also a candidate for the said examination but could not perform well because he had done his studies in Hindi medium, while the examination was in English medium. He has sought directions from the court to set aside the preliminary examination held on August 3.

Re: sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 10:00:00) /59.98.224.91
anybody from sociology????how was the paper?????any predictions of merit????/

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 23:16:58) /42.104.27.91
Mai writ file karuga HC m Ye to English medium valo k sath anyai hai pichla main cancel ho hindi valo ko jayada number deye hai English valo ki % ger rahi hai final selection m
new VERMA committee bane ge haaaaaaaaa.......

By the way what r u getting this time in PT just 4 da speculation of cut off....

Re:

Posted by RT, (2014-08-07 21:09:27) /110.232.254.32
@payal
wats ur total in mains?and marks in interview
howz ur paper this tym?kitne expecting?

Re: ordinary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 20:55:23) /42.104.24.67
I hve written mains in hindi. And i prefer jha n srimali for ancient h.c verma for medevalent n modern manikant notes.

Re: MARKS

Posted by chance, (2014-08-07 20:11:27) /182.64.77.169
GS 58 AND HISTORY 59 CAT. GEN ANY CHANCE...

Re:

Posted by RE, (2014-08-07 20:07:00) /182.64.77.169
HISTORY 59 N GS 58 GN CAT

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 18:34:06) /110.232.253.9
itna sannata kyun hai bhai?

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 16:09:02) /14.139.92.146
http://www.tatkalnews.com/news/43996

पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा
August 07, 2014 02:05 PM
पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने हरियाणा सिविल सेवा की परीक्षा के मामले में हरियाणा सरकार और हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी करते हुए दो दिन के भीतर जवाब मांगा है। एक याचिका पर सुनवाई करते हुए बुधवार को चंडीगढ़ में पंजाब एवं हरियाणा हाईकोर्ट ने ये फैसला किया । गौरतलब है कि तीन अगस्त को 54 पदों के लिए एचसीएस की परीक्षा हुई थी। जिसमें अभ्यार्थीयों को प्रश्न-पत्र केवल अंग्रेजी भाषा में मिला था।लेकिन आवेदन पत्र के विज्ञापन में प्रश्न पत्र के दोनों भाषा यानि अंग्रेजी और हिंदी में होने का विकल्प दिया हुआ था। इस मामले में हिसार के अमित ने हाईकोर्ट में याचिका डाली थी और हाईकोर्ट ने याचिका पर फैसला सुनाते हुए हरियाणा लोक सेवा आयोग को नोटिस जारी कर 8 अगस्त तक जवाब मांगा है।अदालत ने नोटिस में कहा कि है कि एचपीएससी ने भर्ती के लिए दिए गए विज्ञापन के नियमों की अवहेलना की है इसी के चलते क्यों ना परीक्षा रद्द कर दी जाए।

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:59:56) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-07 15:58:55) /14.139.92.146
INDIATODAY.IN NEW DELHI, AUGUST 7, 2014 | UPDATED 14:11 IST
HCS (Ex. Br.) & other Allied Services Preliminary Examination 2014 held on August 3 has been challenged in the Punjab and Haryana High Court on the grounds that the question papers were only printed in English language in violation of the instructions for printing bilingual papers.

The examination conducted by Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) was notified in Februaru, 2014 for 55 posts.

Amit Kumar, a Hisar resident, informed the court he that had been a Hindi medium student up to his postgraduation and was taken by surprise to see that the question papers were set only in English, when the notification clearly mentions that the question paper will be printed bilingually that is Hindi (being regional language) and English except language papers.

Advocate Sajjan Singh Malik, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the HPSC's act was in clear violation of its own advertisement and instructions issued on February 20. Thus the petitioner has suffered irreparable loss as he prepared for the prelims exam in Hindi as was provided in the advertisement, it was submitted.

The petitioner has now sought directions for quashing of the preliminary examination and to stay the further process during the pendency of the petition in the high court.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-07 15:33:57) /14.139.92.146
Dear Big Brothers, why you all worried? Be cool. Result is coming next week.

Re: 2 cr.

Posted by executive in waiting, (2014-08-07 12:35:03) /117.206.176.73
IS baar executive post ka rate 1 hi rahega ya 2 cr. ho jayega . b coz post km h ????????????

Re: MARKS

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:59:08) /110.232.253.137
total 141
SBC

Re: zoology

Posted by Dr. Don, (2014-08-07 11:38:24) /121.245.40.20
Zoology- m getting 77 and written to hpsc about 7 questions . Answers debatable in set C. Avg scor in zoo will b in 70s

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:38:09) /202.56.229.34
nothings gonna happen
no cancellation

Re: hcs

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 11:31:29) /42.104.24.232
This hcs exam will be scrapped for sure. Concentrate on upsc. Forget abt cut off n result.

Because court always judges the legal view not the common sense view. Hpsc surely caught this time. It's better that process ends here only otherwise it could have been more frustrating if it had happened after result declaration.

Re: likely cut of SBC

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 11:02:27) /223.176.240.20
i scored 125 as per keys of HPSC..is there any chance

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:59:46) /202.56.229.34
are bhai since times immemorial PT English me hi hota hai

Note 2 bhi ye hi keh raha hai except language papers paper will b bilingual

language se PT jab hota hi nahi to ye understood hai ki mains ke liye likha hai

few ass holes will always crib come what may

coz when its time to study they neva study

Re: when pre result is likely to be out

Posted by k, (2014-08-07 10:58:48) /223.176.240.20
pre.ka result kab out ho raha hai....

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:53:42) /42.104.25.153
Are inhoone notice b khud type ni kiya kahi ka copy paste kiya h question papers ki tharah
ye to in ko aab pata chala hoga ki ye to blander ho gaya

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:49:21) /42.104.25.153
It's not like that
language of notice clearly say it's for both PT and main
but cancel of exam will not be useful to any one till back door entry system remain.....

Re: bilingual

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:45:21) /42.104.24.232
In 2011 notification Hpsc has mentioned that pre will be in English only. But in. 2014 notification Hpsc has itself mentioned about bilingual paper.
Providing strong point in favour of writ Filed. upsc also provides for bilingual pre exam.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:30:26) /119.226.154.162
bilingual is and always was for mains not PT

nothing gonna cancel

halwa nahi hai paper me phati aur chale court

Re: zoology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-07 10:29:34) /42.104.24.232
Not 2 but 5 questions wrong & 2 debatable.
Bindin protein.
Sterile female.
Brunner in duodenum.
Hepatic portal in all.
Parathormone, were definite wrong answers & role of Diaphragm n glucose from fat debatable.
I hv done many silly mistakes in paper n as of now getting 68.

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 10:10:47) /42.104.26.236
History 89 geography 80 eng 55 hindi 65 gs 51 ......340
and out
what ur medium of writing hindi or English ..... as I had written exceptionally well I read history from op singh notes he provide research data much higher level than balayan(insight) ..... geography from ensemble and alok ranjan note but still get these while I never write any word in hindi after my 10th but there 65 even to my surprise and eng only 55 but some genuine candidates make out to interview like u so my parents blame me
I even feel that whole marks sheet belong to someone else
but this time being a jat of haryana my category change from general to sbc category may be 1-2mark grace but still my score is too less I fell ..... 128 by this key if corrected than go to 136-138
by the way how much u got in pt this time from this key

Re: Law of Logic

Posted by PK, (2014-08-07 09:56:58) /125.63.73.68
As per HPSC notification all papers will be bilingual except language paper. As there is no language paper in the pre exam so it can be in turn inferred that this particular statement is for mains exam only. What u guys say about this??

Re: exam will be cancelled

Posted by worried, (2014-08-07 09:28:07) /117.214.161.178
what can be done by those who appeared and have a chance of clearing it as it looks like the exam will be cancelled?can we file case for mental harrasment or financial loss due to cost incurred for giving exam?why should serious students suffer the mistake of hpsc?

Re: oridnary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 08:01:59) /42.104.25.145
History 100 hindi lt 116 eng 57 hindi 71 gs 44 total 388 given interview and you

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 01:03:02) /42.104.25.208
How many u got in history main last time

Re: @jago wale bhaiya

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:49:06) /141.0.11.136
bhaiya ji aap jag gae ho to writ file kar do,post kam hai nai to mai bhi karta

Re: jaago bhai hindi vaalo

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 23:13:15) /101.215.57.232
20.2.14 note 2-saaf saaf likha ,.,,,the question paper willbe got printed bilingual i.e.hindi(being regional lang)and english except lang paper,.,.,therefor apply writs,,,,fight for ur rights,,,when center could do,,,,y not state,,,,,jaago bhai jaago

Re: Psychology

Posted by Psychology representation, (2014-08-06 23:04:12) /125.19.7.99
I hv sent a representation regarding wrong answers in Psychology but haven't got any reply back from HPSC.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:56:02) /141.0.11.179
zoology-70

Re: ZOOLOGY

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 21:31:43) /117.208.95.29
anybody with zoology optional? how much marks expected in this optional? 2 questions were definitely wrong

Re: time over

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:52:54) /117.197.143.157
time to file representation is gone
ab vaise hi discuss karlo

Re: mech.

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-06 20:51:09) /42.104.24.105
Movmt of cell ----OSMOSIS
osmosis is.....membrane----- ALL STMT wrong

These two also have wrong answers in key

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 20:04:52) /117.197.143.157
result wd be out before 14 definately.. .

Re: hindi

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:24:46) /117.241.32.14
Koi case nahi hai w.r.t. hindi.
Hindi wallo ko angregi bhi to aati hai

Whats the big issue
Paper hindi ke piche tp dubara na hota bahiyo

Re: hcs exam under scanner!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 19:21:48) /42.104.27.106
न्यायालयों से

एच सी एस इस लिखित परीक्षा का मामला

August 06, 2014 05:05 PM

पंजाब हरियाणा हाई कोर्ट ने प्रदेश सरकार को 8 अगस्त के लिए नोटिस जारी कर माँगा जवाब ३ अगस्त को हुई थी परीक्षा जनहित याचिका में कहा की पहले कहा गया था की परीक्षा हिंदी इंग्लिश में होगी ,लेकिन प्रशन पत्र केवल इंग्लिश में ही आया।

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:58) /180.214.147.191
RIT daal di h kya kisi ne highcourt mein..????

Re: Case

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 18:21:19) /117.206.186.102
Please tell the details of the case or any information about what HPSC has replied?

Re: Representation of Errors (Mech Engg)

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:26:12) /117.197.159.234
My Score GS: 52 & Mech: 68
Total: 120 (General Category)

I have represented for the following question, please share any other error except these (esp. in Mech Engg)

Errors in General Studies
Que 1) Encyclopaedia Britannica is useful for ready references
Ans: Micropaedia

Que 2) Alipore Bomb case
Ans: Aurobindo Ghosh

Que 3) Which part of the Indian Constitution provides for establishing Indian as a Welfare State
Ans: Both (Preamble & Directive Principle of State Policy)

Que 4) Seed plant technique
Ans: Paddy

Que 5) The major fungi that affect food-grains in storage
Ans Aspergillus

Errors in Mechanical Engineering
Que 1) If the slenderness ratio for a column is 100, then it is said to be a _____ column?
Ans: medium

Que 2) The maximum diameter of the hole that can be punched from a plate of maximum shear stress 1/4th of its maximum crushing stress of punch, is equal to (where t= thickness of the plate)?
Ans: t

Que 3) When a rectangular beam is loaded transversely, the maximum compressive stress is developed on the
Ans: Both (Top Layer & Bottom layer) depending on direction of transversely applied load whether its upward force or downward force

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:22:12) /49.201.14.34
Arre bhaion kisi ko pta h ye naib tehsildar ka exam kab hoga. Btao bion

Re: PIL in HC...

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:29) /171.78.125.214
click http://tatkalnews.com/

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:19:22) /119.226.154.162
hpsc ne jawaab de bhi diya hai today evening

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:11:24) /202.56.229.34
kaun sa news channel bhai

Re: hcs 2014 pre case

Posted by hpsc secretary, (2014-08-06 17:09:20) /1.38.16.59
Dosto breaking news... Haryana & Punjabhigh court ne hcs 2014 pre exam Hindi m nahi dene ke liye haryana government se 2 din m jawab manga... Check haryana local news channel..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:34) /202.56.229.34
134 it was

Re: cut off of 2011 prelims

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:05) /117.206.186.102
Please confirm the cutoff of exam held on 25march2013 general category..was it 134 or 143..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:06:03) /202.56.229.34
scoring 65 or more is too good and u will surely make it.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:05:17) /119.226.154.162
a friend of mine :

scoring 131 told me very few students dis time cut off may be arnd 120-125

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 17:01:32) /110.232.254.98
mine 142
optional geo-77
gs-65

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:59:40) /119.226.154.162
how much time this committee gonna take

I mean when can the result b expected....

Re: Mechanical Engg

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:57:46) /171.78.125.214
Guys anybody from Mech Engg. here give ur feedback how was optional paper...average or easy ...tell ur score...if any question/answer wrong pls share here...

Re: score

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:56:18) /117.197.159.47
post ur marks idea ho jaega cut off ka.
mine are 138 with present key

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:49:57) /42.104.26.116
Thanks.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:49:10) /42.104.27.252
Only some optional were easy or all.wht abt science subjects. Zoology also had many wrong answers.in 2009 cutoff was 119 & 134 in 2011. This time it Can't be higher than this.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:45:44) /202.56.229.34
from where u got dis figure 11500 candidates

how can it b so low

dat means cut off can be as low as 120

gs was tough.....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:44:08) /202.56.229.34
total 128

any chance
result when???

Re: total candidates

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:42:08) /117.206.186.102
total around 11,500 candidates appeared
Is hpsc sending any confirmation of the mail sent for representation?

Re: email for representation

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 16:39:10) /117.206.186.102
info.hpsc@gmail.com

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:34:18) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re:

Posted by Richa, (2014-08-06 16:33:51) /42.104.26.116
Plzz tell hpsc mail address to send represention...

Re: cancellation of hcs pre

Posted by hcs aspirant, (2014-08-06 16:33:47) /42.104.25.62
Dear friends:
Main apko batana chahta hoon ki pehli hearing per hi pre exam cancel hoga.Hume apne haq ke liye khud ladna hoga.jab brochure m diya h ki is baar pre Hindi m hoga to hpsc keval English medium m exam kaise le skta h.meri appeal sbhi Hindi medium students se h ki sath Milkar case file kre nhi to hpsc result declare kr degi.

Re: Pub Ad

Posted by RPS, (2014-08-06 15:27:37) /49.249.174.2
Any idea how many candidates appeared in Pre Exam.4811 is the figure for Ambala. What about Panchkula and Chandigarh.
Surprisingly, more than 41,000 appeared in 2012 Pre exam. And this time, it is said too less number of candidates appeared.

Re: law

Posted by law, (2014-08-06 15:22:06) /14.98.129.124
yes i send 2

Re: Representation wrt Law

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:17:29) /122.176.169.71
is anyone sending reprsn wrt Law?

Re: pub add representaion

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 15:05:17) /117.197.159.47
acc to managerial view of administration :
B should be answer instead of A

Re: Results

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /182.64.129.64
Hello every body does anybody have any idea to when result of PT is expected this time. As in 2009 it came within two days and in 2012 after one and half month.

Supposedly today is last day for submission of wrong Questions and it might take a week by experts to sort out objections.

So can we safely presume that result will come in 6-10 days from now???

ANYBODY HAVING ANY INFO ON THIS PLZ SHARE...

Re: Pub Ad represntation

Posted by spn, (2014-08-06 14:59:05) /202.56.222.222
Yes for three questions.
1. Difference between Public and Pvt admin
2. Criticism of Riggs Agraria-Transitia-Industria model
3. 74th constitution amendment act

You also send

Re: PUB ADD

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-06 14:54:09) /117.197.159.47
any! sending representation in pub add ?? ?

Re: subject comparison karne walo k liye

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 22:16:40)

GS 79
Pol Sci. 96
Total 175
catagory : GEN
agar tum pad lete to comparison ki jaroorat hi ni padti. Player wo nhi jo easy situation ya weak side k khilaf perform kare. Player wo h jo hard time & strong side k khilaf perform kare. Aur khe ek tu hi nhi h aur b h is dubiya me

Re: GEO

Posted by ANTI GEO, (2014-08-09 20:19:44)

geography se lallu paper kisi ka nahi hoga..

Re: BC

Posted by APPLE, (2014-08-09 20:09:49)

TU TO TOPPER H BAHANCHOD.....
TU TO TOPPER H BAHANCHOD.....
TU TO TOPPER H BAHANCHOD.....
TU TO TOPPER H BAHANCHOD.....

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 18:57:54)

MERA SCORE GEOGRAPHY--------56
GS---------------59

MERA GEOGRAPHY KA SCORE PAPER HARD HONE KI WAJEH SE KAM GAYA.

KYA MERA PT KE CHANCE HE. GENERAL CATEGORY ME PLEASE TELL ME SOMEONE PLEASE.

GEOGRAPHY KA PAPER HARD THA AUR SUBJECTS SE COPARE KARE TO.

HISTORT, SOCIOLOGY, POLITICAL SC., ECONOMICS BAHUT HE EASY THE. INKA SCORE 80-90 KE BICH CHAL RAHA HE..

GEOGRAPHY WALO KA GHAATA HO GAYA. WO SAAB BARBAAD HO GAYE.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 18:38:31)

MERA SCORE GEOGRAPHY--------56
GS---------------59

MERA GEOGRAPHY KA SCORE PAPER HARD HONE KI WAJEH SE KAM GAYA.

KYA MERA PT KE CHANCE HE. GENERAL CATEGORY ME PLEASE TELL ME SOMEONE PLEASE.

GEOGRAPHY KA PAPER HARD THA AUR SUBJECTS SE COPARE KARE TO.

HISTORT, SOCIOLOGY, POLITICAL SC., ECONOMICS BAHUT HE EASY THE. INKA SCORE 80-90 KE BICH CHAL RAHA HE..

GEOGRAPHY WALO KA GHAATA HO GAYA. WO SAAB BARBAAD HO GAYE.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 18:23:39)

Geography ka score sab se kam gaya he.
50-65. Geography ka paper bahut hi hard aya tha.mera score 64 he geography me. aap logogo ka kya he.

History and botany and sociology ka score sab se
high gaya he.Histor---70-90 and Botany----75-90.
Geography walo ke sath bahut hi aanyay hua he.

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 17:58:03)

GEOGRAPHY 54
G S 51
GENERAL
IS THERE ANY CHANCE FOR PT

Re: writ

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-09 09:26:38)

Govt: There is no provision for exam in Hindi. Heating on 12
....................Hindustan times , page 3

Re: wrong que im g s

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 22:29:42)

In 1877 the entrance age to ICS,..vo 1878 me hua tha,,,que wrong h,,,spectrum pad lo

Re:

Posted by Yakku, (2014-08-08 21:39:37)

veer mere court ch case aa ethe benefit of doubt nhi chlda ethe jo written ch hai oh chalda te advertisement ohna de ult hai is da mtlab o case hundred percent harn ge

Re: HPSC will triumph !!

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 21:35:41)

i think HPSC will win the case, not easy to cancell PT so easily. Remember benefit of doubt will be given to HPSC only ..

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 20:42:08)

Sabhi Optionals ka difficulty level bhi itna different tha.. Geography mein sabke 80-90 aa rahe hai.. History Optional mein 70 lana bhi itna mushkil tha..
Iske khilaf bhi WRIT honi chayiye.. KOi to NORMALISATION formula hona chahiye varna is baar MAINS daine wale 90 % Geography wale honge..
HISTORY, SOCIOLOGY aur doosre Optionals ke saath dhoka ho raha hai

Re: @ Mohit

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 18:45:37)

where it is written that in PT there will be a language paper.
Interpretation ka kaam court ka h.
Tum sare pad lo na UPSC k liye ya kisi aur test k liye. Duniya me ek hi test thodi h, jo HPSC k piche haat dho ki pad gaye. Jo court ka decision hoga samne aa jayega. At least serious canditates must not waste their time
Resason to give test of HPSC is only one : Bcz er r born in Haryana
& this is evident from attendance on 3
aug. Only 11,000 students gave test as compared to previous 42,000

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 17:37:26)

kitni bhi behas kar lo

jinka score 135- hai unhe pt aur mains dono ke liye lagega

jinke 140+ hai unhe only mains ke liye lagega

Re:

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-08 17:25:33)

Kitne bahas kar lo
truth is that it was for whole exam procedure i.e. PT and main both

Re: anybody from law please clarify

Posted by आदि, (2014-08-08 17:04:32)

the phrase used for preliminary exam's purpose is 'test booklet' and for main exam's purpose is 'Question Paper'....

itni minute interpretations ki jaati hain kya..... if yes then HPSC might save its case...

any lawyer/advocate brother here please throw some light...

Re: logic

Posted by k, (2014-08-08 17:03:03)

sir,where it is written for mains only....though prelim cum mains its for both..

Re: Re: LAW

Posted by mohit, (2014-08-08 16:48:03)

Note 2: The question paper will be got printed bilingual i.e. Hindi (being regional language) & English except language papers.

Where it is written, is it for Preliminary

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 13:05:46)

Plz koi cutoff ka btai. Has Hpsc setup the committee to review answer keys.

Re: @ writ disposed off

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:59:43)

please don't create rumors

Re: writ disposed off

Posted by haryana, (2014-08-08 12:55:46)

hpsc won again !!!

Re: CASE

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:33:35)

It was posted in Urgent Matters at 104 no. and next date of hearing is given on 12th August
by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH

He is same judge who quashed last HCS pt on August 30th 2012

Re: Case Status as on 06th August

Posted by D.U., (2014-08-08 12:21:02)

117
CWP No.15565 of 2014
Amit Kumar Vs. State of Haryana & Anr.
Present:- Mr. Sajjan Singh Malik, Advocate for the Petitioner.
***
Petitioner is stated to have been a Hindi Medium student upto
his Graduation and Post Graduation(in Geography). He applied for
undertaking the HCS(Executive Branch & Allied Services) Examination
2014 conducted on 3.8.2014 by choosing Geography as one of the optional
subjects.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the note (ii) to para
no.8 of the Instructions attached to the advertisement, it was clearly
postulated that the preliminary examination paper will be got printed
bilingually i.e. Hindi and English except in language papers, however, at
the time of the test it was found that the said optional paper of Geography
and General Studies was printed only in English to the prejudice of the
Hindi medium candidates like the petitioner apart from violating the term
and condition of the advertisement.
Notice of motion for 8.8.2014.
On the asking of the Court Mr. Kanwal Goyal, Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of respondent no.2 and prays for time to seek
instructions.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner undertakes to supply two
copies of writ petition to the learned Counsel for respondent no.2 during the
course of the day.
( JASWANT SINGH )
JUDGE
August 06, 2014

Re: @122.161.47.218

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:09:40)

is this a confirm news

I request to kindly authenticate it

Re: PIL disposed

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 12:00:19)

Highcourt disposed off the PIL with instructions to hpsc to be more careful in future to avoid any ambiguities in future advertisements. Hpsc can go ahead with the selection process.

Re: LAW

Posted by LAW, (2014-08-08 11:50:13)

Thanks for a cool advice, but up only informing the facts.

Re: JUDICIARY RELATED

Posted by Priya, (2014-08-08 11:45:52)

Hello. Does anybody here has any idea as to when wud be Haryana judiciary notification would be coming? Plz reply if u genuinely have some info.Thanks

Re:

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 11:35:05)

@ESM
bhai tera mujhe mushkil lag raha hai isliye baar baar ye post kar deta hai....
aise logo ka kuch nahi hota...
padhle kuch

Re: LAW

Posted by ESM, (2014-08-08 11:28:56)

CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court on Wednesday issued notice to Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for not conducting the preliminary examination of Haryana Civil Service (HCS) in Hindi medium. The court has taken cognizance of the issue after hearing a petition filed by one Amit Kumar of Mundhal village in Hisar district.

The petitioner has alleged that in its instructions, HPSC had mentioned that the medium of examination for HCS would be Hindi as well as English. He further argued that despite its own instructions, the HPSC conducted the preliminary examination on August 3 in English medium only.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/City/Chandigarh

The petitioner stated that he was also a candidate for the said examination but could not perform well because he had done his studies in Hindi medium, while the examination was in English medium. He has sought directions from the court to set aside the preliminary examination held on August 3.

Re: sociology

Posted by Anonymous Guest, (2014-08-08 10:00:00)

anybody from sociology????how was the paper?????any predictions of merit????/

Re: payal

Posted by ordinary mortal, (2014-08-07 23:16:58)

Mai writ file karuga HC m Ye to English medium valo k sath anyai hai pichla main cancel ho hindi valo ko jayada number deye hai English valo ki % ger rahi hai final selection m
new VERMA committee bane ge haaaaaaaaa.......

By the way what r u getting this time in PT just 4 da speculation of cut off....

Re:

Posted by RT, (2014-08-07 21:09:27)

@payal
wats ur total in mains?and marks in interview
howz ur paper this tym?kitne expecting?

Re: ordinary mortal

Posted by payal, (2014-08-07 20:55:23)

I hve written mains in hindi. And i prefer jha n srimali for ancient h.c verma for medevalent n modern manikant notes.

Re: MARKS

Posted by chance, (2014-08-07 20:11:27)

GS 58 AND HISTORY 59 CAT. GEN ANY CHANCE...

Re:

Posted by RE, (2014-08-07 20:07:00)

HISTORY 59 N GS 58 GN CAT